Return to the Home Decorating & Design Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

Posted by missymoo12 (My Page) on
Tue, Jul 29, 14 at 15:02

I posted in kitchens, but you guys were very helpful with my vanity dilemma so I'd like to put the kitchen out to the crowd.
This is a long drawn out project and I am over the "fun" of it all. Kitchen has lots of windows to south and west so all colors just look sucked of life. I finally painted the ceiling BM Simply White like the cabs and the walls the same medium gray as the DR. Everyone who has seen it IRL says its good.
Problem is I have gray tile. It's new construction so please it is staying.
So I had planned Soapstone counters but the $ on that are about twice anything else and now I am rethinking dark counters.
My choices are:
Soapstone -dark blue green hard variety.
Steel gray granite- lowest cost can be honed, polished or leathered. This is DH and DD choice they don't know cost issues
Quartzite - I have yet to find a variety at any yard that doesn't stain or etch.
Not going to contemplate marble.
So would you get a dark counter here? Or repaint walls this is the fourth time
Tried three other shades of white...
Or keep as is and get a light countertop.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

What is the stone in the middle? Am I not understanding?


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

Even though I'm not a granite fan due to the high reflective quality, I recently saw the leather look granite and I love it. It was also in gray. I think two members of your family are spot on in their opinions.


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

White Vermont Quarzite then
leathered steel gray,
smaller piece is Steel Gray but polished.
Do you think it's too much gray?
I have fiesta dishes and lots of colorful views outside from windows.
The grey looks good with what's outside...


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

Here's a pic from farther back.


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

I like both the Vermont Quartzite or the leathered steel gray. I think either would look great.

For me, I would choose the Vermont Quartzite because I have long wanted honed Carrara marble in my kitchen. One day...


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

I would go with either of the darker two. They provide nice contrast with both your cabinets and the walls. I think either would look great!


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

Thanks for the opinions everyone. I'm leaning to the leathered/honed steel gray. It's bulletproof as far as my testing goes and the least expensive.
Going tomorrow to see some slabs.
If the White quartzite was etch proof I might be swayed to go to a higher price.


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

I'd go with the Soapstone if it does not drive you into the poorhouse. Next would be the leathered steel gray. A dark shiny countertop is kind of a pain to keep looking nice. I know because I have dark, shiny granite counters.


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

My first choice would be the white Vermont quartzite, but they are both very. Nice.
I just happen to like lighter counters


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

I like the quartzite.


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

Have you looked at pictures of white kitchens with dark vs. light countertops? That might help you determine the feel you and your family would prefer.


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

Another DD opinion she helped me hoist a big piece of cararra that
I retrieved from a dumpster and has been leaning out side against
The barn for about a year
I had tested out all kinds of staining, etching stuff on it and of course
It stained and etched.
So we look at it today and she says "mom it's the marble, it's what belongs in
The house"
Funny we saw no stains and had to bend down and study it to see the etching
Did the sun bleach them out?


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

People do report back that stains dissipate. That's why patina is soft and beautiful. It's a living finish.


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

we just installed leathered absolute black granite with a slate floor and cream walls and white cabinets/woodwork it turned out absolutely beautiful and doesn't app ear to show water spots or spotty hand prints


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

Snookums It was amazing. It was almost polka-dot with stains. You can hardly see the etches.

Ok - I'd love to see pictures of your kitchen. Even though I have pieces in place its still hard to SEE it...


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

Nope -- stains tend to fade and they can generally be avoided with a sealer. Even where I am sure my sealer has worn off and is in need of another treatment, my marble isn't staining. It will etch, but if it is honed, it tends to all blend unless you are looking for it or get something really bad going on. In which case it can be buffed out.

I was going to vote for the leathered steel granite, but I have marble, so I can't argue with you there if you feel so inclined. I'm at 8 years now and no regrets. My island is a black leathered granite. I didn't want shiny slabs of stone, so I like both your choices.


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

I can't really tell a texture difference on my monitor, but the lighter color looks best to me. It also gives you many more options for future wall and cabinet colors. If you like the "leathered" look, why not find a lighter granite in that finish?


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

kswl I am leaning towards the lighter CT's. My DD age 24 is now saying it is so obviously the marble, once we put the big piece on it.
My stone yard is out of honed carrara right now (what does that tell you?) and gave me some other samples of quartzite and a couple leathered granites but they were creamy, yellowish and stained worse than the marble. I'm going to a different place Monday to check out the Danby Marbles.
I have a little time as my base cabinets finally went back for repainting.


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

Sorry I guess I did not really follow the discussion!

I love the elements of your kitchen and think the tone on tone colorscape is probably the least "dating" for a room full of hard surfaces. It's going to be beautiful, that much is clear!


 o
RE: Are you up for another countertop vote? Please?

I prefer the leathered steel grey best. I tend to like some contrast. I think either stone works with the other elements. There are light bits in the steel grey that pick up the grey in the wall and the same for some of the darker bits in the white vermont.

If the White Vermont etches then it isn't quartzite. Quartzite is composed mainly from quartz which doesn't etch. Some of the white stones being sold as quartzite seem to have harder bits that may be quartz and other areas that are dolomite (a harder marble relative) and some don't seem to be quartzite at all.

Staining is a separate thing that depends on whether the stone has pours, not on its chemical composition. Some quartzite is more porous and stains and some is very low porosity.

Sealers can fill the pours which prevents staining. Sealers don't prevent etching.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Home Decorating & Design Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here