Return to the Home Decorating & Design Forum
| Post a Follow-Up
Posted by sas95
Thu, Jul 10, 14 at 14:48
|I haven't been thrilled with the yellow color in my bedroom since I painted it, but in the interest of not wanting to immediately repaint, I have lived with it. At this point I can justify (to myself) repainting. I had originally wanted a soft creamy color, but... I especially don't like how the cherry furniture looks against the wall. |
I was hoping for suggestions on a new color direction that would play nicely with the existing furniture and rug. My initial thoughts are maybe a warm tan or sand color? Or something else?
I'm open to anything but gray. I don't like gray walls at all. Thanks in advance for any suggestions.
|Benjamin Moore Guilford Green or Soft Fern. Either would look great with that gorgeous rug and the furniture, but also make the room pop a little.|
|This should be easy. Your furniture looks perfect with the rug you have selected. Just match the beige color that is the background for the border of your rug.|
|BM Grant Beige will work well with your colors. I have it throughout most of my house.|
|Tib, I love the Soft Fern and the Guilford green. Both are lovely colors. I also think a beige picked from the rug would look nice as Beverly suggested.|
|Yes, Holly-kay. I think the green would make that rug really shine and would compliment her furniture. I think she needs more wood trim to make beige work, i.e.: crown moulding, trim around the door way, etc. |
and actually, whether green, beige or periwinkle, adding wood trim would add a lot to the room, IMO.
This post was edited by Tibbrix on Thu, Jul 10, 14 at 16:42
|Thanks for the suggestions so far. I will definitely check all of those possibilities out. I had never considered green, but will look now. Those colors are soft and pretty, Tibbrix. |
As for beige, I'll look at Grant Beige as Chispa suggested, and take Beverly's suggestion of looking at beiges pulled from my rug. Truth be told, I'm a little scared of beige. The previous owners of our house had the whole place painted band-aid beige, so I'm always terrified of getting that back!
|Grant Beige is supposed to have green undertones, so that would work with cherry. I am interested in it to replace Georgian Green in my LR, on the Guilford Green strip, which reads olive in my room while Guilford Green read minty when I tested it. It sounds like you want a neutral, so I'd check out Grant Beige.|
|Yes, Grant Beige is a very nice neutral, with greenish undertones. I have some similar colors to OP and the GB looks great with them. I had first painted my house in a yellow/beige and it just wasn't quite right. It also turned sickly green at night. The GB looks great at all times.|
|I have Guilford Green in my bedroom. It looks nothing like the sample. It's a deeper green with yellow undertone. |
I would go with a beige. Some of the popular ones. Shaker Beige, Kilm Beige, Macadamia. Manchester Tan ?
|I like the idea of Grant Beige or some other beige color. Somehow I'm not seeing green.|
|I think a very light gray with a touch of blue would be pretty with both the cherry and the orange rug. Does the rug have some blue in it? I'm not a gray girl either and have mostly warmer tones, but I painted my guest bath BM Silver Mist last year. It is more blue than gray and is a very soft, pretty color. My vanity is dark stained cherry and the granite is cream with bits of taupe and blue/green/gray. I didn't want to go full-out gray because the room is windowless and not tiled, so I felt it needed some color on the walls. Silver Mist was as close as I could get to gray without losing the blue. Actually, I could have gone grayer but had sampled too many paints at that point! You could possibly go a little lighter or grayer depending on your lighting.|
|May Flowers, there is no blue in the rug. The other colors in the rug run more into the olive green/khaki area. Even so, I'm not sure that a blue shade would look right in the house because there is absolutely no blue anywhere else in the house. My home is almost all greens, yellows and earth tones. And the adjoining bathroom has beiges and greens. So if I went in the gray direction but wanted some color, I'm thinking that a green/gray could work better.|
|Oh, the bathroom...no, blue wouldn't work. |
I tried to find a neutral beige to paint my hallway that adjoins the Georgian Green and found that they either looked fleshy or muddy putty. Gave up and used SW Antique White, which can read yellow in bright light.
|Do you have any blue in the rug to pick up? I have this colour in my bedroom, and love it. |
Sorry, disregard my post, I see you don't want blue.
BM night train.
This post was edited by aklvdb on Fri, Jul 11, 14 at 13:41
|SW sand beach or Accessible beige|
|Squire Hill Buff by BM would be a great color that would blend the apricot/beige colors of your rug, look nice with your wood and give you some depth in the wall color. |
Blond Wood by BM is another very nice color that I think would give your room a little uumph and do well, as far as I can see.
I do not see any green in your room but I know it must be there, but sometimes my monitor colors are not realistic so if your rug actually has a lot of green, I apologize for not seeing but still think this is a good color even with the green.
This post was edited by patricia43 on Fri, Jul 11, 14 at 14:42
|Thank you for all of the input. I brought home scads of the color strips today including everyone's suggestions, and so far, Grant Beige and Soft Fern seem to be the top 2 contenders. I'm going to get actual paint samples of each tomorrow so I can try them in the room. I really appreciate the advice.|
|I went to colorjive.com, uploaded one of your photos, and painted the room a Ben Moore Green (they don't have soft fern on the samples, but none are exact and any green on that realm will look the same. I painted it in BM 501 and 502. The green on your walls is really gorgeous, IMO. |
I can't seem to find one comparable to Grant Beige. wish I could copy and paste the pic with the green walls, though.
|Another I would definitely try is BM November Rain, a VERY subtle, soft, gray green.|
|Below is a picture I downloaded from Joss & Main. I'm in love with it! Not sure how the cream will look against your furniture though. |
I'm so glad white and cream walls are coming back in style.
|I'm thinking that the Soft Fern is a strong possibility, but the Grant Beige will look to muddy/blah in the room. It provides no contrast at all with my night stand. Thoughts? Slight tweaks or different direction entirely? |
This post was edited by sas95 on Sat, Jul 12, 14 at 15:06
|Well, I completely see green with that rug and the cherry furniture, and as I said, I did your room on colorjive with a green, and it was beautiful. The grant beige is a very nice color, but I think it will be blah. I think that, with neutral colors like that, you need trim and crown moulding to really make them work. |
JMO, of course.
Do try a sample of the November Rain as well.
|Btw, the green with the cherry furniture and that rug evoke autumn, which is why I think it's a great combination!|
|"I'm thinking that the Soft Fern is a strong possibility, but the Grant Beige will look to muddy/blah in the room. It provides no contrast at all with my night stand. Thoughts? Slight tweaks or different direction entirely?" |
I agree with you. I think many posters are thinking about a deep, dark cherry wood. There are many colors of cherry, and yours is a lighter softer color. It is beautiful. I have a cherry dresser (my Grandma's) and a cherry table (her kitchen table) that are that color (although age has darkened them somewhat) and I think you will need a bit richer color. I think all greens go with woods. I love greens with rich woods and I also love the color of blond wood but that might be too close tot he color of your cherry.
Twilight gold by BM is another pretty color.
I do like the whitish cream colors with it also but the colors will give you more depth and deeper colors bring out the rich colors of good wood.
|Having lived in a green LR/DR for the past 7 or 8 years, I'd want just a hint of green in a bedroom. Too much green and you feel like you're in a frog pond, as a family member so aptly put it. Soft Fern looks like an herbal green, so that should work with the rug colors, but I would look at the next lighter color on the strip. Also look for a barely-there olive green (yellow undertone). |
I'd like this olive color with your rug and cherry, though I'd go lighter.
|Colors with some depth, i.e.: the soft fern, are so great in bedrooms at night, when you're reading. They create a nest-like feel. But in the morning, waking up to that soft green I think would be perfect and a great way to "greet the day" as green is such a living color. |
People tend to be leery of bolder colors, understandably so (and the soft fern isn't even that bold!), but if you get it right, the payoff is HUGE. I'd say, just don't pick the color you feel "safer" with. Try to figure out which one you truly like the best and will make you feel the way you want to feel in your bedroom the most.
|Hard to say, since I'm not into green walls. |
How about BM Coastal Fog
|Another color, and direction, would be blue, namely BM Nantucket Fog. I have it in a bedroom, which has very orange=y pine floors, and it has a lot of yellow in it. In fact, Benjamin Moore pairs it with the colors you have in your room, namely the rug and furniture. And blue bedrooms are divine. Both of the queen bedrooms in my house are blue, and I'll tell youâ€¦the first choice of guests is always the BR with the Nantucket Fog - but I've got white furniture in there, so it's a different effect than your room would have. See link|
Here is a link that might be useful: Nantucket Fog
This post was edited by Tibbrix on Sun, Jul 13, 14 at 8:27
|I'm definitely not leery of color, especially green. My kitchen has green cabinets as well as green walls. I just want something that works this time. |
Blue, on the other hand, is a color that I do not like in decor. It's pretty, but not for me.
This post was edited by sas95 on Sun, Jul 13, 14 at 8:54
|An interior designer once told me to use the middle colors on a paint strip, so that's what I did when we painted most of our house. I've got a lilac guest room, olive green LR/DR, and had a blue violet bathroom. When we remodeled the kitchen, I repainted the green in the hallway to SW Antique White, and then I realized I was tired of the saturation of color in my home. I think deeper colors look good when the wall space is broken up by windows, doorways, white molding, furniture, etc., but my rooms have a solid wall or two, so it was too much color. That's why I say be careful of going too dark. It doesn't appear you have a lot to break up the color in your bedroom.|
|Oh, sorry, I thnk you even said you don't like blue. Sorry.|
|Tibbrix, I love your advice about not picking "safe" colors. I have been doing that for my new house - until I found a color that I LOVED and that made me more brave. sas95, I'd second trying the November Rain sample too.|
|I am a fan of Soft Fern. I recommended it for a friend who has cherry furniture in her bedroom, and it looks great. I also have it in my basement "playroom" which has my old cherry kitchen cabinets built in, and it looks good there, too. |
I'd also recommend something along the lines of Paris Rain if it's not too gray for you.
Here is a link that might be useful: Paris Rain
|Keep in mind that when you try it against your yellow, you may not get the right impression of what the whole room would look like in that color.|
|Soft Fern looks blue compared to Coastal Fog that nosoccermom posted. Do you think a blue undertone is good with the rug? The green in the rug looks khaki to me. Post a close-up of the rug if you haven't decided yet.|
|Soft Fern vs. November Rain. Plus a closeup of the green in the rug. Yesterday was sunny and the Soft Fern was reading green. Today is overcast and it's reading muddier to me. |
This post was edited by sas95 on Sun, Jul 13, 14 at 16:03
|Try PPG Dusty Trail |
|Try a sample of the Guilford green. It's LRV value is very close to the soft fern, but it has more yellow in it while the soft fern has more gray, so the yellow will make it warm like your rug, and not as "muddy" as the soft fern, which is the gray in that color causing that. |
And perspective! It's only paint and can always be redone.
Here is a link that might be useful: Guilford Green story
|I think I have decided on the Soft Fern. I have been looking at it at various times of the day and it has grown on me. And it's true, it is only paint! |
Thanks everyone for your help. Next paint project is my living room, which, I'm afraid, I am also stuck on. Will start a separate thread on that.
|Please post a pic of the finished room!|
|Hey, no fair! I just spent an hour looking through the green paints! :P |
I came across BM Harbour Town 493, which they show on their website paired with a coral color. I found only one pic. It's the paint above the chair rail. It is a green but looks a little gold here. Note the orange candles.
Also Dune Grass 492 was used on Young House Love, so I got a link with some pics.
Here is a link that might be useful: Dune Grass
This post was edited by may_flowers on Mon, Jul 14, 14 at 10:27
|Wow, May Flowers, the Harbour Town is really pretty. I might just have to try that one before committing...|
|I was trying to find more pics and came across on YHL where they recommended Harbour Town as a soft khaki green. They also mentioned Springview Green in the same room, which I had picked out as a possibility for my guest bedroom. So now I see that Springview Green is the lightest on the strip. It is a much brighter green than shown in this pic. But no wonder I liked Harbour Town and Dune Grass. Dune Grass is one of the top five favorite greens on the BM website. |
I think too much green and your room could read pumpkin patch with the orange rug.
This post was edited by may_flowers on Mon, Jul 14, 14 at 11:18
Post a Follow-Up
Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.
If you are a member, please log in.
If you aren't yet a member, join now!
Return to the Home Decorating & Design Forum
Information about Posting
- You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
- Please review our Rules of Play
- Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you
will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your
post, make changes and upload photos.
- After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in
order to see it.
- Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
- We have a strict no-advertising
- If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit
our Test forum.
- If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we
will be happy to help.
Learn more about in-text links on this page here