Here's a picture of the front of the house, in case it helps.

Either of the two darker colors would work.

The light ones seem too insubstantial for the nice strong visual weight of your house.

I agree with Bronwynsmom.
I've looked back at your photos a few times, and I keep leaning toward the darker colors.

Another vote for darker....will you do the front door the same as whatever you select?

I was thinking a different color for the front door... if I go with the plum-brown on the shutters, someone on this forum suggested a dark teal for the door. If I go with the black-ish brown, I'm not sure what color I'd pick for the door.

Your brick looks so different in your two photos: one is neutral, one is orange. Which one is closer to the real brick color?

The top picture is more accurate...when you stand back farther, it does read more brown though. I described it as brown brick for a year... now that I've spent some time staring at it, I'd call it more of an orange tinged brown. My color blind husband still says it's brown. :-)

I like the plum brown.

The sun came out, so I snapped a new picture that shows the brick color more accurately.

I really like the paint colors that are on it.