Return to the Home Decorating Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

Posted by pumpkin_spice (My Page) on
Tue, Apr 5, 11 at 18:51

Hi everyone, I need help picking a color for my main living area. I currently have Tobacco Road in there and it's a beautiful color, but I get very little natural light and it's feeling dark and heavy to me. I'm hoping a lighter color will help. I want to find a color that's creamy, warm and happy but doesn't scream YELLOW.

This is a large area, with 12-foot ceilings, so there's going to be a lot of whatever color I choose. I've painted the 3 colors I've listed above onto poster boards. Subtle and PW seem almost too light, but in such a big room I'm wondering if the color will intensify. Jicama is beautiful but I fear will be too much yellow on the walls.

Does anyone have these colors who could share photos with me? Or maybe a color in a similar vein? I've looked at SW Ivoire and Blonde and they're too yellow for me. But I want SOME definition, I want the color to pop out from white trim.

Thanks for any help!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

Here's Palace White - with artificial light first and natural light second

Photobucket

Photobucket


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

Thank you. It's beautiful in your home. Do you know what color the trim is? When I hold PW up to my trim I see little contrast, but maybe I need a brighter white.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

Our trim is all Benjamin Moore semi gloss base white - no colorant added. Your trim would have to have a LOT of color to not stand out against Palace White - it's probably an optical illusion and because you are only looking at small pieces of trim against your paint samples.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

Have you looked at Benjamin Moore Rich Cream? It's a really beautiful tone. I'm sure you'll turn up several photos if you search this site, or just try Google images.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

I was at a home remodel showcase this weekend and there was a beautiful color called applesauce that was a Hirschfield's color. It was so soft and not at all super yellow. I'm sorry I don't have a picture. I'm going to try it in my own house soon.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

I considered Jicama for a room I was doing but went with something totally different. Let me warn you that the colors from BM Affinity collection ,which subtle and jicama are part of really intensify on the wall. I have several of the affinity colors in my house.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

I'm liking the look of Palace White and Rich Cream so far. I also came across Almond Bisque and Filtered Sunlight. I'm afraid FS might be too pastel for a big living area though.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

I painted my den Jicama last year and love it. It is a soft creamy yellow but not a loud, bright yellow. I work full-time and don't have much time to take pictures of my house, but when I was considering the color I googled a picture of BM Jicama that is on the "Rejuvenation Projects Blog" and it looks in that room (with white columns) similar to how it looks in my room.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

We used Benjamin Moore Windswept in our living room and really like it there.(looks slightly different in this pic) However, did not care for it when trying it in a bedroom that has a different exposure...lighting makes such a difference.

Here's a pic of Windswept:
Living Room shells

I also tried Jicama in a bedroom, but did come out stronger than I expected so did not use.Pottery Barn uses it in 1 of our local stores and it looks beautiful there! (which is why I'd sampled it)

I'm liking the Palace White too and have heard good things about this color.

Good luck!


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

Jicama is really quite yellow. No doubt about it. I mean, its gorgeous, but if you don't want yellow....


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

I have Filtered Sunlight in my foyer and have never liked it. It's on my list to paint, but hoping I can convince DH to put up chair rail and picture frame molding first. It is yellow. A pale yellow, but still yellow. If you don't want yellow, I would not use Filtered Sunlight.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

I have BM Bone White in my downstairs room with BM Semi-Gloss White trim and there is a nice contrast and I love the warm peaceful color that is very close to BM Palace White that I almost chose and may choose when I repaint my Master Bedroom since I love the way it looks in every picture I have seen so far. BM Palace White had a touch more gold or yellow in my paint sample and was a touch darker than BM Bone White but they both are not white.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

Thank you everyone for your input. So far I've eliminated Jicama and Filtered Sunlight. Still liking the Palace White. Why is picking a cream shade so hard!


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

I love Palace...

Lisa...gorgeous room!


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

hi Lisa, I love your room and the pic of windswept. we have a mostly southern exposure. maybe with a bit of western too.
which exposure is the room you pictured above? also, what is the undertone in the windswept in the room you have pictured? is it cream? yellow? peach? thanks!


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

Palace White reads yellow up in my daughter's bedroom. I can see both her and her sister's room (Standish White) from the upstairs hall and both look yellow-Standish more so than Palace. Since your room is large with high ceilings it might not come off as yellow, but to be safe, I'd choose a different color. BM Bone comes to mind. Also, check out BM Blanced almond.


 o
BM Bone White - RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

I agree with Boniieann925 that BM Bone White is a very close match to BM Palace White but the Bone White is more neutral and slightly lighter with less gold/yellow. Both are nice and creamy and go great with BM Semi-gloss white trim. I will look for pictures to post when I get some sleep. The Palace White may also me nice since I love every picture it is in. I would paint two foam boards both of these colors and any other color you think you would like and move them around the room and then put then against white trim.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

Take a look at an old Benjamin Moore color called "Featherbed"-the code for it is CC-928.
I think of it as the perfect non-yellow yellow. It's creamy and bright and looks good against most varieties of
white trim but it doesn't really look yellow. I have had it in 3 houses. It gets lost in the shuffle because it reads pretty "eh" on the chip but most people who paint a room yellow end up wishing the color was way less intense and Featherbed is what they wished the color looked like.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

trk65, please share a picture of BM Featherbed since I wanted to change my Master Bathroom BM Navajo White color with white trim to be a little darker and I have to repaint the room anyway since the painter did such a bad job.


 o
BM Featherbed- RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

I just found a post from 2008 where the cabinets are BM Featherbed. The color looks very much like BM Bone White which is what I wish I painted that bathroom but even if i did I would have to repaint it since the painter put the 2nd coat on the wall before the first coat was dry and it looks terrible and he has drips down the wall. I have lived like this now for a few years and I have had enough.

Here is a link that might be useful: BM Featherbed cabinets that are so nice! See contrast with white.


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

My front hall and the hall down the steps is subtle...and I LOVE IT.

Natural light in summer:

Natural light with no leaves on the trees:

Natural light with no leaves on the trees and from a different angle:

I wish I had better pictures...


 o
RE: Benjamin Moore Subtle, Jicama, Palace White?

have Plantation Beige by Duron but SW bought Duron and have all of their formulas so you can still get it. It's gorgeous. Porter's Sea Sand is similar but I think that Plantation Beige has a little something extra. Reads Yellow but only in a suggested way, not in your face yellow. Will try to get some photos for you but I'm so photo upload challenged!!!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Home Decorating Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here