When my old roaster gave up the ghost about a year ago I replaced it with a Calphalon covered roaster that I've been very happy with.

It's anodized, 13 x 17 inches and plenty tall when I need to cover things, and roomy when they need to be open roasted.

It comes with a flat grill rack as standard. I replaced that immediately with a two-piece adjustible rack.

Other than that, I like everything about it---including the price.

I have the Calphalon Classic Roaster and love it!

I went through the same thing looking for one for my son and his wife. I had stumbled into just the perfect one for me several years ago and he coveted it....don't remember what it was but the handles were perfect the size perfect, not non-stick so you can put it over blazing heat if you wish, and some un known brand.
So for 2 years I looked for one for him....finally found it. Can't remember the brand, but it was also on close out and only about $55 or $60. I was going into these fancy kitchen shops and asking for a non non-stick pan. I wanted aluminum not stainless and it had to be small enough to fit in a normal oven and big enough for a 20 pound bird. They acted like I had 3 heads!
I was looking at estate sales before I finally found what I wanted.....good luck!!
Linda C

I just re-read this thread. I am not sure my roaster is the classic. My Calphalon roaster is the anodized interior.