Return to the Cookware Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Gas vs Electric Range

Posted by Wazatron (My Page) on
Tue, Jun 14, 05 at 17:12

Hi again 2nd post for today.

I have to buy a new range, and am struggling with gas vs electric. The struggle is primarily financial, as if I could get anything Id just run right out and get a nice Viking cook top and wall ovens, but thats another story

Ive been using a crappy coil electric range in my current apartment. The place I had before that was gas, and I loved it but I hated the bottom-broiler.

Ive never used the flat ceramic glass cook tops either. Ive also read that the wet heat of gas ovens isnt as good for baking.

A dual oven, unfortunately, is also out of my price range.

So what do people think of the ceramic glass cooktops? Whats the real difference between gas and electric ovens? Do they have gas ranges with a top-mounted broiler like electric ovens?

Any additional info would really be appreciated!! Thanks all!!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

Did you check out the Appliances Forum? And what's the budget?

This Sears Kenmore Elite, made by Frigidaire, gets rave reviews.

Here is a link that might be useful: Kenmore Elite


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

There are many gas ranges with broilers in the oven cavity. My Frigidaire is one of them ('cuz I absolutely refused to even consider a "bottom-broiler"). They're not the BBuy loss-leaders, but they don't cost anywhere near what Vikings cost, either. Whirlpool and GE and Maytag and Bosch make 'em, too.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

What do I think? I love my smoothtop. It is instant hot, cooldown no dif. than old coil. Clean up is a breeze. I have a four burner with 6 diff size elements. Flat cookware is essential.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

I would never ever again cook with electricity!!!!
Electric oven is fine.....but so is gas!....the nonsense about not being good for baking is just that!
If I had a choice ( and I did!!) of a top of the line do everything electric range with 2 ovens and a broiler and burner with a brain, auto this and auto that.....and an old gas clunker that had to be lit with a match.....I would take the old gas clunker!!...just once I made the mistake of choosing the snitzy electric stove....cooked with the da@# thing for 12 years before i got back to gas!
Linda C


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

I currently cook on electric and have used both the coil and smoothtop burners, but given a choice, IMO there is no choice -- gas is the way to go. Alas, I live out in the country with no gas lines. Can't wait for the day when I can at least switch over to propane.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

Having cooked with gas and electric cooktops, I can't think of any reason to choose electric other than price. Gas gives you much finer control over temperature, and it is great to be able to transfer pots and pans from burner to burner without waiting for them to heat up. Fringe benefit: you can cook during a power outage. The 2003 blackout was a lot more pleasant than it could have been :)

However, I can't think of any benefit a gas oven has over electric other than the cost of the fuel. I have used several gas and electric ovens over the last few years, and I always found it frustrating cooking in the gas ones. With an electric oven, you have a dry environment with the option of adding humidity if what you're baking requires it. The gas ovens I've used are always humid inside because of the natural gas, and there is no way to control this.

I am genuinely curious to know if there are any other benefits to a gas oven.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

I want a inexpensive safe range that s slide in.
I prefer electric.
what brand and store do you suggest I get?
Its a Christmas present . . .


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

Being a huge baker, I can't imagine not having an electric convection oven (many come with electric ranges now a days). I can bake three racks of perfect cookies at one time. I don't know for sure, but I doubt I could do that in a gas oven. I don't love my smoothtop, but I wouldn't trade my electric convection oven for anything.

PS: I once used a gas range at a cottage and wanted to make garlic bread in the broiler. I took me 10 minutes to figure out the broiler is where the pots and pan drawer usually is! Great if you like to lay on the floor while broiling.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

I am not sure why no one has mentioned heat generation comparisons. I did some on our range and the ranges of several friends. The electric ranges invariably heated up a pot of water (same pot, same quantity of water) much, much faster than the gas ranges, which were all slow as molasses. Our own range, a pricey Dacor with a gas range-top and an electric oven, was the slowest (and in many other respects is a piece of junk - don't get me going on it).

Is slow boiling not an issue for anyone else? What about boiling spaghetti? I am reduced to dividing the water into 3 pots and only combining them when the water is boiling.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

No, boiling speed is not a concern for everyone. When I need to boil water quickly, I use an electric kettle, which is much faster and more energy efficient than boiling water on any type of stove (I've tested it against electric smoothtop, induction, and 17.5 MBTU gas units).

The nice thing about gas ranges is their instant response. My old smoothtop electric took forever to heat up, and just as long to cool down. I suffered numerous boil-overs because it took so long to moderate the heat under my pots. Now, with gas, I have fast and infinite control, with no guess work, or moving pots on then off the heat.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

I generally prefer cooking on gas. I am contemplating installing an electric cooktop somewhere in my kitchen for boiling large quantities of water or other cooking which just requires large amounts of high heat. Gas is better for everything else. Regarding baking, I find I have good results with bread and cakes in either. Electric is more stable and more dry, but I am not sure it is especially superior.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

I just read my response above, while it was true I did like my Thermador electric range, In this house we had the option for propane - I am now a Gas convert and loving it.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

Jim

I hear ya. I will say that boiling water was a bit of an issue for us with our old Profile gas range -- it boiled water just fine, but a nice rolling boil in a large pot, starting with cold water, really could take a while. It's just not a problem any more with the BlueStar RNB. Yes, a good induction range would boil a pot of water more quickly, and so would a specialized kettle. But the BlueStar is quick enough that I just don't find it inconvenient any more. I had one of the 22k burners installed in the rear left corner precisely to accommodate large pots of water without blocking access to the other burners.


 o
RE: Gas vs Electric Range

Jim

I hear ya. I will say that boiling water was a bit of an issue for us with our old Profile gas range -- it boiled water just fine, but a nice rolling boil in a large pot, starting with cold water, really could take a while. It's just not a problem any more with the BlueStar RNB. Yes, a good induction range would boil a pot of water more quickly, and so would a specialized kettle. But the BlueStar is quick enough that I just don't find it inconvenient any more. I had one of the 22k burners installed in the rear left corner precisely to accommodate large pots of water without blocking access to the other burners.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Cookware Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here