Return to the Cookware Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
strange question-can you boil water in all clad

Posted by elenal (My Page) on
Tue, May 9, 06 at 16:59

Hi: Strange question here...A neighbor, knowing I was looking for new cookware to break in my remodeled kitchen, just gave me her beautiful All Clad Stainless Pasta Pentola. (She has arthritis, and has never used this big boy.) I wouldn't spend money like that on a pasta pot, but there it is on my counter. My weird question is--can you actually prepare pasta in this pot. I read that you aren't supposed to use high heat with AC stainless, but then how can you prepare pasta w/o boiling water. I'm hoping I've got my 'facts' all wrong. Thanks


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

I've purchased and returned a number of tea kettles that have manuals requiring use of "medium heat only". This admonition for a metal device that has no purpose other than boiling water. In my continuing search since those returns I have yet to find ANY tea-kettle that has a tag that says otherwise. IMHO this is liability-driven nonsense. Perhaps in the future we will be unable to purchase stoves with "high" settings for the burners.

I strongly suspect you're dealing with liability-avoidance labelling and nothing more. I'm willing to be educated, but this sounds like nonsense to me. I have several all-clad pans. I boil water on high with them all the time.

I wonder...should I attach a 3-paragraph disclaimer to this post?


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

I believe many of the cookwares say "med heat" today. I am not sure why. I have some All Clad pieces and yes I do turn them on high for boiling water. Generally after a rapid boils starts, food added, boil returns, I do turn it down some and the rapid boil continues.


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

Thanks to both of you. I hadn't thought about the liability issue, and that does help this silly admonition not to use a super macho pot like an AC over high heat. I'm glad to know that you've both used your AC with high heat. I've been fantasizing about making a bolognese tonight--first meal in my newly remodeled kitchen after 9 months of microwaving. I'm ready, now--thanks.


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

As long as there is water in the pot, you will not damage your AC though it may discolor a bit. Use some Bar Keeper's Friend to keep it nice and shiny.


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

It's like that 100% cotton shirt, with out interfacing or lining that says "dry clean only!"...
Nonsense!
And.....what did you pay for the pot???
Use it!! Enjoy!!
Linda C


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

I'll get the Bar Keeper's Friend. And thanks re the mention of not boiling the pot dry (I've been known to do that). And, Linda, I got the pot for a great price--free! My neighbor had it, and never used it. I've promised to make her some killer pasta dinners in it!


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

I think the high heat discoloring it is probably something they have gotten complaints about, so they tell people not to do it. I say bullhocky. I use all of my pans for high heat if I want to, and the rainbow colors don't bother me at all.


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

Somewhere in the discussion should be the question of warping a pan. I've been told that people who take a hot pan & put it in cooler dishwater warp their pans. A saleslady said that you were suppose to put vegetables in the pot at room temperature, though not sure if it was not to warp a pan. The question remains, can you put ice cold tap water in the pan the set a roaring fire on "high" under it, & still not damage or warp the multi-layer clad pan?


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

Absolutely....if you can't I don't want that pan!!
Why would anyone care if a pan discolors when used as it was intended? I would not be happy that it did....but because it might wouldn't keep me from putting it on high heat or starting something with cold water.
What a pain it would be to have to "start" a pot of water on low...


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

Oh my gaud! I made bolognese at Christmas. It was absolutely awesome! Enjoy your big pot!


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

I bring the water to a boil at just under my stove's highest heat, because somewhere, sometime, I also heard not to use the highest heat.(That seems to be what discolors stainless.) It boils plenty fast anyway. It's the temperature they are talking about, not the boiling. I've called the all clad cust svc # 800-255-2523 several times. They were always great to deal with. They were the ones who told me about Bar Keepers Friend. It is a good friend, takes away anything stuck or discolored. Things do stick if the pan is not hot enough ( let it get hot on a med or a med hi heat) when you are sauteeing, usually it will release on its own. Get the pan hot, then add the oil, when it shimmers add the meat.


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

I actually did call All-Clad and asked about that (among other questions). They said OK to bring to boil on high heat but then need to turn down to medium to avoid discoloration.


 o
RE: strange question-can you boil water in all clad

I've been using All Clad for 20 years. Both the LTD and stainless lines. Yes, you can boil water in them. You can also take them from the rangetop directly into the oven. I've done this on many occassions over the years. Sometimes with the oven as high as 500 degrees. No damage has occured.

This is heavy duty top of the line stuff. Don't be afraid to use it.

Enjoy.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Cookware Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here