Return to the Cookware Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Percolators

Posted by awm03 (My Page) on
Thu, Jan 17, 08 at 16:44

Thinking of ditching my drip coffee maker for a percolator. Anybody have one they can recommend? Anybody use a stovetop percolator? Also, there are some cool looking retro ones on eBay, many of them aluminum. Does aluminum affect the taste as some claim?

Thanks for any & all input!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Percolators

Ask any coffee-fiend and they'll tell you that's a bad move. A move in the opposite direction of good coffee.

If you want something for novelty, go the vacuum pot route.

If you want something that's better than a standard percolator, look at stovetop moka pots.

If you want something that just works, get an AeroPress.

And if you just want a better drip coffee maker, get a Technivorm.

Anything but a percolator!


 o
RE: Percolators

Gosh, joe_b, I like perked coffee. And I did my homework on the 'net: there are lots of others who prefer perked coffee too. It wasn't a big deal for me, so I've lived with a drip maker for many years. But just the other day, I thought to myself, "why am I putting up with this when I'd rather have perked coffee?!" So I'm looking for a percolator! Thanks for the info on the other methods just the same :)


 o
RE: Percolators

Well, you didn't say you were a perc aficionado! ;-)

You should be looking at the Farberware electric percolators -- that's what all of my ol' Swedish relatives have been using since before I became a gleam in someone's eye! They like a nice, meaty cup o' joe, you know what I mean?


 o
RE: Percolators

Sorry...I sure agree with Joe...perc coffee is burned....cooked...boiled. The taste is similar to what you would get if you made a pot of drip coffee and boiled it for 5 minutes.....but if that's what you like, why did you get a drip pot?
I think that's why you don't see them offered much any more....however it is easy to make coffee in an automatic perc pot.
Our pioneer forebearers made a "boiled coffee" in those big old enamel ware pots....you put the water in the pot...and made a mixture of beaten egg and coffee grounds, dumped it into the boiling pot, let it return to a boil and turned it off...
Why not go to a thift store and see if you can pick one up for a song and try it out before you ditch the drip pot?
Linda C


 o
RE: Percolators

"but if that's what you like, why did you get a drip pot?"

Because our first one was a freebie, then the 2nd was a Christmas gift from a near-by relative whom we didn't want to offend by discarding it, then when that one died, I bought our 3rd drip machine assuming that percolators were no longer made. And DH likes drip just fine. But frankly, I've always found drip coffee to be a bit watery. Something's missing in the flavor (must be the burnt taste!). I don't recall seeing a percolator at a thrift shop lately. Lots of old Mr. Coffees though. Like cast iron pans, perhaps the perc aficionados scoop them up to market on Ebay or for their own use. Or maybe too many drip fans threw theirs in the garbage.


 o
RE: Percolators

Try putting a little extra ground coffee in the basket of the drip pot...
There are lots of old perc pots out there.
Linda C

Here is a link that might be useful: percolators


 o
RE: Percolators


"If you want something for novelty, go the vacuum pot route."

I got a kick out of that--those were standard when I was a kid--made by Silex.


 o
RE: Percolators

Farberware still makes a nice percolator in different sizes. Easy to use, easy to clean, not too expensive.

Here is a link that might be useful: Farberware Percolators


 o
RE: Percolators

teresa, thanks for the link to Kohls. I see they have some great sales going on. If my eBay attempt falls through, then Kohls it is. The sale price on the stovetop model is good.

Here is a link that might be useful: Stovetop model


 o
RE: Percolators

Percolators...that's real trip down memory lane! Drink what tastes good to you, AWM. Those Farberwares look really pretty.

Linda, did the pioneers filter that coffee through their teeth?


 o
RE: Percolators

My sister is a percolator fan and makes pretty good coffee. She's also a thrift store fan and says you need to buy several before you get find the one that perks at the proper temperature without keeping it too hot. She also uses quite a bit of chicory...

I do think that coffee that sits in a percolator tastes better than coffee that's sat on a burner for any length of time.


 o
RE: Percolators

A follow-up:

I bought a 14 cup aluminum stove top percolator on eBay, an old Sears model, for $20 (price + shipping). Glad I did. The coffee has that taste of something that was missing from my drip maker -- a fuller flavor. I like the retro look too. It goes well with my stainless steel counters.

There were a lot of old style electric percolators on eBay, some were even beautiful. Maybe I'll try for one of those fancy models some day. Would be fun to have at a party.


 o
RE: Percolators

Socks....no need to filter the coffee through your teeth....the egg you beat up grabbed all the grounds and made for crystal clear coffee.
Linda C


 o
RE: Percolators

My only experience with 'boiled cowboy coffee' was when visiting relatives in Montana over 35 years ago. We went to a picnic in the mtns. above their ranch and they 'boiled' coffee in the fire pit in an enamelware pot. When done, it was removed from the fire and a little cold water was poured over it. They waited a few minutes to let the grounds settle and then poured the coffee.


 o
RE: Percolators

awm I'm glad you found a percolater. We have two Corning Ware ceramic stove top percolators and we love them.

Fori, DH is a chicory fan too :)


 o
RE: Percolators

Everybody likes thier coffee differently.

I have collected a number of brewing apparatus.

IMHO - My ss insulated french press makes the best cup of the lot. A glass french press looses the heat too fast

A tradional european star stovetop perk makes a nice rich cup of coffee as well if made right you will get a nice little froth too used these daily. Aluminum is fine.

My Italian parents and grandparents swear by the old electric perks. I have had excellent coffee from them as well as horrid cups.

The neopolitan flip style perk is a pain I usually made a mess

The Bodum Santos vacuum pot made a great cup of coffee but will not stand up to daily use. The plastic and rubber seals will break down. It ia also a pain to clean.

I love my vietnamese individual drips but they rarely see the light of day

Right now I am on the old autodrip with a built in timer due to need for convinience.

almost any pot can make a decent cup of coffee as long as you use the right ground in the right proportions and fresh cold water.


 o
RE: Percolators

kenzo, when it comes to coffee making, you are The Voice Of Experience :)

"awm I'm glad you found a percolater. "
Thanks, chiroptera mama.


 o
To Perc or Not to Perc

This is an old thread but still relevant to anyone considering a perc (it shows up on Google :-).

Here's my 2 for the benefit of anyone looking into this. I feel compelled to post because there is so much misinformation floating around:

I think it boils down to whether or not you believe that a perc MUST boil coffee. We are told by those in the know that boiling coffee is bad. In reality, however, whether stovetop or electric, boiled coffee is not inevitable from a percolator.

I purchased my first perc, a 12-cup Presto, about three years ago. It brews at 195F using an 800-watt element. The coffee experts will tell you that this falls in the ideal brewing range. Most automatic drip coffeemakers, according to a Cooks Illustrated 2008 coffeemaker comparison, do not reach proper brewing temperatures until late in the brew cycle, if at all. So in reality the perc method is no worse than the popular drip coffeemakers, and perhaps even better suited for some. (One drawback is simply the need to remember to unplug it there's no auto shutoff on your average electric perc!)

Much of what passes for "percolator wisdom" probably harkens back to an earlier era in which inexpensive Robusta pre-ground coffee was the norm on grocer's shelves. Today we have so many more choices! Moreover, many of the electric percolators of old "slow brewed" the coffee, taking 20 minutes or longer to brew 12 cups. Contrast that with today's percolator, which keeps pace with your average automatic drip coffeemaker: 1 cup per minute.

Poor recollections of bitter perc coffee may have more to say about the technique than the method. For instance, one way to ruin perc coffee is to leave the grinds basket in place to "keep warm". Just like a drip coffeemaker, keeping the coffee warm for an extended period will cause the flavor to deteriorate. A thermal server is the better option for fresh brewed coffee no matter how you prefer to make it.

I believe that good coffee is mostly a matter of good technique, clean equipment and fresh water/beans. It is quite possible to give even the most respected coffee brewing method a bad name if you don't master the skill (French press, Chemex, what have you). The perc is no different. There are good products on the market and there are those who know how to use them.

So why consider a percolator? Here were my personal reasons:

-- BPA and phthalates, implicated in both breast and prostate cancer, made headlines some time back for appearing in certain types of plastic, even to include baby bottles (which, like coffee, are also heated). A stainless steel percolator is the solution to concern over plasticizer exposure.

-- Frustrations pertaining to dribbling spouts on glass carafes. A percolator may resolve this common drip coffeemaker annoyance (the PRESTO I mentioned features an elongated teapot type spout).

-- Drip brewed coffee is lukewarm in no time, especially if one adds milk, cream and sugar. The percolator brews hotter, so no need for a microwave nearby. Again another problem the perc resolves.

-- Unable to justify doing as Cooks Illustrated recommended: Purchasing the no-frills Technivorm, a coffee trade endorsed automatic drip brewer built in the Netherlands that retails over $240. For $70 or less my PRESTO was about $45 on sale at Sears an electric percolator will land you in the same "ideal" coffee brewing temperature range for far less money. (In a classier looking form to boot.)

CONCLUSION

There are a lot of good reasons to revisit the modern percolator. Those who bash them are those who haven't tried them at least not one built in this decade!

The best advice I can offer readers is to try a percolator for yourself and form your own conclusions. You might be in for a pleasant surprise!

REFERENCES:

Writer, chef and food critic Michael Ruhlman prefers the perc:

http://blog.ruhlman.com/2008/02/percolator-love.html

The owner of the Coffee Geek website eschews the percolator. See his comment here:

http://gadgets.boingboing.net/2008/02/06/ruhlman-defends-the.html

Oh, and one last note: I do not work for a perc manufacturer. I just couldn't believe how inaccurate the "boiling rhetoric" is in contrast to the reality of my first electric perc and have taken it upon myself to help set the record straight. Thanks for reading!


 o
RE: Percolators

Wow, I can't believe this thread is still around! Just wanted to say I still have -- and enjoy -- the old stove top percolator I bought two years ago. I use it on my ceramic cooktop, turning the heat up to medium-high to get the perc going, then turning it down to low to complete the percolating. When done, I turn the heat off. The coffee is hotter than my old drip (which DH insists on keeping because it's faster) and stays surprisingly hot for a long time just leaving the percolator on the burner. The coffee does NOT taste bitter and has a fuller flavor. A slower process, but worth it. The only drawback is that the aluminum has created a black spot on my ceramic burner that will not come off. It's the nature of aluminum, high heat, and ceramic burners, which is why I only use medium-high heat now to start the percolating.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Cookware Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here