Tomorrow, I'll be hauling out my Dutch oven for the second time. I found the recipe online, and the sauce is more like a barbecue sauce. Instead of adding 2 tsp. of prepared mustard (which mom and I do not like in barbecue sauce), I thought Worcestershire sauce would work in it's place. Annie, I will have to try the Coke Chicken one of these days!.

Here is the original recipe:

Oven Baked Chicken

3-4 lbs. cut-up chicken (as in parts)
1 pkg. onion soup mix
1/2 c. butter
2 tsp. prepared mustard
1 1/2 c. water
1/2 c. vinegar
1/4 c. packed brown sugar
1 c. ketchup
Salt and pepper to taste

Place cut up chicken into Dutch oven or roasting pan. Mix remaining ingredients in saucepan and simmer for 15 minutes. Pour over chicken and bake at 350 degrees for 2-3 hours.

Brad AKA Moonwolf

That looks like a good recipe. Couple of suggestions:

1. If the chicken is in cut-up parts, 2-3 hours may be too long. Better test with a temperature probe and taste test at some point.

2. If you are going to sub mustard with Worcestershire sauce, I don't know if you need vinegar. It may be very good. I am not sure if I am correct.

Pictures please.

dcarch

Although I love mustard, I think I'd just leave it out. My concern with Worcestershire sauce would be that it might be too salty with the dried soup. Actually, a couple of spoonfuls of steak sauce might be a good sub too.

Brad, you're getting lots of use out of that new dutch oven!

Annie

Amish Oven Baked Chicken

1/2 cup flour
2 teaspoons paprika
1 teaspoon black pepper
1/4 teaspoon dry mustard
3 teaspoons salt
3 pounds cut-up broiler or young chicken
1/4 pound butter- one stick

DIRECTIONS:

Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.

Mix the dry ingredients well in a plastic bag, then coat the cut up chicken parts with the mixture.

Melt the butter in a 13 x 9-inch baking pan. Place the chicken parts in the pan, but do not crowd them. Bake the chicken for 1 1/2 to 2 hours or until done. Turn chicken once or twice during baking.

Teresa

Dcarch, I think we'll check the chicken after an hour and a half of baking time. I don't have a proper meat thermometer, though :-(. When we make the sauce, I'll give it a taste test. I'll be sure and post pictures :-).

Annie, I see your point about it being too salty with the
Worcestershire sauce. I tried steak sauce before, just a little dab on the end of my finger, and I did not like it one bit LOL. I'll leave the mustard out of it and do a taste test as I said. I love mustard as well. Especially on a roast beef hoagie or a cheeseburger :D.

Teresa, thank you for the recipe! I hate to ask you this, but is there a substitute I could use instead of the dry mustard? I don't care much for the flavor it gives, which is strange reguarding my last comment.

Brad AKA Moonwolf

Teresa

As promised, here are the pictures of the Oven Baked Chicken, before and after. I picked the bones of my leg quarter clean! We did not add mustard and only used 1/4 cup of the vinegar. The sauce wasn't very thick, but could we add some flour or cornstarch to make it a little thicker the next time? Also, we only baked the chicken parts for an hour and a half. Moist and flavorful! :-)

Step by step process:

Chicken parts in Dutch oven, seasoned w/salt & pepper

The sauce. It smells wonderful!

Before baking (look at the rich color!)

After baking (the best one of all)

Enjoy! We ate this with instant mashed potatoes with instant chicken gravy and Bush's baked beans. Talk about comfort food :-).

Brad AKA Moonwolf

I bought my first Dutch oven shortly after you did, but I haven't gotten that much use out of it yet. It was the perfect size for sauteing the vegetables for the stuffing I made for TG, but I haven't baked in it yet. I'm starting to use my real oven now more - I was in the habit of using the toaster oven way too often, and the weather has cooled slightly so that it's in the 60s and 70s instead of 70s and 80s like it was in October.

I've never made baked beans - always cooked them on stove top, but I do plan to try baking them now, to see how that turns out.

Lars

It would be interesting to get different tastes by doing things a little different the next time you make the same chicken, for instance, you can use a cast iron pan to brown the skin first, or instead of mustard, use curry powder, or add some orange peel, etc.

Wonderful chicken!

dcarch

As a sub for mustard without the bite, try tumeric. It has a very mild flavor and is very good for you. It is usually an ingredient in prepared mustard anyway, it's what gives it the yellow color.

Lars, that is a first for me. Instant mashed potatoes as a thickener for sauces. I'll have to remember that. The Bush's baked beans mom and dad like right out of the can but I like mine heated up. I have a baked bean recipe I have written down but I haven't tried it yet. Congrats on the new Dutch oven!

dcarch, this is some of the best chicken I've ever ate in my life. Browning the chicken first would give it a nice color. I'm going to try it the next time I make it.

lpinkmountain, I think I will give turmeric a try. I remember reading how good it is for you. Most of us forget that it was herbs and spices that helped us not only with our cooking, but our health as well.

If I end up using flour or cornstarch to thicken the sauce, how much should I use? Just a little at a time until it's thick enough?

Brad AKA Moonwolf

You could also make the same recipe in a different type of pan, the bottom part of a metal broiling pan and then you wouldn't have to take it out of the pan to run under the broiler.
You could be making a side dish of rice in your dutch oven while the chicken is in the oven....

Another thing you could do for variety, is to dry rub the chicken, roast it and make the sauce separate. That way you could get a crispy skin, top it with the sauce and serve your favorite sides. Rice would go well with it. But I'm a Minnesota Scandinavian so potatoes are usually a requirement!

Keep a chicken in every pot and enjoy your cooking there Wolfie! :)

Tami..who just might make chicken for dinner!

Cynic, I think this recipe would go very well with rice. It's total comfort food either way lol ;-).

Tami, thank you for that suggestion! I will have to add that to the recipe I have typed up. I'll write out a card for my sister too :-).

Brad AKA Moonwolf