Return to the Cooking Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Have you ever smoked fish?

Posted by shambo (My Page) on
Fri, Apr 5, 13 at 18:54

I've done turkey parts, whole chickens and parts, brisket, & various pork cuts in my smoker. I'd like to give fish a try now. In particular, I'm interested in any special rubs you've used for fish. I can't brine the fish because of the salt content, but I can always omit salt in a rub recipe. I know I would have to be careful to not overcook the fish so it doesn't get too dry.

Do you have favorite rub recipes? Favorite glaze or sauce recipes? Or favorite fish to use?

My husband & I both love smoked salmon on bagels with cream cheese, red onions, and tomatoes. I make my own low sodium bagels, and cream cheese is fairly low in sodium, especially the whipped variety. So the only thing I'm really missing is lower sodium smoked fish.

Thanks for any help you can give me.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Never mind, I can't get the link to work

This post was edited by momj47 on Tue, Apr 9, 13 at 22:34


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

I smoke fish all the time. I like all kinds of flavors. I use 7 or 8 types of seasoning as dry rubs. I enjoy my food not salty. I don't normally use salt unless I cook for company.

I like smoked salmon. Hot smoked (cooked) at 130F and cold smoked at 60F. My smoker is digitally controlled convection smoker, which can keep temperature to within one degree accuracy.

Fos cold smoked salmon (lox), for food safety I use regular recipes with makes it kind of salty. In your case, may be you can do some research as to what part of the preparing of cold smoked salmon is safety related (Salt brine, Pink Salt, and freezing). If salt is not part of the safety measure, than you can skip it. Or you can start with sushi grade salmon, which is a little more expensive.

I have 4 sides of salmon in my smoker now.

Have you tried smoked cheese? do it now before summer comes, when it becomes too hot.

dcarch


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

I have smoked quite a lot of fish, blue fish and salmon, both of which are oily, therefor good for smoking.

However, my experience won't be helpful to you because with my method brining is essential, not just for flavor but for physical reasons. The salt draws water from the fish, making it firmer. Then, the fish is air dried for a while, creating a pellicle on its surface. This, followed by smoking, gives the fish its characteristic qualities. It is very nice unheated for breakfast or a picnic with bread and cheese.

For your purpose, which is to avoid salt, dcarches suggestions are more appropriate.

Jim


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

I have also smoked a lot of blue fish and salmon but like Jim, I do brine and air dry first. I may have to giva a try with a dry rub when I find time to smoke again....

Thanks for the inspiration!
Alex


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Filtered or non-filtered? Oh, wait...

Never smoked them myself but have eaten quite a bit of smoked fish. Can be fabulous when done right. I personally like smoked items, fish, ham, etc, to be so smoky that your mouth feels like you just had a couple cigarettes after a few bites. That's why ham and most bacon are so disappointing to me these days. People have become so sugar addicted that they have to have sugar, glazes and stuff on everything rather than enjoy the taste of the meat or fish.

Oh and a good smoked cheese is a true treat.


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Shambo, I don't know what is the lowest temperature your smoker can keep. To smoke salmon (lox) it's best to smoke below 90F and to smoke cheese, below 100F. Therefore, better do it soon before the outside gets warm.

If your smoker cannot go below those temperatures, you may try to get one of those pellet "cold" smoke generators to go inside your smoker, such as A-maz-N tube smoker.

a few more random thoughts:

1. Chilean farmed salmon I think is the cleanest, but do your own research.

2. Food safety, -4F for 7 days after smoked salmon. Again, do your own research. Mine freezer goes down to -17F, and I keep the salmon in there for 14 days.

3. After brining, perhaps you can soak the salmon more and longer to get rid of more salt.

4. Smoked shrimps and scallops are WOW!

dcarch

This post was edited by dcarch on Sat, Apr 6, 13 at 7:43


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

I have smoked trout and salmon both. I prefer the trout hot smoked.

For smoked salmon that I eat on a bagel I use Alexa's recipe for Gravlax...delicious


Gravlax

2 Tbl white peppercorns

1 Tbl fennel seeds

2 ?3 cup kosher salt

1 ?3 cup sugar

2 -lb. center-cut, skin-on salmon filet

1 Cup dill sprigs, plus 1/3 cup chopped dill

1 ?4 cup aquavit (optional)

Mustard-Dill Sauce

. In a small food processor, pulse peppercorns and fennel seeds until coarsely ground; combine with salt and sugar. Stretch plastic wrap over a plate; sprinkle with half the salt mixture. Place salmon filet on top, flesh side up. Cover with remaining salt mixture, dill sprigs, and aquavit.

2. Fold plastic wrap ends around salmon; wrap tightly with more plastic wrap. Refrigerate the fish on the plate for 4872 hours, turning the package every 12 hours and using your fingers to redistribute the herb-and-spice-infused brine that accumulates as the salt pulls moisture from the salmon. The gravlax should be firm to the touch at the thickest part when fully cured.

3. Unwrap salmon, discarding the spices, dill, and brine. Rinse the filet under cold running water and pat dry with paper towels. Cover a large plate with the chopped dill. Firmly press the flesh side of the gravlax into the dill to coat it evenly.

4. Place gravlax skin side down on a board. With a long, narrow-bladed knife (use a granton slicer if you have one; the divots along the blade make for smoother, more uniform slices), slice gravlax against grain, on the diagonal, into thin pieces. Serve with mustard dill sauce or on knckebrd with minced onion. Refrigerate any remaining gravlax, wrapped in plastic wrap, for up to 2 weeks.


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Forgot to add ...I did try smoking oysters...interesting but not worth the effort.


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Shambo, we have smoked fish, mostly salmon but also black cod (aka sablefish), and bluefish. All three are high in oil which keeps them moist.

There is one tricky point to smoking fish IME. It's difficult to know when the moisture level is right. If you smoke for too long, the fish can end up dry. If you smoke for too little, the fish can have a wet, almost soggy texture. This is particularly true for fish that you eat a day or two after smoking. My preferred way to get to that sweet spot is to use a thermometer and get the fish to about 130F.

The fish cure I use is a mix of brown sugar, salt and optional seasonings. As jimster says, the point is to remove moisture. I don't know if the fish is salty after curing, it doesn't taste it to me but you may not want to take the chance.

We used to hot-smoke whole salmon and eat with the following sauce. Good with blue fish too. Recipe is from the SmokinTex booklet which came with our smoker.

Dill mustard sauce

4 Tbs Dijon mustard
1Tbs dry mustard
3 Tbs sugar
2 tbs white wine vinegar
1/3 cup vegetable oil
3 Tbs minced dill

Mix mustards, sugar and vinegar to a paste. Slowly beat in oil. Thicken to a mayo consistency. Stir in dill.

Has no salt! Keeps in refrigerator a long time. We once found it after months, tasted it and it seemed fine so we had it on our fish. We're still here to tell the tale.

We tried cold smoking fish using the cold plate that came with the smoker, but it never worked for us. We've smoked cheese this way and it was good, but fish takes too long.

Hot smoked salmon has a completely different taste and texture from cold smoked. You can also use leftover hot smoked in lots of great dishes - pasta, breakfast strata (easy and always a hit at brunches), spreads, chowders.

Cheryl


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Cheryl,

I envy your having sable available. Are you on the west coast? Sable is by far my favorite fish for smoking but I can rarely get any.

Jim


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Jim,

I'm in New Mexico, hundreds of miles from any ocean. I found frozen sable at Trader Joe's. I first thought it was mislabeled, but after defrosting and cooking, it really is sable. If you find it, beware - it's not scaled. I've never come across this before. The fish is boned and cut into largish pieces, but it's not scaled. I also bought frozen cod from TJ's, and that was boned, skinned and cut but there were scales everywhere which you couldn't see against the white fish.

When we lived in New England, fresh sable showed up once in a while but the price was in the nosebleed range so I only bought it once in a long while. At TJ's it was about $12/lb.

You can console yourself with lobstah! I'd trade with you in a heartbeat.

Cheryl


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Thanks, Cheryl!

There is a Trader Joe's about 30 min. from here which I've never visited. Time to make an expedition.

Jim


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Deleting duplicate post.

This post was edited by jimster on Sat, Apr 6, 13 at 19:40


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

There is a market in Grand Central Terminal, NYC.

Very high prices, but good stuff. I saw sable there, $29.99 a lb. Same price as Chilean Sea Bass.

dcarch

This post was edited by dcarch on Sat, Apr 6, 13 at 19:52


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Thanks for all your replies. Sorry it took me so long to get back to the forum. My children and their children ended up spending most of the day with us yesterday, and two granddaughters spent the night.

Anyhow, I'd like to try making smokey hot smoked salmon -- not lox. Cheryl thanks for the sauce recipe. Sounds good! My smoker doesn't really go lower than 200 degrees, but I think I'll just start some experimenting. I've purchased professionally smoked fish that was dry as sawdust, so I'm sure I can do as good as that.

The smokey flavor of meat coupled with a tasty but salt-free sauce adds amazing possibilities to our menus. I figure I could do the same thing with fish.

By the way, I have one really important question: Does smoking fish in an smoker make everything else smoked afterwards taste like fish? I regularly clean my smoker after each use, but it's hard to perfectly remove every bit of grease. The smoker is cleaned but not out-of-the-package pristine any longer. Do fish odors linger? Would it be OK to smoke the fish in a baking pan to contain the fatty drippings? What do you think?

Thanks again!


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

I see no problem with smoking the fish in a baking pan. I would put a rack in the pan so smoke can circulate under the fish.

Jim


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Deleting duplicate post.

This post was edited by jimster on Sun, Apr 7, 13 at 18:12


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

"-----By the way, I have one really important question: Does smoking fish in an smoker make everything else smoked afterwards taste like fish?---"

I don't clean the smoker, most people don't. I have smoked many kinds of food, I have not experienced food tastes cross contamination.

dcarch


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Thanks again for your feedback. I'm looking forward to giving this a try. Because of the lack of a brine, the end result will probably be more like baked fish with a smokey flavor.But that's going to be fine. Smokey fish on a bagel will be great! No worries about sodium overload. Thanks!


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

Elery says he's smoked fish at 180, rub whatever and hot smoke it, it's good.

We did wash the racks afterward but didn't notice any after taste otherwise.

Elery also brushed ours with grade B maple syrup when it was nearly done and gave it a nice glaze.

Annie


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

I have been trying so hard to be good but every time I read the title I say to myself -- " No- but I used to smoke cigarettes" Back to being good.........

My family are commercial fishermen and smoke salmon all the time I have never done so myself but I prefer hard smoked more like salmon jerky. The texture of soft smoked gives me the willies.


 o
RE: Have you ever smoked fish?

CL, I wrote the title and thought the same thing as you. But I was too lazy to reword it. I understand your feeling about texture. I don't care for lox -- it's too "slimy" and not smokey flavored. However, I do love smoked fish, but it has to be a firm fish. My husband really dislikes soft-fleshed fish.

Thanks, Annie, for the info from Elery. I'm going to take the plunge this weekend. I just got an email from our local fish monger, so I'll order some salmon to pick up on Saturday. Northern halibut is available too, so I think I'll order some of that for a non-smoking meal.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Cooking Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here