Replacing laptop battery questions

9 years ago

We have a 2011 Dell Inspiron 17, N1070, XP os laptop.

Most all the time when in use it connected to AC current, battery has seldom run down.

A few months ago started receiving messages, "you need to replace your battery", then more messages "you Need to replace battery soon". Computer stilled worked. A few days ago while using it began to act strange, went blank and black. Shut off and rebooted. Message came up "plugged in and not recharging" but computer would work with message popping up. Gave that message for about 3 days and then just this am I checked battery status and it said" 63% full and charging, soon it read 100% charged.

Again I am saying this laptop seldom used by battery only, usually connected to AC current.

Yesterday began to check in on a new battery. Dell says to use only a Dell replacement battery, and I must order from Dell as cannot not find in retail stores near. A battery store has a Ray O Vac one to fit and they guarantee it would work. We came home without, had to think.

My Questions:

1- Do I need to replace with a Dell or would the other brands
work as well? Is replacements that are offered on Amazon
and other websites okay to order?

2- Learned there were 6 cell and 9 cell batteries. which would be
better, still going to use mostly with AC current. (I need to
check this battery out for cell size, I will do).

3- Is this battery really as dead as the messages says it is after
using so much with AC or is this a scare tactic message from Dell because of the age. 3 1/2 years is really pretty good for a
battery.

Any advice or comments on this subject is very much appreciated.
We are very very Senior Citizens trying to stay in the game but get so tried of all the new learning and changes. Our minds just spins sometimes. I spend considerable time on the Cooking Forum and
have learned so much there, lurked here lots just reading and absorbing the posts, my first to post here.

Thank you in advance.

Shirl

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

aputernut
9 years ago
Try running on battery and run completely down, then recharge fully. it's good to run down once in awhile, then fully charge.
chas045
9 years ago
I doubt that Dell is trying to over sell batteries, but I agree that since it can say it is charging And you were supposedly running on ac when you got the blank screens, that something is off. Might I suggest that perhaps the ac connection plug at the computer is intermitant. If it shows a light when connected, is it sometimes off?

I have had batteries in general fail soon or last a long time. I did have a battery that would charge to 100% and only last 10 minutes and then only 5 minutes or less and discharge rapidly while sitting, so that could be the problem. Personally, I would buy a cheaper battery since long running time is not an issue for you. You could consider it a diagnostic test. Problem goes away; it was the battery. Problem stays; its something else.
Related Discussions
Will a Generic Battery Work in My Dell Laptop
Q
Comments (5)
A risk with third party batteries is that they not-infrequently are lower quality and have less capacity than OEM versions. I personally never take the chance. A dead battery in a laptop is like a needed major repair on a car - you go the cheaper route if the rest still works fine, or it's a good excuse to buy a whole new replacement. But even when going the cheaper route and getting a replacement battery, i think it's a false economy to buy an aftermarket brand. Capacity is rated in milliAmp hours, for laptops it's usually a number in the single digit thousands ( 3000-9999 mAh hours)
...See More
going from electric to battery in a laptop???
Q
Comments (4)
Read your manual. It probably has the guidelines best suited for 'your laptops design and its circuitry . Toshiba here was first time ever taken out of the factory box about mid December 2007, so its 1.5 yrs old, I don't know how long it sat on shelf - its battery right now shows a 6% wear level, 44000 mWh design capacity new / currently 41151 mWh at 100% of charge. Probably more than 99 percent of the time its on the AC adapter and runs 24/7. Sleeps after 100 minutes of non use which really doesn't happen every day like I should. I should force sleep for it & then maybe I'd force more normal sleep on me too ;) Battery is under the left palm rest where I feel no heat. It would be rare for me in the things I do to shut down windows before moving the laptop while the on battery. Only have the one ac adapter, meant to buy another for a second location but price always makes me dizzy.
...See More
Disconnect Laptop Battery when on A/C?
Q
Comments (3)
The provided link address far more than my question, rather the claim in PC Magazine. The claim is the battery will live longer if you remove it when A/C is connected. There is nothing here about how much energy is consumed, simply the constant charging of a battery when the computer is on A/C for long periods of time take life/longevity out of the battery compared to the case where the battery is sitting disconnected during these long periods of time with only it leakage current for a load. The article also recommends not running the battery down as compared to recharging it as soon, in the discharge cycle, as possible.
...See More
leaving battery in a laptop ........
Q
Comments (5)
I leave mine in (but 'exercise' it now and then like mikie advised). I think my original Toshiba battery lasted about a year and a half. Then I bought a battery from a local computer guy, and it's the most awesome battery, lasting and lasting - better than Toshiba's imo. The reason I bought the battery from someone else, too, is that the store where I bought my laptop from would honour their warranty for the battery and give me a free replacement, but they wanted to send the laptop away to analyze the battery/my laptop, etc. It's like they didn't believe me that the battery was dead - ha. So I bought a different battery altogether. Probably more than you wanted to know. lol
...See More
exgm
9 years ago
In numerous cases, Dell in particular, if you flip over the laptop there is a pushbutton on the battery and a series of LEDs that light up to indicate the level of charge when you push the button (assumes the charge circuit is operational and that the battery can hold a charge). I would start by checking Dell's website to see if the battery is part of any recall, many were.
If you rarely use it on battery I wouldn't spend any extra on a larger capacity one. Third party ones should be used with caution, quality is often lacking.

Personally I have used Lenmar replacements, for laptops and camcorders, when competitively priced. So far I have been lucky, some reviewers seem to diss them.

I would definitely factor in the cost of a new battery vs purchase of a new warrantied unit also.
mikie_gw
9 years ago
Use it on battery - see how long it works.
Charge it and use it till it runs it down a 2nd time.
About the only way to tell what kind of life is left.

If always on a/c power maybe just leave it out and put your adapter on a UPS.. small nice ones retail about $69 and sometime online maybe for half that price. Watch which batteries it has... 3-5yrs is the better sealed lead acid ones that actually do last that long.
exgm
9 years ago
I have yet to see a lead acid battery on any laptop, conceded they may exist. I can easily rig a gel-cell for an external power supply no problem, but it sure won't be integrated into the unit.

NiCad, NiMh and Lith Ion are the predominant types in order of age, Lith Ion currently dominant.
mikie_gw
9 years ago
Actually what I said.... sealed lead acid ... usually is a AGM sealed lead acid battery ---- for a UPS.

This post was edited by mikie on Sun, Oct 12, 14 at 18:04
exgm
9 years ago
@mikie, my bad.
Still, I'd put that investment into a new battery, ups is rather a restrictive tether.

Replacing laptop battery questions

Comments (7)

aputernut

chas045

Related Discussions

exgm

mikie_gw

exgm

mikie_gw

exgm

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US