Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
mistepmom

hard water marks on glasses

MIStepMom
19 years ago

Can anyone tell me how to clean hard water marks from drinking glasses? Our old dishwasher just didn't do a good job even when I put the jet dry in it. We have alot of iron in our water, but also have a water softener. We now have a new dishwasher, but the damage was done from the old dishwasher. Any tips on how to make my glasses clear and sparkling again?

Thanks Carol

Comments (36)

  • kathyg_in_mi
    19 years ago

    Don't use powdered soap in the dishwasher with hard water, only liquids. The powders don't all ways disolve completely and are abrasive.
    Kathy G in MI

  • jamielovescoffee__az
    19 years ago

    Good ideas above. If it is just hard water deposits then it will usually come off with the vinegar. If the glasses have actual etching, I think that means they are permanently scratched.

    Good luck! Don't you just hate hard water!

  • lindac
    19 years ago

    If your glasses are etched there is nothing that will make them better. Etching of glass is like scratches on polished furniture... You can't remove the scratches....just perhaps hide them
    But if the marks are caused by hard water, a good soak in a white vinegar solution should help.
    Linda C

  • MIStepMom
    Original Author
    19 years ago

    Thanks for all the great advice. The glasses don't seem to be etched, so I am going to try the vinegar tonight. I will let you know if I had any success.

    Thanks again

  • Lynne_SJO
    19 years ago

    Don't use the LIQUID soap if you have a Bosch dishwasher. It is against the manufacturer's recommendations. We also have very hard water and I use three things together:

    1) Powdered cascade
    2) Jet Dry
    3) Glass Magic (a powder that comes in a small green box kept near where the DW soap is and designed to prevent hard water spots) -- it is great. I really do notice the difference when I forget to use it.

    Lynne

  • joepyeweed
    19 years ago

    Jet Dry and glass magic may work but i bet vinegar does the same thing and is awhole lot cheaper... look at the active ingredients and compare ...

  • Audrey_NY
    18 years ago

    Carol,
    I have tried every tip mentioned on an old cloudy wine decanter - no luck. In desparation I tried liquid calgon with a little warm water and left it for a day. I did shake the bottle occasionally and Wow it is clean. I am not sure why I have this around. I think I used it on the boys white t-shirts when they were home.
    Good luck! aej

  • olcia
    16 years ago

    Oh, I think you should buy something that will help you dealing with hard water and not with it's results.

  • dagmarskodis_adelphia_net
    13 years ago

    THANK YOU FOR THE INPUT.LATELY MY DISHES HAVE A STAIN OF WHITE CLOUDY SUBTANCE ON THE GLASSES AND MY DINNER PLATES.
    HAVE WELL WATER WITH LOT OF LIME IN IT. """" HELP """"
    WILL USE VINEGAR IF NOTHING ELSE WORKES.
    SINCERELY,
    DM SKODIS
    HAPPY NEW YEAR TO YOU AND YOURS!!!!!

  • saferproducts
    13 years ago

    I had that same problem, dagmar. I am also on a well, and I thought my dishes were ruined. They are a dark brown, and after running them through the dishwasher once they became a dingy white. For years I struggled with it, using everything I could think of. Recently, with my pregnancy, I discovered just what all is in dish detergent and was disgusted. Dishwasher detergent is probably the most harmful item in your household, and every time you run it it emits dangerous toxins into the air. So, that being said, I decided to switch to an all-natural dish detergent called Diamond Brite. I switched, not expecting anything but to have a safer product that was not killing my family. Well, it was an extra bonus that the first time I ran the dishes it took the white film off, and literally left my dishes and silverware sparkling clean! This may sound insane, but I bought a couple of bottles of it and gave as part of a Christmas basket to friends who also are on wells. They are hooked!

  • carl_w2003_yahoo_com
    13 years ago

    Vinegar didn't work and I see various posts about people saying it does. I tried it and the white residue marks are still there. The person at the place we bought the dishwasher (it's a new dishwasher) said not to use liquid detergent in it, just the powder form. So ...now what do I do????

  • ks_toolgirl
    13 years ago

    "Holy post-resurrection, Batman", lol!

    Actually, I have a suggestion to share... I learned this trick from my (late) best friend, for cleaning years of deposits from antique/vintage glassware.

    IF it's truly "deposits", & not "pitting", it's worth a try! (If it's pitting, that - as stated above - means particles of the surface glass are literally gone, as opposed to unwanted crud & minerals on the surface causing cloudy appearance).

    The solution? Denture cleaning tablets! I know - crazy, right? Lol! My most frequent use for them is old glass vases - years of holding water for a period of time, followed by rinsing & storage again, can REALLY let deposits build up.
    I drop a tablet or 2 into the glass or vase, fill with hot water, & WAIT. Overnight. (Not easy, when you're anxious to find out if you've come across a gem, or a dud!). For everyday glassware, where outside also needs cleaning, I fill a sink with hot water.. Drop 2 or 3 (or more) tablets in & add glassware. Let soak overnight.
    Does it always work? Nope. But when it does, it's great to get the yuck off, without scrubbing & potentially scratching the glass!
    Does it solve the hard water/dishwasher problem? Nope. But if you try it, and it helps, perhaps it's worth a monthly sink-soak to keep them looking pretty?

    For the record, I've never bought name-brand, always the store-brand of whichever store I'm in when I need them. (Cheap, I am!).

    Also - I'm not suggesting that anyone put the tablets into the actual dishwasher. (Just a disclaimer, there, lol).

  • sales_CitriClean_net
    13 years ago

    Here's another fix. A new company in Florida sells a product called CitriClean. More info or buy on line at www.CitriClean.net

    Here is a link that might be useful: CitriClean of Florida

  • casey123
    13 years ago

    I was having the same problem just last week and found out that if you buy lemi shine you may be able to solve your problem.
    I tried it and it worked. my dishes are nice and clean.
    What i did and this worked for me was that i filled out the soap dish with the lemi shine (I empty my dishwasher. No dishes were inside) and then run it like i would normally run a cycle. Then I put my dishes and because i only have one compartment to put the soap, I use every day 1/2 of my regular soap and on top i use the lemi shine and so far so good.
    hope this help.

  • joycedrisc_aol_com
    12 years ago

    Vinegar in dishwasher cycle didn't work for me. Next will try denture tablets.

  • whirlie54mn_aol_com
    12 years ago

    how do you put the vinegar in? Just fill up where the detergent goes? I have been using cascade and my glasses are now white and the silverware even has a grit feeling to them. I put in jet dry but it seems to be getting worse. I have washed the same load about 3 times now!

  • mcacchione_comcast_net
    12 years ago

    I have the same question whirlie does. I too use Cascade, for years and never had this problem until now. I guess I will just try putting the vinegar under the lower rack and run it. I think the DW has the build up and needs a good cleaning.

  • kajer31_hotmail_com
    12 years ago

    White vinegar works on glass OK. I use CLR on the brown residue in my dishwasher, on my fiberglass jet tub and on my old porcelain sink. And I occasionally use Brillo to clean my white dishes. Hard well water is a constant problem but these solutions do help.

  • SharperClean
    12 years ago

    use vinegar and just rub gently with dish cloth, definetly sport will disappear.

  • Lesyeuxbleu
    12 years ago

    I had bad water spots on a Chemex coffee maker (I always wash/rinse and air dry). Vinegar did not work on it, but I used Bar Keepers Friend on it and it worked. It took a bit, but got the stains off. I want to say that I made sort of a paste and rubbed it on, then let it sit for a while. It takes rust off of other things really well, too.
    Best of luck

  • kmdawson1110_gmail_com
    12 years ago

    I obviously have very hard water at my apartment. I didnt have any problems for the first few months, then all the sudden, my black dishes are white and my glass dishes are dirty looking. I just tried the vinegar and baking soda and it didnt do anything at all. Theres no way I can afford a water softener. What do I do??!!

  • krissie55
    12 years ago

    Use Lime-a-Way to clean dishes. Then always use white vinegar in the rinse dispenser of dishwasher in hopes it will prevent a repeat of white deposit.

  • ks_toolgirl
    12 years ago

    Joyce - in your last post, you'd mentioned trying denture soaking tablets, never heard back... Did they work?
    It's been a while, perhaps she hasn't been around? I'd just love to hear if it worked - or not. (It's a crap-shoot.. Sometimes it works like magic, sometimes it doesn't).

  • Cynthia A
    12 years ago

    I had the same problem until this... I poured in 1/2 cup of bleach with Cascade powder soap and bingo... it worked! After getting all my dishes cleaned and removed all the etched/cloudy looking glasses, stained silverware, I'm down to 1/4 cup for each wash. I will not use Jet Dry again!

  • kvoutilainen_yahoo_com
    12 years ago

    It's goofy but I swear it works.

    Instead of soap in the dish washer, put in one packet of crystal lite lemon flavor (the drink powder. (use the size that makes one picture of lemon drink)

    Then just run your dishwasher through it's regular cycle.

    The citric acid cleans the lime scale of the crystal and leaves the dishwasher shiny clean too.

  • albert_135   39.17°N 119.76°W 4695ft.
    12 years ago

    Just based upon recollection of high school chemistry, which I acknowledge has faded considerably, I would expect lemon juice in the rinse dispenser to work better than vinegar.

  • galekw_comcast_net
    12 years ago

    Your glasses are etched because you use too much dishwasher detergent. I had the same problem and the repairman told me to fill only half way. Have not had a problem since.

  • badsocref
    12 years ago

    Probably the best thing you can do to avoid deposits/etching is to wash and dry glasses by hand immediately after using them. The hard water deposits should be removed pretty easily with any acid (vinegar, lemon juice, etcetera). Give the glass a good long soak in the acid of your choice. If the glass still looks milky, it's likely etched. There's nothing that you can do to remove the etching, but you can hide the etched appearance somewhat with WD40 (yes, the "lubricant"). Spray/wipe some WD40 on the glass, and let it dry overnight. Wash THOROUGHLY! There's something akin to tallow in the WD40 that creates a coating on the glass. It won't be perfect, but should look better - at least for a while. Note that this is not an intended use of WD40. Don't sue me if you don't properly wash the glass and get sick.

  • KenCane
    12 years ago

    States Ban Phosphate-Laden Dishwasher Soap
    July 2011 started a ban in sixteen states of the sale of dishwasher detergents that contain high levels of phosphates, a source of pollution in lakes and streams.
    Stores will not be allowed to sell detergent with more than 0.5 percent phosphorous. The bans do not apply to commercial dishwashing products, and detergents for hand-washing dishes generally contain no phosphorus.
    States instituting the rule include Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, New Hampshire, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin.

    One major cause of problems in dishwashers and cloths washers is most people use way too much detergent, more is NOT better. In a dishwasher fill the cup half way and use Cascade Complete liquid. Powder does not dissolve as well and be sure your rinse agent (JetDry) is full. If you are using a HE cloths washer use 2 tablespoons of 2X HE detergent. If you have a mildew smell in your front load washer then that is soap buildup, use a cup of white vinegar on its hottest or "tub clean" cycle to clean it.
    DO NOT mix bleach in your dishwasher!

    A posted comment:"my black dishes are white and my glass dishes are dirty looking "
    Try soaking them in CLR, if that does not work then they are permanently etched and there is nothing you can do.

    A posted comment:"I occasionally use Brillo to clean my white dishes"
    Noooooooo no no, you are scratching your dishes making them worse. Never use Brillo pads or Comet type cleaners on anything except stainless steel and that is not even necessary. If you do use one of these products on stainless than only rub with the grain, if you rub cross grain than you will permanently scratch the surface giving it an old warn out look.

    Here is a link that might be useful: NPR, Dishes Still Dirty? Blame Phosphate-Free Detergent

  • coffeegrinder
    12 years ago

    I tried the vinegar, doesn't work. I let it sit overnight. I have a glass jar with a small mouth that curves outward so brushes and cloths are not an option to clean the interior. I swirled and sloshed it around periodically but after a day the spots were still there. I am now trying the denture tablets.

  • gdeann
    12 years ago

    We fought hard water for years and finally won the battle with a product called Lemi-Shine. It can be purchased at Walmart, Dillon's etc. For the horrible buildup the first time or two, fill both dispensers with the product. Good luck! You will love it!

  • cleaningqueen
    9 years ago

    Carol can't thank you enough for your liquid Calgon solution. I never take the time to feed back but I am so grateful that you shared your solution. I have a faboulous Waterford Crystal limited edition Carafe and as I come from Waterford it is a prized possession. For some seven years I have tried to find a solution to the cloudiness and terrible water marks. I have tried every solution but nothing shifted it, in fact things like bleach made it worse. I didn't expect your solution to work but here I am 24 hours later with my carafe restored to its former glory and not a mark in sight!!! Thank you Carol and good luck to anybody else seeking the cure. Eternally grateful cleaningqueen

  • emma
    9 years ago

    I soak my glasses and any other dishes that are cloudy in vinegar water, the put them in the dish washer. The come out sparkling like new. I do this about once a year.


  • preacherswife36
    8 years ago

    cleaningqueen - I googled liquid Calgon, but there are several products. Which one did you use? Your comment gave me hope, but I want to buy the right thing.

  • lynnben
    8 years ago

    I have used vinegar in my dishwasher to help with the spotting on the glasses, which for me did not work, and my silverware became dull. I have stopped that and will try some denture tablets to remove the old spots I have used them in my toilet bowl to remove the hard water mark and it works with gentle scrubbing. I will try the other ideas in the dishwasher. Thanks, Hard water in AZ