Return to the Cleaning Tips Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

Posted by kathy547 (My Page) on
Thu, May 27, 10 at 18:36

My carpet is old shag that we can't afford to replace until the future sometime. I haven't cleaned it in several years so I know it's filthy. I live in a rural area so renting a shampooer will be difficult time-wise (I won't have enough time to clean the carpet & return the machine in a timely manner). Don't want to hire someone because my budget can't afford it. Besides, I want to have my own so I can clean it whenever I want. I have done comparison shopping at Walmart, Home Depot, Sears, & online. Shop vacs are cheaper so I was wondering what the difference was? Has anyone used a shop vac to clean your carpet, & what were the results?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

Um, well, a carpet shampooer will actually shampoo the carpet, using brushes, and then vacuum up the cleaning solution.

A shop vac will vacuum up loose dirt, and suck up spilled liquids. They won't shampoo the carpet.

Were you just planning on throwing water on the carpet and vacuuming that up? If so, that's a bad idea. Too wet.

The shampooers don't put down a huge amount of water while working.


 o
RE: Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

Hello, Kathy!
Well, I think Mary advices above are really good, and I add the information that maybe you can afford a good carpet cleaner, with wich you can make dry cleanings or cleanings with water without any problems, and combine a cleaning with a shampoo, too.

Here is a link that might be useful: A good carpet cleaner


 o
RE: Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

Do not get a Hoover Floormate. I bought one and it permanently broke after only two uses. I lost $175 on a piece of junk that was actually recommended here on Garden web.


 o
RE: Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

Thanks for all the response. Why I was wondering about the difference between shop vacs & shampooers was because I've heard one or two people mention they've used a shop vac on their carpets. I want something not too expensive but not so cheap that I'm going to have to replace it every couple of years (like the vaccuum cleaners I've gotten at Walmart).


 o
RE: Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

Kathy

I think you will have to change your way of thinking. You want something cheap, even after your experience with vacuum cleaners from Walmart. One you have to replace every couple of years.

Years ago, Bissell sold a carpet cleaning adaptor, which could be attached to a shop vacuum. Shop-Vac even sold similar, but are no longer available.

If you were to use a shop vacuum to extract the liquid from the carpeting, you would need a narrow slotted attachment, a way to apply the liquid cleaning solution and a way to agitate the solution into the carpeting. It can be done, but you would need to know what you are doing and know how to set up the shop vac for "liquid pick up".

The easiest thing to do is purchase a carpet cleaner like a Hoover SteamVac, use it properly and maintain the equipment properly.


 o
RE: Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

After a flood in our basement I tried using the shop vac to extract the water from the carpet. All I can say is don't even bother! My shop vac has excellent suction but the only way to maintain suction on the carpet was on my hands and knees.
Another solution might be a powder cleaner such as the one Resolve makes. You sprinkle the powder on the carpet, rub it in with a brush and let it dry. Then you just vacuum it up. I use it on the carpet in my car and it does a good job. It's not quite as good as a true carpet cleaning but better than nothing.


 o
RE: Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

Kathy,
Let's get the terms straight. A carpet shampooer is just that. It has brushes, water, and shampoo. A steam cleaner/carpet extractor is another machine and the process is differant. I would just go out and buy a Hoover Platinum Carpet Steamer. It's going to B more than U want 2 spend, but U get what U pay 4. My old Hoover is 17 years old and starting to leak. I think it was $279, all those years ago. Go and buy it at Sears so if you don't like it U can get your $ back. I am going to go buy 1 as this old Hoover is on it's last legs.

Do not use that powdered cleaner on shag! It works as I have used it 4 years, between the shampoo and steam extraction, and my carpet is white. It's just very dense and the powder just stays on the top of the pile. I also spend $ on vacs and they not Kmart junk. I just use my Rainbow, as it just uses water and I dump it in the toilet. If had to use my Kirby, Electrolux, or Tri-Star would be changing the bag after 4 passes. I use them all after the Rainbow but do not go through all of the bags. You will have that in that shag and it will be like drywall dust with the vac U have. U will hate yourself. Listen to GE Guy as I think I know who he is. He knows his stuff.


 o
RE: Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

I don't know if you live near a big box home improvement store, but many places will rent their carpet cleaners by the week or partial week and it will still be cheaper than buying a machine such as the Hoover or Bissell. We bought a house than needed major carpet cleaning a few years ago. We rented a machine from Home Depot for the entire week (7 days) for $100. Don't bother with shampoo--it only attracts more dirt once it's dry. I just used extremely hot water with a bit of vinegar mixed in to get rid of any smells. The carpets turned out great.


 o
RE: Carpet shampooer or shop vac?

I'm answering 4 years late, but oh well… We have two carpets that are 9 feet circular, shag and synthetic nylon. Buy or rent a carpet cleaner with the best suction (I've heard the big green bissel is good). Vaccuum well, then lay your rug on your deck outside. Make a solution to clean it with: hot water (cold if wool), pet enzyme formula, vinegar, dish detergent….. Hose (soak) the entire rug down, pour the solution over the really dirty spots, get down and scrub with fingers and hands. Turn it over, pour some solution back there, too and hose through the back of the rug until water runs clear. Turn it back over and use vacuum to rinse and suck until water runs clear. Hang it over the deck rail to dry or drape over some deck furniture. Make sure the forecast is not for rain!!! That's what i do. Labor intensive and takes two people depending on size of rug, but it works.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Cleaning Tips Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here