I think the dark walnut would look lovely on the front door especially if you have white trim and light colored walls.

But, don't stress overmuch about matching various wood stains. If you have any wood furniture, you're probably going to wind up with a multiplicity of different wood stains in your home anyhow. We certainly have. For example, from where I'm sitting right this minute in my great room I can see...

* clear coated mahogany kitchen and great room cabinets
* Brazilian Koa (Tigerwood) floors
* Mahogany stained double front doors
* Pine windows and interior doors and baseboards stained with a customized mixture of stains that comes close but does not exactly match the mahogany stain on the front doors (the stain is slightly lighter and redder)
* A very old pine bookcase that my dad built when I was a kid that is stained with Jacobean stain (almost black! - I only remember the stain color name because he let me pick it and I chose the color because Jacob was a family name)
* A dark walnut kitchen table
* A dark maple grandfather clock
* A set of cherry end tables
* a clear coated yellow pine sofa table and
* a rosewood piano belonging to my nephew (that we're holding onto until he has a place to keep it)

And somehow it all looks GREAT together....very very homey. I'm not sure it would look nearly as homey and welcoming if all the various pieces of wood in the house "matched". Don't stress. Your new home is going to be beautiful!

I think dark doors would look pretty with everything you have so far.

Thank you jjdcl and bevangel. I appreciate both your words.

Bevangel, your home sounds delightful! Beyond homey, I can't even imagine how stunning a mahogany kitchen would be. It's so much easier to see someone's complete home and love it than for me to build the home I will love.