Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
stucco vs hardie plank

Posted by crazyone (My Page) on
Mon, Oct 12, 09 at 23:55

has any one had both stucco (put on by a reputable stucco firm) and hardie plank on houses and can you state which you prefer and why?

we are in Zone 3 which gets all seasons which factor in but we have always liked the look of stucco. it seems so much pleasing to the eye. I have seen some of the hardie houses done with a few different applications and thought them lovely but our house is a basic ranch style with 1 dormer on each side and we do not want the horizontal lines to be all you see.

opinions and photos greatly appreciated


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

I had been thinking for a long time we were going with a fiber cement clapboard look (like Hardie Plank). Lately, I've been thinking about stucco as well. I'll be interested in the answers.

One question I have is this: can the stucco products be pre-tinted thru and thru, so that the colour can't actually peel or wear away? If yes, then the next question is: does this colouring fade over time?

I understand the pre-painted Hardie Planks will hold their paint a lot longer (3 to 5 times?), but they still will begin to show wear and eventually need to be repainted. Can this be avoided entirely with stucco?

Found this link. May be useful to some.
http://www.cement.org/homes/brief15.asp


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

we have had stucco on our last 2 homes and they were colored thru and thru and they never faded but again were light colors.
and this whole hardie plank issue is scaring me right off however the architecht and 3 builders were swearing it was the answer to all the problems.. HMMMM


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

Real Portland cement based stucco or the 'synthetic' junk?

The real thing has a good record.

The fake stuff a poor record.

I am not a particular lover of cement based siding like Hardi, but mot of the problems have been paint related, not the base material.


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

I wish other things in this world held up like Hardie plank. Mine was installed and painted 13 years ago. Paint bonded to it, you can't even get a fingernail under it to peel it off. What more could you ask for? It's one of those rare things, you repaint it cause you're tired of the color!

Here is a link that might be useful: Gray Hardie


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

I have seen some of the hardie houses done with a few different applications and thought them lovely but our house is a basic ranch style with 1 dormer on each side and we do not want the horizontal lines to be all you see.

We had similar concerns, so we went with a mix of board and batten and lap. The boards (panel) and lap are Nichiha, and the battens are Hardie. The exposed foundation is getting stucco.

I appologize for the quality of the pic. It was taken with a cell phone on a really dull day, and it looks it.


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

@crazyone
> this whole hardie plank issue is scaring me right off

What scares you about the Hardie Plank?


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

I would say it depends somewhat on where you live. We are in central California, with plenty of earthquakes. Stucco does not hold up well when the earth moves.

We used hardiplank and are extremely happy! Ours is a multistory victorian, with dormers. It looks perfect (IMHO) and our friends and neighbors agree. Also, the hardiplank is pretty much impervious to fire - another consideration in my neck of the woods.


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

I agree, it depends where you live in some instances.

Down here in S. Louisiana Hardie Plank is a dream come true for many reasons, the main ones being it's impervious to termites and moisture.

Stucco is known to crack down here due to sinking ground and then the moisture factor is a killer. One tiny leak and you have huge, expensive problems.


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

We had stucco on the front of our old house and HardiPlank on the covered rear porch. We had no problems with the stucco, and the HardiPlank was ok, but after 3 years, when we sold the house, it was looking like it would need to be painted in the next year or so. And that was a covered porch! After only 3 years! The stucco was exposed to the weather in the front, and we didn't have any problems.


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

We've had HardiPlank on our home in upstate NY for almost 4 years. Winters are severe with over 200 inches of snow (actually, it is probably much higher--I am in denial). Wind is fierce, lots of rain, etc. Our hardiplank was factory painted and has held up perfectly. Not a peeling section anywhere. Still looks brand new.

Photobucket



 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

jojoco-
Looks great, and you must have a climate that tests the limit of this stuff. That's not to say that there isn't an occasional batch of siding that is defective, but, in searching online for reports of problems, I haven't found large numbers of people who were dissatisfied with this product. And since it is widely used, I'd expect Google to turn up thousands or tens of thousands of complaints if there was a basic deficiency with this material.

A few people who reported delamination problems were in locales where they had large drifts of snow that were up against the siding for months at a time. I'm curious to know if you allow drifts to sit against your siding or not.


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

jojoco what a stunning home, very lovely!!


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

thanks! Here is my home in the winter. No special treatment. Fact is, we tend to steer clear of the shoveling jobs.

Photobucket



Photobucket


jo


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

A picture really is worth a thousand words!
Beautiful looking house Jo and a great reinforcement for those of of worried about the wear of Hardi in cold weather climates.
It looks brand new and gorgeous!


 o
RE: stucco vs hardie plank

Jojoco - my husband is in love with your house!! We are looking at the Arbordale/Southerland Donald Gardner plan, but now my husband wants to throw the Fitzgerald in the mix because of your house photo!! Do you have any interior photos of the house plan that you could share?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here