Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Posted by renton123 (My Page) on
Fri, Oct 11, 13 at 15:27

We had decided on doing ebony stained kitchen cabinets. However seeing so many beautiful white kitchens online I'm now having second thoughts. Wondering if anyone else has dark/black kitchen cabinets and loves or hates them. We will have a decent amount of natural light coming in. Thank you in advance. This forum has been very helpful through our build.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Our friends bought a house with black cabinets and they look good. The previous owner's were a little rough on the cabinets but left some touch up pens that work really well.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I personally do not like them... but it is not my house!

FWIW... I dislike white also.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Not my style but I've seen some kitchens with black cabinets that were absolutely gorgeous. (I can admire a style without wanting it for myself!)

I'd probably advise against black cabinetry if your kitchen is small or will get very little natural light because the black might make it feel overcrowded and even smaller. But if the kitchen is large and well-lit, go for it.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I'm not a fan. At most I would want them on lower cabinets only with a lighter color above. Or better yet, just on an island and do the other cabs in another color. I suggest you go to houzz.com and search for kitchens with black cabinets and see if you like the look or not.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I am currently in a rental with a black kitchen - with deep fire engine red walls if you can imagine. Although I am sure they can be done much better as this is an old house with bad cabinets that they just painted black to 'update' them - I do not like it. It's dark and very intense. I do not enjoy being in the kitchen and alas no dishwasher so I am currently spending a lot of time in there!

If you love it and decide to go ahead - be sure you plan for a space with a lot of natural light (windows on at least 2 sides) and that your lighting plan is very well thought out.

Do you have any inspiration pictures to share?

edit: clarified the cabinets age and quality - has nothing to do with it being a farm house and looking back that is how my original post read. Sorry.

This post was edited by Autumn.4 on Sun, Oct 13, 13 at 14:03


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Have you ever owned a black car? Black tends to show all kinds of dirt. And it sucks the light out of the room. Forget having abundant natural light. That's only a plus in the daytime. If you ever want to use the kitchen after dark, you'll need a lot of extra lighting to make work. And, the only time black would be a non trendy choice that could stand the test of time is if the home is very modern, and you're talking glossy black slab cabinets. Or, you're talking a more rustic country style home, where you have more traditional cabinets with "antiquing". Anything else, like the current "espresso shaker" or "black island" is going to SCREAM "so 2000 teens". Just like whitewashed oak screams "so 80's".


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Black kitchens can be tricky. If you aren't careful, they can get very dark...

From Farmhouse plans

Having lots of light and white walls, can balance things out a bit...

From Farmhouse plans

From Farmhouse plans

Or you could choose to have a black and white kitchen...always a classic look.

From Farmhouse plans

From Farmhouse plans

From Farmhouse plans

From Farmhouse plans

From Farmhouse plans


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I would love to have black cabinets, as long as they were from a better cabinet maker. AND lots of light, what company are you thinking of? What would be the rest of the house built ins, etc?


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I am also planning to have black cabinets in my kitchen. I love how elegant and classy black kitchen cabinets look when done correctly. I would suggest looking at all different black colors and not a shiny gloss black. Having enough light is key to a black kitchen. I plan to have LED lights installed under the cabinets above counter top and under cabinets close to the floor to give more lighting. My entire back side of kitchen/living area will be all glass. Please post pics when you start. I am in full research mode on them. Good luck! :)


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I am also planning to have black cabinets in my kitchen. I love how elegant and classy black kitchen cabinets look when done correctly. I would suggest looking at all different black colors and not a shiny gloss black. Having enough light is key to a black kitchen. I plan to have LED lights installed under the cabinets above counter top and under cabinets close to the floor to give more lighting. My entire back side of kitchen/living area will be all glass. Please post pics when you start. I am in full research mode on them. Good luck! :)


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I would not use dark cabinets above the counter height because reflected light is just too important in a kitchen.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

It depends on the style of the home and how much extra light your are OK with adding. Don't do it if you aren't willing to at least double the lighting though.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

dd has black cabinets lighter granite, floors and walls, lots of windows very open concept it looks/works
great
i'm a huge white cabinet fan would take her kitchen in a minute.....


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Black cabinets are not my cup of tea, but they can look nice in the right setting. I don't think they're right for every application: You must have the natural light, and you must balance out the dark with plenty of light colors -- walls, curtains, whatever.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Thanks for the opinions guys and gals! We've decided to continue with our first gut instinct and go with them. Also going with a gray quartz countertop and SS appliances. I know not everyone's cup of tea, but realized we're building for our tastes :) Here's our original inspiration photo from Houzz

I'll post pics when complete (which should be around Jan)...unless it looks awful ;)


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Thanks for the opinions guys and gals! We've decided to continue with our first gut instinct and go with them. Also going with a gray quartz countertop and SS appliances. I know not everyone's cup of tea, but realized we're building for our tastes :) Here's our original inspiration photo from Houzz

I'll post pics when complete (which should be around Jan)...unless it looks awful ;)


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

renton - haha! I am sure it will look very nice. I wouldn't dare post a pic of the rental red and black combo. What were they thinking???????


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I actually like it. make sure you have lots of natural light.
See link.

Here is a link that might be useful: Black and White kitchen


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I considered a black island, but decided against it due to the door sample - felt it would be too dark overall. I did end up doing a hutch we call the coffee station (DH coffeemaker there) in the hallway between kitchen and laundry room. The stairway going to lower level, coat closet and garage door are also in this small hallway. The hutch is the first thing you see when you enter through the garage door and I love it.

What style is your house?

Here is a link that might be useful: Our kitchen, more pictures


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Uh oh... Autumn.4 I'm doing a red/black combo.
Would you post pictures just so I can see if I'm making a mistake?


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Oh my gosh Lori - are you serious (about a picture)? I'd have to do some rearranging (picture arm sweeping across the counter knocking all junk on floor) before I ever DARE take a photo. You have to remember this is a rental....an old home rental. So it's not done well. Old cabs - doors that are so wide you open them and they are wider than the base cabinets, horrible lighting. In fact - the light cover above the sink is being held up by kid space martian duct tape. They just painted them all black and slapped red paint up. When I look at it I think red-rum, red-rum....

I will see what I can do for you, but it wouldn't come until tomorrow after football. Maybe it can be your ANTI-inspiration picture.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

lori-okay here are a couple. The first one I actually took a couple of weeks ago to fondly remember my children and hubby hand washing dishes. That is not something I see every day and it could be the one and only, lol!

It was a sunny day and note how much light is lost when it gets to the cabinets. Swallows it right up. The next picture I took today and it's by another window. It probably doesn't help that the paneling was also painted black. Enjoy. ;)

 photo photo5_zps15d0be00.jpg

 photo photo3_zps8d861179.jpg


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Autumn, that is truly horrible....but Black and red could be done really classy and look really nice.
Loribug, have you drawn it out and colorized it to see what it'll look like?
If you search houzz kitchens using black+red as search criteria there are a lot. And most are really modern and mostly really in your face. I think the ones that work best are where the red is just a dash of color, like this or
as in red tiles mixed in the backsplash or red bar stools as a punctuation mark.
I think the OP inspiration kitchen is really pretty. Notice that all surfaces are highly reflective, including the ceiling.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

Ok wow.... That is truly horrible.

I was thinking more like this.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

and this. only with the Island black. This kitchen is similar to my layout...


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I tried to warn you how bad it was done here! Rentals are hard to come by around here and we got what we got. I will say that it's all new - new paint, new flooring, etc. so it's CLEAN. Not my choice in decor but it's a place to sleep. I can't wait to get this build done!

That said - it is very heavy feeling in there. If it was well lit it would make a huge difference. There is one dome light in the middle. I had to put a puck light above the stove - there is no vent hood, no nothing there.

lori-I like the one on the left with the glass doored red hutch and dark island. I also like renton's inspiration picture.


 o
RE: Black kitchen cabinets - opinions

I loved the look of black cabinets but had reservations about selecting them. Would it be too dark? Would it affect resale? We decided that it is our house and we went for it! I love the results!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here