Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Posted by siena_s_dad (My Page) on
Mon, Oct 22, 07 at 0:05

Does anybody have experience with sun tunnels? We are installing 2 in our rebuilding. The builder provides the tunnels. However, we took a 1st look today and found that the light coming out is blue instead of natural light. It looks like an early Holloween in our bathrooms. The builder said that is the way the tube reflectors are. The only alternative is to get foil tube but there will be less light. The glass on the tunnel is also an ugly frosted glass. We want the glass to be smoother. My wife has complained about it all afternoon. Are there any options out there to remedy this? I don't mind paying for 2 new sets as long as it makes W happy.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

I don't know if there's any way to rectify it -- but our Sun Tunnels (Velux brand) also cast a very blue-whiteish light. Since our paint color scheme is warm-toned, I'm not sure how well this is going to work...


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Sun pipe uses only galvanized/polished reflective ducting as well as galvalume roof jack. You have a choice of different difusers.

Here is a link that might be useful: tube lights


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

We have the Solatube brand. I don't see any blue to the light that comes in.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Just checked. Our blue devil is ODL Solar Flair. Yuck. Called Solartube dealer today. Each 14'' will cost $460. They don't sell parts. Gotta buy the whole set and reinstall.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Depending on your diameter, sun pipe will sell you the galvanized reflctive ducting seperately. It does not emit blue or any other color of the spectrum, just natural light.They also have a wide variety of diffusers.We are impressed with ours ,quality product.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Just a silly question, did the installer remove the blue protective film from the inside of the tunnel? I just installed one last week and it did cast blue until film was removed.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Do you have any theater friends? They could get you a pink gel for next to nothing.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Ditto on jr. There is a blue plastic film!


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Not the problem here... We did remove the blue film.
And the light is more white than blue - just not as warm as I'm used to.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

This board is so resourceful. I asked the builder whether he removed the blue film or not today and he swore he did. But he promised to double check.

Actually, the light is more natural on a very sunny day, but becomes blue on a cloudy day or in late afternoon during low light. The whole diffuser looks blue. So if the blue film is not the issue, then I hope to get new ducts. Thanks a lot.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Oruboris, are you suggesting applying some pink gel in the tube right above the diffuser to neutralize the color of the incoming light? Is pink the best color to neutraliz blue? I suppose I can give that a shot before I toss the reflective tubes out.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

fwiw
Natural daylight is quite blue compared to the yellowish light that is output by most home use light bulbs.

We seem to grow accustomed to it through our windows but put a daylight fluorescent light bulb in the middle of a room and people complain about the whitish_blue light.

I put a 20watt daylight fluorescent on-top of a partition wall... because at the time of purchase they didnt have any warm white lamps. A few days later swapped it with an existing 20 watt warm white tube hidden over the kitchen sink.
Don't notice that bluish light next to that kitchen window but it sure sticks out reflecting off the ceiling in a darkened room.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

You could use any color you liked, but pink is usually the favored color for natural, healthy looking skin tones. If you find a source [online theatrical supply?], you might want to get a couple different colors to try.

In the world of film photography, portraits are usually shot on pink toned kodak film as opposed to the cooler Fuji film.

For outdoor shots, the light at dawn tends to be quite pink, noon is blue, and dusk is golden.

Our brains actually have built in color correction so we don't notice this. It's why a film photograph indoors without flash looks so wierd-- yellow under incandescent light, greenish under flourescent. The light hasn't changed, our preception of it has.

But when we have two different light sources in one space, the brain tends to 'normalize' the dominant one, and declare the other 'wrong'.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Just want to report back the results of my experiment. Taking oruboris's advice, I consulted my photograher friend. He picked out the yellow Rosco lighting gel for me. It is a 24''x24'' thin square piece of film at a cost of $6.95 each. The staff at the Palo Alto photograhy store also agreed that yellow gel was the best to neutralize blue light. I went with it since our bathroom is painted yellow. There are many Rosco series. I just pick up whatever they have in store. You can also order online.

I had the contractors cut them and place them right over the diffuser. Lo and behold, the light coming down the celing warmed up instantly. There is about a 15% loss in the brightness. But the blue is gone and the tone is softer and warmer. Wife is happy.

So $14 and this board do the job of what would have been a $1,500 replacment. Thank you for helping, guys.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

I'm thrilled that it worked! Since originally posting to this thread, I had a cheap brand installed in my main bath. Because it receives no direct sun, it is a very cool, 'sky' blue...

So I'll probably end up taking my own advice!


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

adding this to an old thread: We had 2 Tubular skylights installed yesterday (9/19/13). I was shocked and extremely disappointed seeing the blue fluorescent light cast, nothing like the natural sunlight I was expecting. I knew I could not live with this and needed to find a way to get rid of the blueness and soften the starkness of the light coming through. I found the product Rosco Lighting Gel (but it is not a gel or liquid) very good advice. I bought it through a Theatrical Lighting center near by and found out it is very commonly used for stage lighting effects and photography. It comes in hundreds of different colors and basically a very thin sheet of plastic. I used the glass circle as a pattern, traced around it, and then cut the circle out with a pair of scissors. Start to finish...just taking a couple of minutes and the price per sheet of Lighting Gel was $6. Inexpensive, easy fix !
I first tried a very pale shade of yellow, better... but was still disappointed as it now cast a slight green hue. I went back to the store and bought a very faint Caucasian “flesh” color, that worked perfect. The actual color is R3410. It completely softened the harshness so now no hint of blue/fluorescent casting whatsoever.
Rosco Lighting Gel is easily available, I have 2 stores within 3 miles of my Southern California home or I’m sure it can be purchased on line as well if you google it.


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Thanks for the tip!


 o
RE: Sun tunnel reflecting blue light?

Has anyone ever tried to paint the tube white to reduce the florescent like quality of the light?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here