Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

Posted by phoggie (My Page) on
Mon, Sep 1, 08 at 13:03

We are in the planning stages of building a new home...and DH asked me this morning, painted or stained woodwork. I am totally confused on this...one day I want painted, and then the next, stained.

What are the pros and cons of each and how did you decide? I have seen pics of stained doors and painted woodwork, but is that something that is normally done? I think I have pretty well settled for stained cherry cabinets, but the doors and woodwork are a big problem...
so I am asking your advice....and mixed woodwork pics will be appreciated....thanks,


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

Stained can be initially more expensive than painted because you need to use nice wood for stained and can use cheaper wood or mdf for painted. However, painted can require more upkeep after it is installed (at least in our experience) because it shows dings, marks, etc., more and needs to be repainted more often than you need to refinish stained woodwork. What you chose depends upon the style of your house, what you like and budget. We have a prairie/craftsman style house, and my DH really likes stained, so stained was the obvious choice for us. They all look nice. Mixed is probably not as common as all stained or all painted, but mixed is often done where I live and looks very nice.


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

We did mixed. Like carolyn said, I think it is definitely a personal preference. We have a lot of "wood" in our house, so the painted trim with the stained cabinetry, doors and window worked for us. Here is the best picture I could dig up of the combo.

Photobucket


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

jay~
Thanks for the pic. Are your doors stained and the woodwork around them and the woodwork at the floor white?
I kinda like that look.....I also like some stained, but think all of it would be too much. Do you have a fireplace? If so, how did you do that? Thanks again.


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

Our current house has all paint upstairs and mostly stained downstairs. Upstairs trim and doors have been repainted three times in 22 years--one room four times. Stained woodwork has never been redone, just orange oiled twice. I love the crispness of white trim in bedrooms, but we will be going full stain in the new house!


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

phoggie, Our doors are all stained. Our windows are stained. The casing around the windows and doors is painted along with the base trim. Here is a picture of our fireplace... I have lots of pictures. Just let me know if there is something in particular you are interested in... We just moved in this weekend, so please excuse the mess! j.

Photobucket

In this pic, you can see the corner of the stained door with the painted trim.

Photobucket


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

jay and all others~~ please post any pics you might have on your woodwork....LR, Kitchens, BD, Bath. etc....enjoy seeing them. I don't know why this is such a hard decision for me to make.....guess I like them both. Maybe I need to try to decide on how I want to go with paint colors....darker colors look better with white....light colors look better with stained....or at least, that is my thought.


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

I have had both and while I really like the look of both, I have to say that stained trim and woodwork has required much less maintainence (sp?) and doesn't show the dings of the vacuum cleaner and whatever else may hit it.


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

This is such a personal preference that pros/cons of each is actually irrelevant to the decision. You have to go with what your gut tells you. What feels better to you, what house design/style are you trying to achieve is much more important than whether or not you'll have to repaint something before you'd have to touch up the stain...IMO.

Pictures such as above may help you get to the final decision though. I'd suggest touring homes and looking at design books for assistance. Also, stained cabinets and stained trim are two completely different things. I wouldn't consider having stained cabinetry and painted trim to be a "combination" of the two. Jaymielo's pics above are more reflective of a true mixture of stained/painted wood.


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

Originally, I wanted dark wood floors and all painted trim because I loved the crispness of the contrast. Then I looked at another house that my contractor built (for something completely different) and fell in love with his use of cherry trim, doors and floors. We're building a Craftsman style farmhouse, so the stained trim makes better sense, but either would have been beautiful. The stained trim and the solid wood doors raised our costs a bit, but once I saw them, I was hooked. The best way to decide is to go tour some homes for sale during open houses or model homes and see what catches your eye.


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

I think a lot depends on the color of your walls: I like a good deal of contrast between wall and trim.

And wall color in turn is somewhat dependent on the ambient light level of the room: if there isn't a lot of light, I like a pale wall. Lots of light, a darker wall helps keep it from being blinding.

If you have a medium tone wall color and want a dark stained wood, you'd better have a LOT of light...


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

Thanks all~~
Wish I lived closer to a larger city.....all are about 2+ hours away from this small town in mid-Kansas...but the last time I talked to a builder in Topeka (and these homes were not all that spectacular), he said that he built about half stained and white cream...not any stark white anymore.

I have seen some pics on the forum somewhere that shows a dark stained front door and white trim, but I don't know if the other doors are stained with white trim or not. Anyone have these? Thanks


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

Me again... ;-) Yes. Our front door is stained and trimmed in white. (Stark white actually)

Photobucket


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

My house doesn't have tons of natural light. there are front windows....but also a front porch. There is a huge sunroom on the back. I do have two skylights, but they are on a northern exposure, so not a lot of direct sunlight. And I wanted rich colors on the walls....light chocolate and red for some areas. I chose white trim to help contrast the darker paint colors. I love how clean and crisp white trim looks.


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

Carolyn above said it, and I'll extrapolate -- painted doors (a light color) have the big downside of showing dirt/fingerprints. If you have kids and light colored painted doors, prepare for fingerprints on all the heavily used doors like the powder, doors to the outside, pantry, etc. I love the look of stained doors with white trim.
good luck.


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

Ummm. Be sure your paint or stain is compatible with a marine polyurethane for the top finish. Finger- and paw-prints will wipe off easily.

As far as cleaning dark/light colors, remember that opposites show up. That is, grimy fingerprints will be most noticeable on light shades and dust/pollen will be most noticeable on dark shades. Doesn't matter whether they are paint or stain, the tone will affect which sort of dirt you notice. So choose the colors you like best, but be sure to give them an easy-clean finish.


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

phoggie, Sorry, I just reread your post. You weren't looking for pictures of the front door, but interior doors. Again, our interior doors are stained with pure white trim. I choose to do this because I like the way the color on the wall contrasts the trim. All these decisions are a matter of personal preference, but I know it helped me to see pictures of what others had done while I was making decisions. Good luck! Jaymie

Photobucket

Photobucket

Photobucket


 o
RE: pros and cons of painted vs. stained woodwork

I like a bright house. We have lots of windows and french doors and lighter shades of paint. Only our entry door is stained, and it is in a surround-sidelights that is painted. All our doors, frames, window casings, baseboards, etc. are BM 'white linen'.

We are empty nesters in a traditional style house (not craftsman, etc.). The only 'little destroyer' visiting frequently is one grandson, age 3.5. I think our less expensive but solid manufactured wood doors and our trim can be repainted many times for what we would have spent on wood worthy of staining.

An FYI about your cherry kitchen cabinets: I was told they tend to darken with age.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here