Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

Posted by jzinckgra (My Page) on
Sun, Sep 16, 12 at 10:12

We are building a 2100 sqft chalet, 3 bed, 2.5 bath. like everyone else that is building, we try to get to the build sight as much as possible especially now, while they are framing. When the foundation was poured, our initial reaction was "this looks really small". Out came the tape measure, thinking the foundation guy screwed up the dimensions. Lol. Nope, all was correct.

Then the framing started and things were looking more "normal" with respect to size. The 26' tall prow wall looks awesome and really gives the house prominence. Yesterday, we went back and more walls had been put up. We quickly realized things were yet again too small. For instance, our large couch won't fit comfortably in the great room as it will be too close to the sliding doors. The loft area upstairs, where we figured we would put the computer desk also likely won't fit. Seems like we should have designed our house around our furniture. It's not all bad as we wanted to replace some of the furniture with something a bit nice and mature. This is our 1st house build and according to my wife will be our last:).

Anyways, it's funny how things on paper look so much bigger. We're very excited and know everything will work out, but just wish things were a bit larger here and there. Coming from a 3700 sqft colonial, we knew we wanted to downsize and have an open floor plan, but this seems to have gone almost too far towards the smaller size. Looking back, we probably should have visited more of the builder's homes in progress and brought a tape measure to get a better idea of how our house plans would compare. It will certainly be a cozy house and very energy efficient.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

Another pic of the "great room" or as we're now calling it, the small room....


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

Do you have exterior photos of one that's been completed?


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

Have you drawn in the furniture, on your floor plan? That's why I do that all the time. It's not the size of the room...so much as how much space you need for everyday and entertaining.

If your furniture fits and you have comfortable walkways, then the home should be just right for you and your family :)


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

I do think its important to have a furniture plan in the drawing stages. Even if you don't own the furniture yet, a quick internet search will give you some dimensions to go by,then make sure everything is to scale. This is where a home design software comes in super handy. Sweet Home 3D is the one I'm using currently and is a freebie, very useable tho. Apparently you guys missed that step in your experience and I do hope it all works out! Looks like a lovely location!


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

Your previous home was massive...and you probably purchased furniture that suited that larger scale. Honestly, I wouldn't fret too much about your old furniture being too large for your new house. Even if it technically would fit, the proportions would likely look awkward in your new, cozier home. Take this as a sign from above that it's time to go furniture shopping, or maybe to ask your builder to do some built-ins (for example, the nook where you wanted a computer desk sounds like it's just BEGGING for a built-in desk!)


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

You really have to wait for drywall. I have heard this from a lot of people who build. When my footers were set I thought...this is waaaayyyy to small. Heck I even thought the house was going to be to big for the lot. It's 1.5 acres...but wooded so the cleared area made me question it.

It still seems small and my house is 4600 sq ft above ground. The Basement adds another 2600. So I know I am delusional. However, I have started playing with furniture placement online and know that I have more than enough room.

But no matter how big the house is, just about every owner questions the size until the drywall and lighting are in.


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

Yes, our old house had a 28x36' great room and easily swallowed all our current furniture. We'll wait for the drywall, but a trip to the furniture is probably in order. Didn't think to play with house plan software and furniture.


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

:)

Our house isnt near your previous house of almost 4k sq ft (ours is 2,250) but when the foundation was first poured and cured. I remember walking on the slab like this doesn't look like all of our rooms on the 1st floor are going to put let alone the 3 car garage. Once framing went up the house even appeared smaller to me so thats why I had to laugh with your post because I remember at that point pulling out the tape measurer to make sure the dimensions were correct. Let me tell you that if you feel its small now, you will start to think its even smaller once the drywall goes up because you wont have the depth perception of being able to look between all of the rooms...lol In the end the specs of the rooms were on but for some reason during the build they just appeared to be smaller than they really were!


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

We were told that it would look small until the roof was on. Because your perception is skewed when the sky is the roof! lol


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

I kept thinking that there was a mistake during framing because all of the rooms felt so small. It was not until drywall and the roof went in that the rooms felt the right size for us.


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

I didn't have that issue. I had spent so much time in our house in my head before we built it, that it all seemed exactly right as the framing and then the sheetrock went up.

The only time the space felt huge was when the hole was dug as they had to excavate under the garage as well. Then the place seemed ginormous.

Especially with the mountains of material that came out of the hole.


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

Layout trumps raw square feet.


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

Very neat looking house!
I hugely regret not furniture planning before framing. Our keeping room is way too small and might not be usable the way we intended--to comfortably relax on couches and watch the tv above the fireplace. Our architect assured us it'd be a great size, but everyone comments on how it's just a tad too tiny :( oh well, live and learn (though there is no way in hell I'm building another house--I agree with your wife)!


 o
RE: Is your house smaller than you thought it would be?

I have very poor spatial reasoning - I can't gauge, for example, how a 10x10 room would feel until I'm in it. And yes, I'm a major clutz because I'm constantly misjudging distances & steps...

When the walls went up on our build a few weeks ago I freaked out because it was so big! Of course, we're coming from the opposite scenario (2000 sq/ft house to almost 4000 sq/ft) but still. Although I love the flow of the house I'm thinking we should have found something smaller. The roof is being framed this week so I'm curious to see how that's going to affect my perception.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here