Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Dining Room location

Posted by sadiect (My Page) on
Wed, Sep 28, 11 at 1:40

The home we are in the early planning stages of building has the dining room set in between the family room and kitchen. I've never lived in a home where you had to walk around the dining table to get from the kitchen to family room and vice versa and was just wondering if this layout was something others have and if so do you like the setup?

The other option I'm considering would be an L shape with the family room and dining room at opposite ends and the kitchen in "middle" so to speak. I have a feeling I'm over thinking things, but it's hard to plan for something when you've never experienced it.

Photobucket


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Dining Room location

Sadie, I have an acquaintance who has a new home with a layout very similar to yours. Instead of a kitchen island, however, she's got a peninsula counter that extends from the kitchen wall on the exterior side. Anyway, the times I've been there, I always think "why on earth did they design it this way? It's such a pain to go from the living room to the kitchen!" I think their dining room size is smaller than yours, but it's a pain no matter how it's sized.


 o
RE: Dining Room location

I've seen layouts where there is a breakfast area in between the kitchen and the family room (could easily be a dining room as in your plans). However the table is not necessarily centered in the breakfast/dining room, so as to leave room for a straight path ("traffic flow", if you will) between the three rooms.

Will you eat all meals at your dining room table? Its a bit more awkward walking around something you only use a couple of times a year than something you use several times daily.


 o
RE: Dining Room location

This looks to be your only dining room.
I have seen many houses similar to this layout. And, they work. They work better if they aren't there just for show most of the time (except holidays) and are a regularly used room of the house. And, like books, many of the houses I've been in with this layout have the door a little offset, and the table offset, for a more direct walking path--although, with an island, you will be walking around something one way or another.
That said, your alternative of putting the kitchen in the center doesn't seem to work with the rest of your "utility" layout. Your guests (and family), in order to get to your dining room, would have to walk through the kitchen every time. That would annoy me.
Also, will you use your study as a study?


 o
RE: Dining Room location

We toured a Southern Living home at Lake Oconee years ago that had a similar layout. There was a partial wall between the kitchen and dining room. Access to dining and living rooms was via an aisle on either side. While the home was beautiful, I prefer a more open design. Maybe you could eliminate the wall between the dining and living rooms which would ease the access?


 o
RE: Dining Room location

The idea of the plan is good, but the layout seems a little awkward. The powder room is only accessible from the kitchen or garage. There's no bath off the entry/living room, other than the master.

If you have kids in the upstairs bedrooms, they will have to walk downstairs, wind throught the living room and dining room, to come down for breakfast. Same thing to access the laundry area.

Maybe look for a plan with the master bedroom and bath in a similar location, but put the office in front, on the same side. Keep the great room in the back, but have the kitchen closer to the front, off the entry. You can still have your view out the back (from bedroom, great room and dining) but with a better layout.


 o
RE: Dining Room location

I really appreciate all the feedback! This would be our only dining area, so it would be used multiple times daily. I wanted a room that was large enough to expand for holiday gatherings since we don't have a "formal" dining area as well. And yes the study is intended as a study only.

My goal was to have the best of both worlds with a pretty open layout but with the option to close off hence the double pocket doors b/w the living and dining.

Lavender- I like your idea of moving the office over to the other side and reconfiguring.

Back to the drawing board...


 o
RE: Dining Room location

I have a Family room-dinnig room-kitchen layout and it works great. However, our island and dining table are the same size (8')and the opening to the family room is much bigger so you so you're not walking around the dining table. I'm assuming the sofa is going to be facing the fireplace so then you will have to walk around the sofa again. That would drive me nuts! Make the opening to the family roomn much bigger and it will work.


 o
RE: Dining Room location

Sadie, I'm going to leave the discussion of the dining room to others. We did not opt for an open floor plan, and wanted the kitchen and eating areas to be separate from the family room. I do like your kitchen layout, and that nice big pantry.

You have a nice mudroom entrance and laundry area. However, I think Lavendar-Lass has a good idea about the location of the powder room. When we designed our home, we wanted the powder room easily accessible from all areas, but a bit private, too. We didn't want the family room to be the main traffic pattern, and I didn't want traffic from the garage to go through kitchen, dining, and family rooms. This is not our final plan, we did make a few minor changes, but this layout is working very well for us (empty nesters).

Photobucket


 o
RE: Dining Room location

We had a similar layout in our old house, except it was the breakfast room between the kitchen and family (there was another dining room at the front of the house. Anyway, it was originally built with a cased opening b/w the family and breakfast, and we ending up demo-ing that wall to open it up completely. It was great! Plenty of room for an aisle, so you weren't walking around the table, you just walked past it.


 o
RE: Dining Room location

We are building our house with that layout but with no divider wall...like pps7. We wanted an open layout and no formal dining room. We are bumping out the outer dining wall to make a window seat with tall hutches on either side also. Right now we're trying to figure out visual ceiling details to define the spaces but not separate them. I'd nix that divider wall. It will give you a much nicer flow.


 o
RE: Dining Room location

We have a similar floor plan, but our powder room opens near the steps to the basement. I know chisue prefers powder rooms near the family entrance, but I feel strongly the other way--I don't want people to have to go near my laundry room or garage door entry to use the facilities.

Our "nook" is our only dining area. The room labeled "dining room" is really a second office. We don't have a wall between our family room and dining room, so we aren't really walking around the table, just passing it.

If we could do it over again, we'd make the powder room a little wider, put in cabinetry instead of a closet facing the nook, and possibly recess the refrigerator so we can have a full-depth fridge with a counter-depth look.

I know many people prefer an island to a peninsula, but I love my kitchen. We've had as many as 4 cooks in it working, and I love that only the cooks go in the kitchen--there are no "through kitchen" traffic patterns.

There are some changes to the master bath--if you're interested, they're elsewhere on the site.

Here is a link that might be useful: Beth's house website


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here