Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Posted by rktman (My Page) on
Fri, Aug 29, 08 at 11:28

Holy cow Batman,
I just got a quote for Hardie Siding Installed, $500 per square (on the back my house only, brick front and sides already done). Why on earth would I pay that when my brick cost was the same? How does this compare with some of your actual costs for cement siding?
Thanks.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

I just priced Hardie lap siding at about $110 a square for primed boards. That's for materials, not installed. So, the estimate does seem high, but I know that around here siding installation costs are ridiculous. I recently got a quote that worked out to $1000/sq, which made me sputter. (I'm in the midwest.) Have you gotten another quote?


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Not yet. I'm in MO. $1000/ sq, that's crazy. I'm still looking for other options.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Is it a small job?
One story house and not very large?

There is a certain 'penalty' associated with smaller jobs.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Something is wrong with those prices! Are you an O/B or going thru a GC? I just got pricing last week from a local sub and he charges $2.00/sf, factory primed, material and labor included. I'm a GC. Material runs approx. $.86/sf.
FYI, brick runs approx. $6.50/sf, material and labor in this area.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Well, I'm only doing 12 square on the back of the house. Brick costs me about $.95 per brick(m&l) X 5 brick per sf. So brick cost per sf= .95x5=$4.75. So at 4.75 per sf x 1200 sf, this is $5700. Using the Hardie quote of $500x12 sq, this is $6000. Unless my math is messed up, Hardie makes no financial sense assuming brick is the superior product.
I may just be getting a high quote. I looked on get-a-quote.net and their estimate was around $275 per square which would be more reasonable.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

should be 7 brick per sq ft. changes the numbers a lot.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

King size brick, 5 per sf.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Do you already have a brick ledge?


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Good point. If there is a ledge you need an expensive flashing detail or furr/flare the siding out and if there isn't you can't install brick.

I wouldn't necessarily consider brick to be the superior material. The overall design of the house is more important. What is your goal? Save money, add interest to the house?


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

"If there is a ledge you need an expensive flashing detail or furr/flare the siding out and if there isn't you can't install brick."

You can use steel angle bolted to the foundation as a ledge but $$.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

I would consider brick to be a superior material in light of the fact that all other sides of his house have already been bricked. I don't like the switch in materials at the rear...it generally looks like you ran out of $$$ half-way through your project.

Around here almost all homes are built with a brick ledge because the foundations are almost exclusively bricked regardless of the cladding material above.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

I don't like the switch in materials at the rear...it generally looks like you ran out of $$$ half-way through your project.

Here, million dollar + homes often feature stone fronts and EIFS for the rest.

When I see all-stone homes, I just know it was a vanity project by the owner who wanted to prove he could afford it. (We did a custom with just that rationale.)


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Good point worthy, but I still agree with dixie. I am very sensitive to costs but there has to be a better option to the brick front with vinyl sides/back design.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

I think worthy is talking about stucco, not vinyl. It depends on the style of the really, Craftsman style, very popular around here might have 3 or 4 different sidings.
I to, can't stand to see houses built with a brick front and other 3 sides are vinyl.!!!!!


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

three sides vinyl?

NO. i'm going to say that word ...i can't stop myself

Mc Man... no. i'm going to stop. don't want to start another one of THOSE threads.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

An incredibly ugly or an incredibly beautiful house can be built with the same combination of materials. Well designed houses are not simply an assemblage of common shapes and materials; it takes skill to integrate them well.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Very true!


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

MightyAnvil is oh so right on the need for a great design when dissimilar materials are used.

However, the fact remains that in many areas, especially in the 50's, 60's, and 70's, tract housing seized upon the use of brick or stone fronts with the other sides of vinyl or cheap siding as a method of cutting costs. If one lived in such an area (and is senior enough to remember) then "false fronts" are indeed a sign of elcheapo building while a fully bricked house was a reliable sign of quality construction. Now, that's a lot of years ago, and many good builders [probably including Worthy] are too young to be aware of this sublimal attitude. It may be unfortunate, but I am among those seniors who still consider that a house which is totally brick or stone is superior in exterior construction quality to any other, except for the extremely rare case of superb architural design which deliberately incorporates a mix of exterior materials -- and I have never seen such in the common false-fronted houses.

Sorry, Worthy, but IMO the fact that someone is costing a house at a million or more does not automatically indicate that the cost is based upon good quality or good design.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

I live in one of those 70s houses with the brick front and horrible cedar shakes on the other 3 sides. I'm shopping siding as we speak and would love opinions on what would look best--a shake or board? Fiber cement (HardiPlank, Nichiha or vinyl (CertainTeed Cedar Impressions)?

btw, the large evergreen on the front corner will be replaced with a magnolia.

From House


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

I just got a quote of $7650 for installing Hardiplank on a 1000 square foot house (one story, with 1700 square feet of siding). This estimate came from a general contractor. I would prefer wood, but that costs even more. Does this quote seem reasonable?

Sorry to be stupid, but does 1700 square feet translate to 17 squares?


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

OP, do what you like and what you can afford.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

We paid $17,500/sq for Hardie colorplus (prepainted), which works out to around $700 per square. This also included soffits and flashing where required. The house is elevated with the majority above 10' above grade, and ICF, which meant that the Hardie had to be screwed instead of nailed. The installer was by far the most expensive of our quotes, but was also the only one who seemed to have a clue what he was doing. And he did an awesome job, so for once we got what we paid for!


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

Carterinms, why does the Hardie have to be screwed rather than nailed if the house is raised? My house is raised, but only by about 2 feet.


 o
RE: Brick vs Hardi Cost - This has to be wrong..

The hardie had to be screwed because the house is ICF. I mentioned that the house was raised because much of the installation was done on ladders, which I assume also increased the cost.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here