Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Help with Siding Decision

Posted by wu343 (My Page) on
Sat, May 26, 12 at 23:01

I am getting to the end of our budgeting process with and I have to make a decision on adding one of two options. The two options are to finish out the basement or upgrade the vinyl siding to Fiber Cement (Hardie). We already have an upgraded vinyl (Monogram 46) with cedar impressions in the gable ends and lineals around most windows.

1. Will an appraiser give additional value to Hardie siding over vinyl? We are getting a little worried about the house appraising high enough to cover the construction costs.

2. I do like the look of Fiber Cement siding, but is it really worth the extra cost from a durability perspective? Will I have to re-caulk it every few years?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Help with Siding Decision

a few things:
first, the finished basement will appraise out higher then fiber cement siding. Also it will typically increase your taxes as well.
For the siding option, look around and see what other houses in your area are. If they are vinyl, stick with the vinyl.
You can also looking into using LP Smartside. I personally think it looks better then JH, and it runs around the same cost. Install is much easier so typically it falls right between JH and vinyl price-wise.


 o
RE: Help with Siding Decision

I think it depends on your area. I know that most of the homes in my area are hardi and that appraisers count it as masonry. I also like to custom paint. But if your area is mostly vinyl I would not pay the cost.

Not sure of maintenance.


 o
RE: Help with Siding Decision

I just spoke with our siding sub and he discussed Hardie and SmartSide siding options with me. He said that in Northern Minnesota they have switched to installing mostly LP SmartSide unless the customer asks for Hardie. I like the idea if cement board siding on my house over the wood fiber Smartside, but I'm worried about all the horror stories about moisture and chalking issues with Hardie. Anyone have experience with LP products? If I went with SmartSide, the installer would also use the LP trim for windows and other details. He said LP (vs. Hardie) has a much less expensive product for that cedar shake look in the gable ends as well.


 o
RE: Help with Siding Decision

you cant go wrong with the LP. Great product, good warranty. I think its one of the best looking composites as well. The LP still needs caulked however. About the only real true maintenance free option will be going with vinyl.
For your climate zone 6, I would be far more concerned about air sealing and moisture/drying/insulation levels within your wall and not what is covering it.


 o
RE: Help with Siding Decision

Our builder is using r21 in the walls and a full house wrap (Tyvek)


 o
RE: Help with Siding Decision

r21 what....batts?
absolute code min (wont hit code in less then a year). I assume its too late, but I would put the money there if possible, especially for your climate. Your shell of your home is the only place you see payback and cost savings in your investment.
your "r21" actually performs closer to an r15 assuming 2x6 framing. Adding exterior foam sheathing will do wonders to that at a minimal cost. Air sealing from the inside prior to insulation placement is also key. The tighter it can be, the more it will save you.


 o
RE: Help with Siding Decision

It is not too late to add insulation upgrades. I was thinking about doing spray foam, but my builder said it was not "worth it" from a cost perspective. What can I do to increase R value with a minimal cost? I was told that foam would end up costing about $10 - $12 thousand more than batts. Is that really worth it? I have never had a house with spray foam insulation before.


 o
RE: Help with Siding Decision

your builder is correct. Spray foams, even open cell, is usually not worth the cost. It creates a tighter air barrier, but only at the stud plane. It fails to address air leaks at the top and bottom sills, as well as around window opening framing. Spray foams, r value wise, perform slightly better then batts, but you still have thermal bridging issue. Untill you address that, anything you stuff between the studs will suffer a loss r value of 15-20% reduction. The best thing you can do is add exterior foam sheathing. XPS is r 5 per inch. Adding that greatly boosts the performance of what is inside the walls. However for your climate zone 6, to avoid dew point issues and condensation inside the walls, you would need to go thicker then 1".
The cheapest thing you can do to make the biggest difference would be to caulk/seal your walls as best you can. Go around and caulk the bottom plates to the subfloor, the sheathing to the studs, the cracks between the top plates, etc etc etc. The more easy air sealing you can do, the better. Air moving through the insualtion continues to reduce its performance, especially with batts as the weather gets colder. (your "r21" batt performs even lower when the temps decrease).
However the walls arent the only thing. THe ceiling also is a massive source of air leaking, especially with the use of many can lights that is popular today. Even the insulated "air tight" cans leak. Air sealing has to be done at the ceiling plane as well. THis is typically done from above after the drywall is on.
If you want a slightly upgrade, I would ask him about blown cellulose of fiberglass (such as Spyder). This will perform much better then batts as it will fill the entire stud space that batts never do. It would be an upgrade, but a blown/dense pack product mixed with air sealing will pay for itself in a very short time. Building new is the best time to add energy improvements. They start saving you money from day one. The same can not be said for upgraded siding, counters, cabinets, etc.


 o
RE: Help with Siding Decision

We are already getting r50 blown fiberglass in the ceiling. He also added "Thermax RIM" (I'm not sure what this is). The poured basement will get R11 batts in the walls.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here