Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Posted by liptonjl (My Page) on
Tue, May 1, 07 at 13:48

Can I see photos of what it looks like? I have been hearing some good things from friends but I'd like to see some "real life photos"


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

These pictures are as "close up" as I have on my computer. I believe our boards are the wider 7" but I'd have to measure them for sure. We decided on the wider because we have a very long house (140ft) and didn't want the hardi plank to look like toothpicks! LOL

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

We went with a 7" reveal, as our place is spread out like Kats. They are still working on it, but here's what it looks like thus far.
Kats-I haven't seen your house pics in a long time. It looks great!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

We have the 5" reveal, our house is about 40' wide and we wanted the smaller boards. The color is a standard Hardi offering, "Mountain Sage" with another standard Hardi offering "Sailcloth" as the trim.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

sandyponder


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

We have it. Love it. Ours is the factory finished Mahogany stain.
We've had contractors come out who could not tell it was not real wood (until they got up close).

Here is a link that might be useful: Our new house


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

This is ours--Woodland Cream is the color:

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Jo


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Nice copper z-bar flashing above your windows + door,sandyponder.
Lifetime flashing for sure.Nice House!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

fishpants

Thanks so much for the compliment. Those pics were taken almost 3 weeks ago and so much has been done since then. ETA is June.
I'm heading up there this evening so hopefully there will be enough light left for my camera. Then I can post my own thread of pictures. Something I haven't done in a very long time!!!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

in regards to pre-painted hardi siding; we really like the look of the stained wood (like zone 8 grandmas) but we can only get the hardy plank primed, not pre finished. Will we be able to get a look of real stained wood painting it afterwards?

thanks
michael


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

michael,
Thank you. I don't know the answer to your question, but hopefully one of the many knowledgeable folks here will.
Ours has two tones in it which is what makes it appear realistic. I was told that could only be accomplished in the factory. I'm just repeating what I was told, however.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Hey mikeyvon, if you dont have luck with a hardie contact,try some painters in your area that are custom oriented. They can do things like grainig on materials other than wood and use custom staing techniques, though it might get kinda pricy. Im told there are many creative and talented people in your area, and is something even an artist might consider. Same with concrete, they are doing some amazing staing,texturing,stamping work with concrete these days.Good Luck!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Sierraeast,

I have found on here some pictures of stained hardiplank and it looks great. I also did some google searches and it looks like staining works well. I will most likely go the staining route. This will be a diy job, so I will be the one who will get creative. I have many artists friends, but usually they have no clue lol.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

I love hardi. I much prefer the look of hardiplank over vinyl siding. the picture is from far, so may not be of any help. also, it's not painted yet.

one thing that's neat about hardi is that you can get the grain texture or you can go with smooth. I like them both. I think they even have a beaded board style.

my summary: Hardi looks real and is solid.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Here's ours (painted on site) with 6" reveal and a tiny bit of fish scales or scallops also in Hardiboard:

This photo is missing the upper shutters, but you can see the Hardi better:
Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting


Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Kats, I can't wait to see more photos! The roof is going to be fantastic!

Fishpants & Sandyponder, I *love* those bold colors!

Jojoco, I've always loved your house and now it looks even better with the landscaping in!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

hoosiergirl,

wow!!! great looking house. I love the lookout/gazebo and the bell tower.

bmh - yours looks great also.

I cannot wait until we start diggin dirt.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Thanks, Mikeyvon! We love it!

Once you start diggin', hold on to your hat 'cause it's quite a ride! Good luck with your build!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Just wanted to say to everyone who has posted pics in this thread that ya'll have some beautiful, beautiful homes. I cannot wait to see more pics from all!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

mikeyvon,
There is a product called wood perfect by masons select, I attached link, it is a semi transparent wood coating that I used and from 5 feet away you cant tell my siding and trim is not real wood. Sorry I have no pictures to post or I would

Here is a link that might be useful: wood perfect


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

kats, fishpants, sandyponder, jojoco, bmh4796, hoosiergirl, zone8_grandma - - You all have really lovely houses! Looks like being on this forum is almost a guarantee for a great home. :-)

As a variation on a theme, ours is "HardiShingle" prefinished by a company called Weiss in a custom paint color. They'll paint any color you like. They also pre-stain. We got the individual shingles. They cost less than the shingle panels, but labor is more. However, we would have wasted so much material with the panels due to all the cuts that this worked out better for us.

The parts of our house that still say "Tyvek" will get El Dorado stone one of these days!

Front elevation


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

jr1318,

thanks for the link. the stuff looks great. how does it hold up? have you had it long? I have read that stain does well on fiber cement also.

michael


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

home_nw,

I hadn't seen a pic of your home before. It is absolutely stunning!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

wow, i did not even really look. home_nw, your home is stunning. your location looks awesome as well.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

home_nw:

You were talking about the Hardi-plank shingles...did you price them out in comparison to regular shingles? How do they compare in price? Thanks! Absolutely beautiful home, btw...love ALL the pix here!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

mikeyvon,
the manufacturer give a seven year warranty on self applied, si far looks real good, I preapainted before install, and so far the finish seems very tough especially against abrasion.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Kats, mikeyvon, and juniork, thanks for your nice comments on our house. :-) Like so many here, I've been planning our house for years. It's hard to believe it's becoming real! Every house posted here is spectacular - - each in a different way.

I love the shape of your house, kats. Looks perfect for relaxing outside with some privacy and with protection from wind. All your porches are wonderful too. Is that a balcony upstairs?

Juniork, we're trying to build our house to be as maintenance-free as possible, so we never priced cedar shingles, although we think they're lovely.
- We paid a little over $400 per square for the individual HardiShingles, pre-painted by Weiss (25-year warranty), delivered. (Unpainted, they would have been closer to $250 per square, I think.) One square of the individual HardiShingles takes 210 pieces. Pieces come in three widths (6", 8", and 12"), and are 18" tall. They are mounted with 8" exposed.
- By comparison, the HardiShingle panels cost around $475 per square, unpainted. They're 48"x16" and are mounted with 7" exposed. One square takes 43 pieces, but there's a whole lot more waste if you've got a lot of cutting to do. (We did!)


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

GORGEOUS home & setting, Home_nw! I agree with Kats: it is STUNNING!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

$475 PER SQUARE???? Isnt this stuff the "norm" for the southern areas?


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

hoosiergirl, thanks so much! Your home is gorgeous too. I love all your special features - - they really add to the overall appeal. By the way, I want to thank you for posting a photo of your mud bench on another thread. After seeing yours and kygirl99's, I was inspired to have our builder make one for us too. It's not exactly the same as yours or hers, but definitely shows your influence. Thank you! :-)

linda117, I don't believe the shingle style is the norm for southern areas. I think it's generally considered more of a northern style since it mimics cedar shingles. I'm not sure why the HardiShingle panels are so expensive - - probably cost more to make. Also, $475 per square is approximate only. I agree with you, it is high!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Well I'm glad that I was able to help in some small way, Home_nw! I hope you update us with pics -- I can't wait to see your home finished!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Hi
Building a new house.Using hardi plank.When I called James Hardi with questions about paint, i could never get a person to talk to only to leave a message.Three times I left messages,never to be returned.VERY BAD support.$82 a square from Lowes unpainted,$182 a square factory painted.Using with stone.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

We purchased ours unpainted, but I'll have to ask my DH where he purchased and how much he paid for it. We are in southern Louisiana.


 o
checked on price unfinished

I checked with DH and he said we paid $100.00 for 100 sq. ft. primed, but unpainted. Purchased from a local lumber yard.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

home nw,
Your House looks great!
I am trying to pick the siding style and color for our house and have been looking at Hardi Shingles or Maibec real cedar shingle panels. I like the color of your house. Can you tell me what paint or stain color that is? It looks like a taupe in the photo. Is your trim pure white?


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

pinkpowertools, what a great name! Thanks for your nice words about our house. You're right, the color is similar to taupe. We tried to pick a color that would blend into the natural landscape around us and not show too much dirt.

Weiss sent us paint samples on HardiShingle and we picked one called "Cashmere," even though we thought it didn't look at all like the "Cashmere" in their brochure. Turns out it was some custom color that someone had mistakenly labeled "Cashmere"! Weiss, bless their hearts, sold it to us anyway, and named the color "Danny's Cashmere." (Hmmm, s'pose Danny was the one who mislabeled the sample??)

You're also right that our trim is all pure white. It's mostly Azek, plus some Fypon/CDM pieces (low maintenance!) and is being painted with a Benjamin Moore 50-year paint (again, low maintenance).

Good luck on your build! What stage of building are you in?

Here is a link that might be useful: Weiss colors


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

If anyof you are acting as GC please tell me what trade typically installs the hardi siding? I haven't been able to find anyone to give me a bid for the install of the Hardi Board siding.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Ideamom, we didn't act as the GC, but our framers put up the Hardi-plank. I have heard that you need to go with someone that has experience with it, as it's not cut or installed the same as wood or other products. Good luck and hope that helps a bit!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Home NW, Thanks for the info and link to Weiss. Your right, the Cashmere paint chip online is very different from your custom color "Danny's Cashmere" more of a yellow.

We also plan to use Azek and other PVC or molded wood trim for low maintenance. I am just starting to get samples of colors and materials.

Our house is not new construction but an extensive remodel. We will be changing the entire look of the house, remodeling 2 baths, master bathroom/dressing room, kitchen, new Laundry/ pantry area, adding on several additions to create a mudroom, more garage storage and an office/ guest room. We are in the final drawing phase with the architect and have put the initial drawings out for bid. I am hoping these last changes will be closer to our budget and then we can finalize things with our GC. I would love to get the new foundations started this summer and have the framing done by end of September. We will have a place to stay for four months starting in November but we want to be here as long as possible.

Anyway, there have been days we thought about tearing the whole thing down. I don't think I will know which would be better till it's all done :)


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

ideamom, our framer will be installing the Hardie as well


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Ideamom - Just like rachelh, our framer installed our Hardie too.

Pinkpowertools - Good luck on the remodel! Sounds like it should be nice when it's all done.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Here is ours....

Here is a link that might be useful: The Woolsey's


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

home_nw,

I love the shape of your house, kats. Looks perfect for relaxing outside with some privacy and with protection from wind. All your porches are wonderful too. Is that a balcony upstairs?

Sorry I didn't answer your question earlier, I just came back to the post. Yes, it is a balcony. Orginally it was supposed to go to the end of the porch roof line. We asked the architect to do this but like several things we wanted he said he submitted correctly to permits but really never did. Anyway, it's off our gameroom and I wanted a place for people to go outside to smoke or play cards on a nice evening. From that side of the house (south facing) we get a view of mountains, our beautiful glen, and the city lights.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Here's our Hardi plank and shingle shake:

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Soonermagic, I'm a long-time gawker who has to de-lurk to tell you how much I love your house! It is just beautiful and so charming. I'm in OKC and as you know almost all new construction here is brick. It's nice to see a new home as lovely and individual as yours. You've given me inspiration for the country farmhouse I've been contemplating.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

fishpants, would you please be kind enough to share your Hardi siding color/paint/stain? It looks just great, as does the rest of the house! (I really like your window trim, too.)


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Okie - Thanks for the compliment. I DO know what you mean. Every new home here in Oklahoma looks practically the same, brick with front garages. We did a tear down in the neighborhood surrounding OU, so we made a concerted effort to try to make our home blend in with the neighborhood. We want it to look as if it could have been there since the 1940s and not completely out of place.

Folks in the neighborhood and around town now think that all we did was renovate an existing house and forget that we actually bulldosed it. I think that indicates that we are at least close to achieving our goal of blending in with an old neight as best we could with a brand new house.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Are there other brands then Hardi Plank that are less expensive and just as good?


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Deanbrent,

Sure hard to get much cheaper materials than fiber cement regardless of brand (Certainteed, JH, etc.). Pre-finished prices are just over $1/sq ft, unfinished are under $1/sq ft. Vinyl siding - about as cheap as you can get is $0.50-ish/sq ft - unless you use sheet goods. Brick, stucco, log, etc. are all multiple dollars/sq ft.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Texasgirl 06 - I love your home. You must be near east tx with all those pines. What kind of wood are your cabinets made of. They are lovely.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Here is ours, just pre primed, no paint yet.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

Soonermagic, I agree, your home is *so* CHARMING! I love it!!!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

happykate- we had ours done in the 'new pilgrim red' option before delivery. We're really happy with how it looks. Still not quite done however, since it's been so windy off and on. The siding sub hasn't wanted the material to get busted in the gusts, etc. or worse, knock one of his crew off the lift they've been using.


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

I will be putting Hardi plank siding up in less than a month. I live in the middle of a woods. I want to blend two different shades of paint. Gray primer(dry) than (light green first...(dry) than a gray over it,(dry) and possible another charco gray lightly to give depth to the cedar mill. Pain staking but I got time and I want my house to blend with the woods surroundings. Could someone please guide me on how to do it right. Thanks!


 o
RE: Does anyone have Hardi Plank siding?

soonermagic I am in love with your paint color, could you please share that with me?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here