Return to the Building a Home Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
New M. Bathroom design

Posted by Laberglund (My Page) on
Thu, Apr 12, 12 at 23:30

Sorry for the primitive design, but does this work?

master bathroom

Room dimension: 14x12

We'll have a pocket door separating the vanity and closet from the rest of the bathroom.

We felt like the old design wasted some space, since we were unable to use all the walls in the closet, and we also didn't want to have to access the closet via the bathroom for privacy issues.
Thoughts?

Posting the old design for comparison.

Here is a link that might be useful: Old plan


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

If i were doing your updated plan... Id put the toilet under the window and extend the close all the way back to the wall where the window is.


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

Or for more privacy flip the tub/shower to the window wall and move the toilet across from where the linen closet is now. I just depends on what you value more - closet space or more floor space/privacy for the toilet.


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

In your situation, it isnt worth the expense, in my opinion, to move the toilet. (your old plan had it in a much better place, resulting in less lost floorspace to "hallway".) You are also losing space in your closet, actually, to the floor again.

In your situation, I'd probably move the toilet to adjacent to the proposed tub and under the window and extend the closet all the way to the back wall. 7' width is wide enough to get 2 hanging rows of the full depth (if you want lots of closet space), and enter from the bedroom to the closet.

Or, if you aren't crazy about that much closet space, post both drawings up for comment. There is a better solution to the one you have posted.


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

I actually much prefer the original plan. It had a sense of spaciousness whereas your new design feels very cramped. Far to much of the available floorspace is wasted on the "walkway" to the toilet. I also think you wind up with LESS useable closet hanging space than before. Without counting corners twice, how much linear wall space do you actually have in each design to put clothing rods on? In the original design, it looks like you have about 20 feet (12 ft on the back wall plus 4ft each on the two side walls.) In the new design it looks like you only wind up with about 16 ft (8 on the back wall, 5 on the wall next to the bedroom and 3 on the other side wall behind the linen cabinet) Overall, it just doesn't look like a good renovation to me.

If you really want/need the additional privacy afforded by having the tub/toilet in a separate room, here is a modification of your design that would allow that while not eating up so much of your current closet space.
Photobucket


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

Sorry to be repetitive. Kirkhall posted while I was prepping my response so I hadn't read his.


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

I talked with someone today who told me that people are tending to want a walk in shower these days, rather than a tub with shower. Thoughts on this?


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

Ok, going a whole new direction here.
I think we're going to plan on doing a walk in shower, and plumb in a tub to put in a few years down the road.
I came up with this, but I'm guessing it's probably not using space super well.

master bathroom


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

I don't think your picture posted the way that you thought. At least it isn't very helpful here...

Bevangel has a very good plan laid out for you.

As for shower vs bathtub--
Do you bathe? I ask because I do not. And, I haven't since I was probably 7. I hate the idea of setting my rump on a tub bottom...

If the house has another tub, I'd not hesitate to do a walk in shower only in your space (as Bevangel has posted it). Will you have a large hot water tank/endless hot water? Many tubs, in order to be bathe-able for the adult (think soaker tub), need a lot of water. And therefore, never are used after installed because the homeowner figures out the water gets cold before it is full enough.

Some thoughts.


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

Go with a tub/shower combo OR with a walk-in shower. Forget trying to have both a shower and a separate soaker tub. Don't even waste the money running plumbing for both. The space you have just isn't big enough to accommodate both unless you want to give up practically ALL of your closet space.

Since your house has another bath with a tub, you don't have to have a tub in the master. (Code only requires one bathtub in a house.) Most adults would probably agree that they use the shower far more often than the tub. If you want a walk-in shower, you can certainly have one. While you can tile the shower alcove, I would recommend that you use a plexiglass door/wall on the front side instead of tiling. (See the link below) It'll feel more open and you don't really have the space to build a tile wall enclosure on the front side.

Here is a design with walk-in shower for you. Note that I made the window narrower (24" instead of 36") and made the narrow end of the closet a little narrower because a walk-in shower is usually a bit wider than a standard alcove bathtub. Photobucket

Here is a link that might be useful: shower door you could use


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

Wow, bevangel, nice work!! I'm impressed.

We went with a walk in shower/no tub in our master because we shower so much more often than we bathe. We have a big bathtub in the guest room bathroom I can use - or the hot tub. We've been perfectly fine. Though I am excited at the thought of having a master tub too in the new house (with a window)!


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

Bevangel's plan is really the best use of space. That last mocked up plan you did has a confined hallway that just won't work. Is there something you don't like about bevangel's plan?


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

I do like Bevangel's design. Thank you.
However, I was envisioning more of a square shower, with glass walls on 2 sides. My husband and I share a 6' reach in closet at the moment, so he feels that such a huge closet as drawn above is in excess. Does it work to take a few feet from the closet in order to have a closed off toilet (with pocket), which frees up some space for a more square shower? Also, this frees up some space for a closet into my foyer/great room area which would be great for storage/vacuum, etc.
This is my final thought--if it doesn't look right, we'll probably end up going with Bevangel's design and be done with it.
Thanks so much for your thoughts.

master bathroom


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

You need at least 24" in front of the front edge of your toilet bowl in your water closet to be legal. Since you don't have dimensions, I can't tell what your toilet room long dimension is. ( seems your new linen closet would be 3x3 as pictured, which leaves only a 4' toilet room--not big enough). Though, 3' deep linen/hallway closet is really too deep.

where would you put your closet door? bedroom wall or vanity wall? I think you could do either, but one gives you more closet space.


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

I my closet getting too small? I'd really like a 72" vanity rather than a 60", so would need to move the linen closet to accommodate that. I know the closet is plenty big enough for my husband and I, but for resale?

master bathroom1


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

A 7x8 closet would be a bit snug for me and my DH to share unless it was a home we were starting out in or sharing early in a marriage and just didn't know better. I say that because our last closet was about that size. Our new closet will be 10x6 1/2 which still isn't all that large to a lot of people but larger than what we're used to. And it is a nice sized closet which we are having built out really nicely. But it could have been bigger. 7x8 is about the same square footage as my kids closets that are roughly 9x6 and they have a decent amount of storage. But it wouldn't be enough for two of us.


 o
RE: New M. Bathroom design

And, I wouldn't put the linen closet there. Move it to the useless corner in a closet this size--up to the corner of the closet opposite the shower. (nothing else will really fit in that corner anyway. Yes, this way your closet door swings to a wall, but you lose the hanging space this way.) You might should really consider a pocket door or outswing depending on room size.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Building a Home Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here