Honed vs. Polished Marble Bathroom Dilemma

9 years ago

I'll start off by saying I am OCD so marble and me don't mix well. However, I have decided I am doing 18X18 Cararra marble on my bathroom's floors and 2" hex Carrara marble for my shower floor. I got a sample 12X12 from thebuilderdepot and it was fantastic. White-ish in color with distinct grey veining. After discussing with my contractor, I decided to go with 18X18 marble as I have a fairly large bathroom at 12' X 12'. I kept going back and forth between polished vs. honed. I plan on sealing the marble so I am not concerned about stains but I am concerned about the etching. However, I don't plan on any foreign substance being on the floor except water from the shower. I have read countless threads on this forum but still not sure if water etches? I live in North NJ where we have hard water so that is a concern. Even though I prefer the polished, I was thinking honed which hides etches better is a better compliment to my OCD.

To make it more complicated, the tile place where I got my subway (1 hour drive!) gave me a great deal on 18X18 polished ($9 sq. ft.) vs. the $9.95 on thebuilderdepot but I dont like the material as much. It is a bit more grey in color with less distinctive veining. However, it could just be that thebuilddepot.com gave me a fantastic sample which isn't a good indicator of what I would get if I ordered 150sq. ft. I am lost :(

Comments (3)

Fori
9 years ago
You can test how your sample reacts to your water and see if it's bad. Then test all the stuff you might clean it with or spill on it.

I'd be tempted to leave polished for the walls and honed elsewhere--it's okay to mix 'em.
jewelisfabulous
9 years ago
Around here, the minerals in the water leave long black streaks on the Carrera marble homeowners put in their shower. It's such a shame to see it happen to such beautiful stone.

Have you looked into the porcelain "Carrera" tile? It has the beautiful white with grey veining. It's a dead-ringer for marble, but not susceptible to the issues the porous Carrera is affected by.
Related Professionals
Montrose Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Plymouth Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · West Virginia Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Bay Shore Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Alpine Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Islip Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Spanish Springs Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Turlock Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Weston Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · South Jordan Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Menlo Park Glass & Shower Door Dealers · Pleasanton Glass & Shower Door Dealers · Reston Glass & Shower Door Dealers · Trumbull Glass & Shower Door Dealers · Campbell Window Treatments
enduring
9 years ago
I'm with Jewel654, have you looked at the porcelains? Here is a few that I was looking at. I went with the large one shown here in the center. Thats a pan of snow. The large tile is called Atlas Concorde, Marvel Calacatta Extra, and is from Italy. I chose the matte finish, and this sample is matte. I bought it through Nebraska Furniture Mart. They were very helpful and gave me a discount as well. The other tiles shown are a variety of other tile samples.

The tile is ever so slightly warm and looks beautiful with my walnut vanity and woodwork in the bathroom that I finished this past summer: