Return to the Bathrooms Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
No door to bathroom

Posted by holcombe3 (My Page) on
Wed, Sep 25, 13 at 22:06

We are picking our interior doors out tomorrow. I like the idea of not putting a door going to the master bath because it would make it feel more open. However I'm worried I will regret it and want to be able to shut it when I'm in the tub and such. Anyone with doorless bathrooms have an opinion?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: No door to bathroom

What about a pocket door?


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

I'd hate it, but that's me. Where's the toilet?


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

We just had a pocket door installed on our master bath - 32 inch wide door and we plan to keep it open most of the time. Toilet is in the corner away from the door but it IS a small bathroom. We are liking having the door open most of the time and also liking the extra room we have that doesn't get used as it was previously by the traditional bathroom door when it is open or on its way to being open. I was actually worried about whether the pocket door would get jammed easily, especially in a humid environment but this pocket door is installed so well and slides so easily and freely that I don't see how it will get jammed. But we've only had it for a couple of months -- crossing fingers.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

Can you post a quick sketch? This would very much depend on layout for me.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

Oh, boy, I think there's a spectrum of answers for this ranging from "why not?" to "over my dead body!" I know this because we did a master with no bathroom door and when some people saw it for the first time after the remodel, there was silence and a slight intake of breath before any comment. But we did it for ourselves and it works fine for us.

Depends on your need for privacy plus the timing of your various uses. We skipped the door because the room is carved out of the upper half-story, the ceiling is peaked, and it would just make for an odd geometry. Our walls don't even go all the way up to the ceiling. The toilet is at the far end behind a pony wall and the visual entry to the bathroom is blocked from the bed by a built-in dresser. So there is visual if not acoustical privacy. That is simply not enough for some people, but if you find the idea of no door acceptable, then for you, it probably is.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

we had a doorless bath with a very large opening to the master bedroom. The small room with the toilet had a door. This was a rental townhome--it was gorgeous when we went to check the place out--loved it! functional, ugh, no!! My husband gets up for work earleir than me, I could hear (and see) him in the shower, the vanity lights were distracting when you are trying to sleep, etc. If it were my choice, I would not do it that way.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

That would be a serious ugh for me also. Although not as bad if the toilet were enclosed in a little room with a fan.

How would this impact resale value? Would it be difficult structurally to add a door later on?


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

Here is the layout. The bed will be on the wall where the closet is.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

Personally, I would hate to not have a bathroom door. Our bathroom door is open a lot, but sometimes I just want the privacy. For example, if your significant other is sleeping late and you need to get ready, do you want to be able to shut the light out so it doesn't bother your sleeping sweetie? If you do french doors and leave room for the doors to lay flat against the wall or do pocket doors that can tuck away, I think that would allow you to keep the room open most of the time, but give the option to close when necessary.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

I must say that even though I wouldn't do it for myself, at least the layout makes it appropriate (think hotel bathrooms) -- the toilet room has a door, and you can't see into the bathroom from the bed, so not too bad.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

I must say that even though I wouldn't do it for myself, at least the layout makes it appropriate (think hotel bathrooms) -- the toilet room has a door, and you can't see into the bathroom from the bed, so not too bad.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

We once lived in a double-wide mobile home. In the master bedroom it had two vanities open to the MBR. The shower and tub were within an enclosure between the vanities and not visible from the MBR proper. The problem was, if either my husband or I went to bed early, turning on the light over the vanity and/or running water was very disturbing. I'm not a particularly modest person, but I like the idea of being able to shut the door on all bathroom activities.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

I think it would work better if most of the room was shielded from view. What about moving the doorway up to where the closet and bath meet and putting the corner back to square. Then put the opening, no door, between the closet and bath with a wall slightly wider than the opening in front of it. So you would go through the opening, then turn right into the closet or left into the bath. That little wall would make a great display area, or place for a full length mirror.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

Taking a bath and walking out of the shower directly across from an entry without a door might not work for some people


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

I think having a door or no door depends on the layout. I actually have no door to my bathroom and it really works for my layout. Just omitting a door when the layout actually calls for one, may end up feeling something is missing.

A lot of the modern design has no door because it view the bathroom as part of the master suite. The bedroom flow in to the bathroom seemlessly, either with a small partition or with no partition at all. This way, you get a bigger room, feel more open and airy, and more light. Sometimes, the partition can be a short wall or a full length wall hiding the vanity on the other side, or having a "closet" alley between the bed and the bathroom. Most people will still hide the toilet so it will not come to the direct view from the bedroom area.

In your plan, personally i see it as two rooms. So if everything stays, I think a door is appropriate. However, it can easily turn into a more modern/ no door design if you move a few things around. I also personally do not like diagonal walls (where) and corner tub. I think if you don't want a door, it also calls for a stand alone tub, and maybe an semi open shower area.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

Just something to check--how will the "room" be treated for fan ventilation by your local inspector? (They will want a fan sized appropriately, and if no door, you might be looking at a HUGE CFM fan...)

I think you need to at least consider that.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

Definitely depends on the practical layout. And lifestyle, in terms of hours of use; someone an early-AM riser while the other sleeps in, etc.

Then there is always the basic need for privacy. Some people need closed doors.

Our master suite is a three-room setup (bathroom, sitting room, bed/sleeping room) and "L"-shaped, so bathroom lights and water noises (sink, shower, toilet flushing) from the bathroom really don't interfere with anyone sleeping. We have large door-less arched openings that separate the three rooms from each other.

So with regards to practicality, my open space works because light and noise from the bathroom really don't interfere with someone sleeping.

Lifestyle-wise, my wife and I are all over the place with regards to waking and sleeping. Example, tomorrow I'll be up at 3AM, but my early morning shower won't wake her. The layout of the space ensures that.

Same with privacy...we're not shy around each other. So privacy-wise, there is no need for closed doors for us.

I love the door-less setup we have, we've been here for years and there's been no talk of needing to change it. I even offered to add doors a few years ago and she flat-out refused.

It's definitely not a one-size fits all proposition.

With your layout, I think I'd want to have a door to block light and water noise. I'm not a big fan of the double doors that you have on your drawing, mostly because the left door, if left open, appears that it will interfere with the shower entry.

I'd rather see a single large hinged door, say 3'6" wide, or pocket doors. With you vacillating between door versus doorless, a single wide pocket door would probably work well for your set-up, but your sidewalls may not be long enough to pull one off.

With your small sidewalls on each side of the bathroom entry, two pocket doors might work.

My two cents. Good luck with your decision!


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

I'm in the pro-door camp. We live in So. CA, and many homes built in the last 10 years are built without a door to the master bath (although most have a little "water closet" for the toilet with a door). Our last house didn't have a door and it was very inconvenient because of the number of times one of us went to bed late or had to wake early. My husband in particular has the occasional morning where he has to rise pre-dawn, and that was enough of a hassle for us that we specifically looked for a home with a door to the master bath.

Dunno, maybe we're just light sleepers, but the noise and light factors were significant for us...


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

I would prefer installing a curtain rod with floor length curtain on it. this will put about a 30% privacy for the bathroom. All people may not be feel it comfortable to use bathroom without a door.

Here is a link that might be useful: shower accessories


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

we've had a master with no door for years. So I'm probably used to it. New bath will have no door, the entrance is on the left and you walk in facing a cabinet or shelf wall. All the fixtures are on the right so you turn to access the rest of the bath, by going around the end of the vanity. The toilet room has a door. I'm in Hawaii so the room does not get cold drafts.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

Our master bath has no door,can only see the vanity and mirrored closet doors from the bedroom, and the toilet closet has a door. Toilet behind a door is a must for me. I'm used to not having a door to the bathroom itself and it's not a deal breaker especially because what I see from my bedroom is just cabinetry and mirror, but would prefer one for reasons other's mentioned. Too noisy if husband is up earlier showering. Doesn't bother him at all cuz he can easily sleep thru that. Hoping to add a door in a remodel, but the layout with entry doors to bedrrom swinging in direction of bathroom opening is going to make that difficult. Would love pocket doors, but don't think that's possible without redesiging the layout which works well now.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

We also have a similar set up with our Master Bedroom bathroom. Two separate areas. Area #1 is a space about 9'x9' with double vanity and one wall area with custom shelves. This area opens directly from the bedroom without a door. Carpeting runs from bedroom into vanity area.

Area #2 has garden tub, stall shower and toilet. There is a door leading to this area and has sheet vinyl.

We are getting ready to put our house on the market and the bedroom carpeting needs to be replaced. My question is, do I redo area #1 with carpeting or do I redo area #1 AND area #2 both with new hard surface?

BTW, I do like there not being a door going in to the vanity area.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

No doors? Not for me. Married over 45 years, but for pooping and a few other personal grooming times. PRIVACY. Always give me an optional door. But I don't like to crap in a closet. Too much like public restrooms. This is my home.

-Babka


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

Doors. Yes. ITA on the suggestion of 2 small pocket doors. That would give you the best of both worlds, and look lovely.


 o
RE: No door to bathroom

We have that situation now and I really wish I had a door. We don't have room for the door swing, so we are thinking we will add a pocket door when we redo the bathroom. The toilet has a door, but you almost have to stand on the toilet to close it - so that will be another fix needed. The fixtures all have a lot of privacy, but it's light and sound when one of us is up later or earlier than the other that most make us want a door option. I like the split pocket door idea too.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Bathrooms Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here