I don't have experience to share with you, but if you have a Restoration Hardware outlet near you, make sure you visit. I was shocked at how many medicine cabinets and mirrors they had at the one I visited. Many of them are just catalog returns. Even if you're not interested in buying from the outlet they have most of the things that are not sold in stores so at least you could take a good look at one before you buy.

We put the cartwright medicine cabiet in all of our baths. The price was too good to pass up. They are all installed, but we haven't used them yet. They look nice enough to me.

Assuming they are manufactured by the same company, I have a Hutton vanity and I am very pleased with the overall construction, quality, and appearance. So far, I have always been pleased with the quality of items I have purchased from Restoration Hardware.

Check shipping costs - I wanted to order a medicine cabinet but there was a flat rate shipping cost of $199. The vanity was $500 that's almost half the cost of the piece!