I would think that you might have trouble getting the faux counter and faux tiles to coordinate - much like faux and real marble. it is hard to say without seeing the tile you are using. A countertop material that is clearly different will probably end up looking better, in my opinion. Either plain white or maybe a dark quartz counter will be lovely. KevinMP did a beautiful bath with marble, dark wood vanity and a dark grey countertop (IIRR his was granite, but you could do quartz instead).

Like pps7, I have faux carrera tile and real carrera countertops. I love the combo.

Thank you! I just saw Kevin's bathroom the other day, love that look!

PPS7 and Pricklypearcactus, any trouble with staining on your countertops? I put my makeup on at the sink so I'm worried about powder, blush dust making a mess.

Right now I'll either do real marble on counters with gray tile floor or faux marble floor and real marble counters

Thanks again!!!!

I haven't had a single stain, but my sink is not heavily used. Eventually I plan to put carrera marble in the master bath as well, but for now the sink with marble is really only used for washing hands and hand washing delicate laundry.

Just to follow up went to the Tile Shop this weekend for their big laborday sale and fell in love with a display they had. It was basket weave marble tile on the floor, subway marble on the shower walls and a greek key trim in black going around it, gorg! Sadly we can't afford all real marble so we'll do faux tiles in the shower and since it's in a separate room anyway, we are the only ones who will see it. I have found one marble remnant slab for my vanity and just need another one for my husbands which is smaller so should be easier to find a remnant, right? I will attempt to post pics when this is all done around November. Thanks again for all of the good advice, jrueter, PPS7 and Pricklypearcactus!!

Those of you who mixed faux Carrera floor with real Carrera vanity tops, could you post a picture? I'm thinking about doing the same thing but was concerned about how they'd look together.