Enduring, I know this is a really old question, but what did you end up doing about a tub? I am also curious about the Memoirs.

Hi there, I went with the Bellwether tub, which was the 30x60" tub. It was not the 32x60" which was a deeper Bellwether model. I didn't go with the Memoirs because of cost. It would have been a deeper tub than the smaller Bellwether that I went with. The dimensions of the smaller Bellwether is pretty much like the Villager. Both shallow depth for bathing. It is ok, but not ideal. The tub would be used for children and pets for the most part, though I took lots of tub baths while my other BR was being remodeled. I would have preferred the Memoirs for the water depth though. I love Kohler cast iron, and the colors are fun.

Hi Enduring. I have a Memoirs and love it except for the non-slip coating. Between my well water and clay soil the non-slip area gets an orangey, brown color that I cannot clean off easily. I don't have a water filter. I use a magic eraser and scrub, but it is soon nasty again. It is deep, comfortable and has a vintage vibe. One hint, check the finish of the porcelain carefully. We bought ours through Lowe's and twice it was delivered with a huge chip in it and the third one had tiny spots of glazing missing from the side under the drain. Something we didn't notice till partially installed. Kohler sent a replacement immediately and told use to keep the one we started to install.

Thanks you two for your input. As you probably noticed this is a revived thread. I hope this helps Maddybeagle. It sounds like a great tub.

This is very helpful! Thanks, everybody! I'm bookmarking the cleaning advice in case I go with the Memoirs.