Part of what I liked about the oval is that it 1) softens the angularity of the overall shapes going on in the bathroom and 2) it repeats that curve you have in the soapstone backsplash.

I do like your frame, a lot.

Definitely not the squatty square. If you do decide to go with that frame, then the rectangle is the way to go. I just feel like some curves are...friendlier.

I still like the oval shape.

I always liked the rectangle, but not the white frame. I like option 8 or 9. I don't think the oval goes in your space.

I like the framed oval but not so much with the sconces. That wood framing material is really interesting and different. It will look great with your paint. From a practical standpoint, the thin-framed rectangle works better because it allows more of your reflection while at the sink. The square shows more mirror, and might work because it looks like you have low ceilings.

You should put your two or three favorites up for a vote in the decorating forum since it gets so much traffic. I wish the bath forum was more like the kitchen forum where they love to discuss form just as much as function.

Alex9 & Crl I think the oval helps soften the space too. That is why I cut the scallops out of the backsplash when I made it, the slab just looked too heavy and "square". But as I toy around with shapes and materials, the oval looks a little small right now for the space.

catbuilder and May-flowers, your vote for the square will keep me thinking. The frame just "sings" with the wall color paint. I do have low ceilings at 7'. I have these sconces that I am about ready to ditch. I got them last year, one of the first items of the room. I bought them online and while I think they are beautiful they are a little large.

The idea to post this on the deco forum is terrific so I will do this.

I prefer the rectangle in your space. The oval seems wrong with the offset faucet, and it will cut off to much of a person's reflection when using the faucet. The frame finish is beautiful with your other elements. I do think the sconces are a bit large in comparison to the surrounding area. Hope you get more input in decorating!

Thanks Abfabamy (what a name:) I am posting there as we post. I think the scones may have to be sacrificed in the future. But not until every thing is in place. They weren't the most expensive but they weren't cheap either. That switch out would have to be done under the cover of darkness!

Lol! He might not even notice!

May-flowers there is a high probability he won't!

I think Alex is dead on. Can't wait to see the sink in situ!