Return to the Basements Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Water in Basement and Dry Wells-Advice Needed

Posted by bostonbasement (My Page) on
Fri, Oct 28, 11 at 18:03

We recently bought a condo that was built in 2008, and appears to be in good condition. When we bought it the seller disclosed that there were basement flooding issues in the past, but that since he installed a $10k interior drain system with 2 sump pumps its been ok. They have been working fine minus two occasions when one of the pumps jammed (debris from an electrician) during really really heavy rain.

Having read these boards, it seems to me that most people suggest keeping water out of the basement in the first place so that we don't have to rely on the sump pumps and I want to rely less on the pumps in the event that we have a really bad storm where the pumps can't keep up with the incoming water. So I had a waterproofing/foundation guy come out to assess the situation outside my house to see if there is anything we could do. This is where I want to get others' opinions, since he noticed that on our property there are what he thinks are 2 dry wells. One on the left is an open grate dry well in my driveway which collects driveway runoff and my neighbors gutter runoff and the discharge from one of my sump pumps. It looks like this dry well just seeps water out of the bottom. The other dry well is in front of the house in the garden, and is covered. I believe (although I'm not sure) that all of my downspouts are directed into this covered drywell underground. Upon opening it, this well had holes all along the sides so I'm assuming it drains out of these holes and into the surrounding soil. This well had a pipe at the top which i assume is where the gutters flow out of, and another one at the top which my contractor guessed that it may be an overflow pipe that goes to the city storm sewer if it fills too much (although this is probably useless since it would probably only fill to the top at the same time the city sewer is overflowing).

Now these 2 dry wells are basically right next to my house, one is maybe 5 feet from my foundation, the other is even less. I always assumed that they were piped into the city sewer but I guess not.

My contractor said that these wells are a bad idea since they are so close to the house, and when it rains heavily its probably just putting a ton of water into the ground around my house, and then probably going into my basement sump system. Do you think this is what causes water to enter my sump pumps? From what I've noticed the sump pumps only turn on when it is a lot of rain really quickly. For example last week we had over 1.5 inches of rain over the course of a day and the pumps never turned on, however we've had instances where it was less rain, but much more sudden where the pumps turned on (usually coinciding with street flooding).

The contractor suggested that i stop routing my downspouts to the covered drain, and he would have them run underground and then empty onto the sidewalk and then into the city drain. He would also reroute my sump pump discharges to the sidewalks as well instead of into the open dry well, and my other pump which discharges right onto the soil in front of my house. Now since my street tends to flood and the pipes for the downspout/sump discharge may get submerged in water, he also suggested installing what he called popups or release port/valves further away from the street so that the discharge pipes don't get blocked.

This is a big alteration and also fairly expensive and I just wanted to get others opinions on the matter before going ahead with this one way or another. I'm afraid that this may have some unforeseen consequences that may make the water problem worse. We have a neighbor who doesn't have drywells (although their house is much older) and their basement gets water too. Right now the water issue isn't bad, the pumps do what they are supposed to do, I just wanted to do something that would make me less worried when I'm away from home and theres a torrential downpour and be able to handle extreme circumstances.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Water in Basement and Dry Wells-Advice Needed

he would have them run underground and then empty onto the sidewalk and then into the city drain. He would also reroute my sump pump discharges to the sidewalks as well instead of into the open dry well, and my other pump which discharges right onto the soil in front of my house.

Where I build and reno that is absolutely forbidden. All drainoff must be handled on your own property with absolutely no hookups to city sewers or property.

Running your water onto hard surfaces could be disastrous in the winter when the water can easily turn the sidewalks to a sheet of ice. A friend got her first home downpayment in the form of a settlement from her landlord's insurer after she slipped on ice in front of her apartment building, fell and cracked an elbow. Hope your liability insurance is up to date.

So before you go that route, double check with the city that it's okay. Don't count on the contractor!

On a house I built a few years ago, the homeowner insisted on his own external drainage guy. He ran everything to drywells two feet from the street, figuring what didn't disperse underground would run into the street. Within a year, acting on the complaints of neighbours, the city ruled drywells and all had to go.


 o
RE: Water in Basement and Dry Wells-Advice Needed

Nothing would be directly connected to the city sewer. Everything would end on my property which slopes toward the street and city sewer. The lot space in my city is limited so nobody really has the option to deal with their own runoff. Houses are literally feet from one another, and rather than flood their own or neighbors property most peoples downspouts direct the water to the street.

Do you think the dry wells being so close to the house could be a major source of water going into my sump system?


 o
RE: Water in Basement and Dry Wells-Advice Needed

Do you think the dry wells being so close to the house could be a major source of water going into my sump system?

Definitely. But it depends on the character of the soil. High clay content would retain the water, lots of sand would drain well.


 o
RE: Water in Basement and Dry Wells-Advice Needed

where would it drain to though?


 o
RE: Water in Basement and Dry Wells-Advice Needed

Into aquifers. I wasn't suggesting a solution.

I once owned a house with a shallow basement and water leakage problems. When I demolished it and excavated for a new home you could clearly see the upper levels of dense soil, eventually giving way to the older water washed-gravels and sand of the ancient lakeshore beneath. For the new home, the soils engineer recommended no weeping tile, as it would only impede drainage.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Basements Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here