If this is all in the basement, stick with the same method all around. Better to go to at least 1" extruded e.g., Styrofoam. Remember, on the wall to garage, the space at the top of the wall is above grade. Also place the bottom plate on an inch of extruded too. This acts as a thermal break while also providing protection from any minor floods or leakage that might occur.

I live in the Northeast and I am finishing my basement. I plan on using spray foam insulation and having it sprayed directly on the poured concrete walls.

I am very confused by the competing claims of open vs. closed cell contractors.

My basement has been dry for the 5 years since the house was built, but I am wondering about moisture from the concrete and/or penetration from the surrounding soil. (The foundation has been sealed on the exterior but not insulated.)

Is it better to go with the closed cell that will act as a water vapor barrier or use open cell that will allow the moisture to dry to the interior of the basement?

I am getting conflicting views on this, please help!