Return to the Basements Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Basement bathroom - full or half?

Posted by freezetag (My Page) on
Tue, Feb 19, 08 at 13:41

When we discuss finishing our basement, dh and I can never agree about what sort of bathroom it should have. There is rough-in plumbing for a sink, toilet and tub, but I don't see the point in having a tub (or even a shower) in the basement.

We currently have two full baths upstairs, and a half-bath on the main floor. Dh thinks that, because we have four kids, someday we'll need another tub or shower (they're currently 12 and under, so they don't shower excessively yet). But all the bedrooms are upstairs (as well as the laundry and linen closet), so I wonder whether anyone would use a basement shower.

The only way I see it being useful is if we put in another bedroom in the basement. Two of the kids share a room, and we did at one time talk about adding another bedroom in the basement, but no one wanted to move down there by themself, so we have dropped that idea for now.

Do any of you have a full bath in the basement? If so, do you use it much?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

I vote for a full bath. When your kids get older, they'll want a bedroom in the basement. Also, a full bath would probably increase the value of your home. Just my $0.02


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

I also support the full bath (at least a shower).

We put a second kitchen in ours and when having the house appraised several years ago the realtor gave an interesting perspective. Said that in these times, many graduated college students return home for awhile. Having a independent living space for such would be of value.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

I definitely vote for the full bath. You are already talking about how someday their bedroom might be in the basement so you might as well do it now. It will be 10x more expensive to add it later.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

If you are gonna finish a 1/2 bath, you might as well include a shower. The incremental cost of including the shower is relatively low to the total cost of the 1/2 bath.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

I'm going to go aginst the grain and vote for a 1/2 bath. We also had this delima, and a good friend helped solve it. She told me that she had a shower in her basement which of course noone ever used since all the bedrooms were upstairs, and when they had an exterminator come out for an influx of cockroaches in their house he told her that they were getting in through the drain in the downstairs shower since it was always dry. After he treated the house he told her to make sure that once a week she turned on the shower and let water run for a while to keep it from happening. I think it sounds like you have plenty of places to take a shower or bath, and who is going to want to carry all their clothes down a level or two to take a shower anyway (or run dripping wet with a towel around you upstairs) :)


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

Our main floor master bath has a shower and a tub. Our upstairs with 2 bedrooms and a loft has a bathroom with a tub/shower unit. Our main floor bathroom is a 1/2 bath only.

When we planned our basement, my wife planned a spare room for guests. It is mainly for those possible guests that we plumbed our basement bathroom with a shower unit.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

We installed a bathroom with a shower when we finished our basement. The main reason is when we have guests stay overnight they stay in the basement because we do not have a guest room. I don't know if that would be a considertion for you. If you want to leave the option of having a kid live in the basement than do a shower. Don't bother with a tub just a shower.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

You say it's already plumbed for a tub or shower? Then to me this is a no brainer. Add the shower to the bathroom. You don't need a tub, and you will not only add value to your home but also increase flexibility in the future. Putting in a pre fab shower stall is not very expensive.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

We have a basement bath w/shower and its been used a grand total of maybe 4 times in 4 years. If it's roughed in, may make sense for a basic shower, but I wouldn't bother with a tub. We have 2 younger kids, maybe it'll get used more when their older or have friends stay over. Keep it simple and don't go overboard. At the end of the day, bed or no bed, it's a basement.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

Well, there are basements and there are basements...


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

My father put a full bathroom in his basement condo (have no idea why, two full baths upstairs - no one will ever use it). He also said he was going to take a shower down there once a week so the drain does not get dry. Sounds like a chore.

Basements are usually cold and I like warm areas to shower.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

The question I have is about your potential basement bedroom(s)- do they have egress windows or is the foundation a walkout? If so, then I say install the shower. If those rooms don't have the large windows for egress in case of a fire, then you cannot according to code have a bedroom down there, so then you should skip the shower.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

If it was me, I would say no and focus on using the money saved in yearly tax increases to save for the 4 kids college education. With all the negative news I hear regarding the economy and the debt people are in, I think people need to take a step back and focus less on redoing homes.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

Is the basement a walk out or walk up? If there is access to outside, then a full bath can come in handy if you have pets - or like to garden. It might be a great place to hose dogs or kids off when they get trashed in the mud.

When I finished my basement I added a full bath not really knowing if I would ever use it - just figured it better for re-sale. I didn't spend a lot of money - used a fiberglass two piece unit for the tub and shower walls. After that we got a few dogs - boy did that thing get used a lot.

The money you get back on re-sale for a full bath is worth the few extra dollars to add that in now. Just don't go crazy with the materials.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

Posted by pete_p_ny (My Page) on Sun, Mar 2, 08 at 20:30

If it was me, I would say no and focus on using the money saved in yearly tax increases to save for the 4 kids college education. With all the negative news I hear regarding the economy and the debt people are in, I think people need to take a step back and focus less on redoing homes.

Nowhere did the OP state this was some financial hardship. It's a bathroom, not an indoor swimming pool.


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

I agree with the full bath. Our house is being built on 8 acres with a walkout basement and there will most certainly be muddy dogs and muddy feet to deal with. The family has been warned that all muddy feet and wet or dirty clothes will be left in the basement and off my hardwood floors or there will be hell to pay!


 o
RE: Basement bathroom - full or half?

I'm in the Midwest and while it seems common to me, I don't know that its a fact regionally...but it seems that men in particular like having their "man shower" down in their "man cave" that they don't have to get fussed over about. Or in my sisters case her "woman shower" since her husband is a total controlling neat freak and insists on squeeging after every shower. So she uses the cheap fiberglass stall in the unfinished part of the basement. I just looked at a house for sale - by the kitchen door that comes in from outside the wife insisted the husband take the half bath and put in a shower - he wasn't allowed any further into the house till he'd used it.
And as a gardener and pet owner - I'm with sniffdog.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Basements Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here