Return to the Appliances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
best bar dishwasher?

Posted by wkearney99 (My Page) on
Thu, Dec 20, 12 at 17:12

We're building a new house and I've need for two dishwashers. One will be in a beverage bar (aka butler's pantry) area and will be used pretty much exclusively for wine glasses, most often large ones for red wine. I'm assuming that on holidays it might also get used to handle added loads. But most of the time it'll be just glassware. And then usually not all that many at one time. We're planning on this using a cabinet front.

Would using a smaller 18" be appropriate? What size would clean more efficiently/quickly for glassware? It seems 24" units are often less expensive (economies of scale, probably).

So whose DW should I be considering? Or avoiding?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

The 18" DW is made for bar area/butler's pantry dishwasher useage and for tiny apartments.

The best is Miele Futura Dimension Slimline Series G4500. It has a built-in water softner to manipulate water hardness of your water throughout the cycle so fine stemware and crystal come out perfect.Miele is the only dishwasher approved by Riedel. Works well on standard dishes too.

A cheaper option would be the Bosch SPX5ES55UCx. It also has a built-water softner that softens water but does not manipulate it throughout the cycle like Miele.

I would avoid the GE models.

Economies of scale do work against the 18" models.

Miele has load and turbidity sensors on some 24" models.

Bosch has a half-load option and turbidity sensors on some 24" models.

So I don't think the 18" models are more efficient in any significant way.It is a space savor for smaller areas.


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

Plan for just another 24". It's more versatile, thousands more are available to select from, and at cheaper prices than 18" ones.


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

Yes, a 24" seems a better solution and we have the room for it. Right now the Bosch 800 series seems to be the best fir for our wine glasses. The upper rack holders seem to have the best fit for our glasses.


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

A single fisher paykel dish drawer would be an excellent choice to wash bar ware.


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

We got the Bosch 800 series for our wet bar. It has a nice fit for tall wine glasses (which we have and will be the primary barware cleaned!) It has the option for quick wash and it's quiet enough to be near our dining room (the wetbar is next to the dining room.)

Our other choice was the Fisher Paykel dish drawer and they were good for plates but not for our wine glasses (we could fit 6 red wine or 8 white wine!) Not a great choice for us at all!

Good luck!


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

good gosh corky - how big are your wine glasses ???


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

What "manipulate water hardness of your water throughout the cycle" in regards to the Miele mean?

I considered both the Bosch and the Miele and went with the Bosch due to the price difference, just ordered them from AJ Madison for a great deal - even better if you have to buy more than one Bosch appliance. (I'm so impressed with the deal that I must have mentioned it on 5 threads this week) ha


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

Ours are big wine glasses, I actually took one to the stores around here to compare how the racks would handle them. The top rack on the Bosch 800 series did better than most others. There were some LG units that were close but i'm not sure I'm prepared to go with that brand.

Thanks for the noise observation on the 800, ours is likewise going on a bar wall opposite the dining room, and we've got all wood floors. So noise is definitely a concern. Not enough to spend crazy for it, but certainly a factor.


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

Ha, xedos, not sure if you mean me but they are really tall and then the red wine glass have a fairly large bowl. To anyone out there, I ABSOLUTELY recommend doing what you did - taking your actual wine glasses/barware to the store and try them in the dishwashers.

We quickly discovered a) we couldn't get the drawers, b) we wanted a full-size, c) we didn't want the cutlery rack on the top b/c our glasses were too tall (even in the regular kitchen!)

The noise situation on the 800 is fantastic and we have all hardwood floors here too (our home in a 1917 colonial.)

The ONLY key to using a bosch is really letting it go all the way through the cycle - it will seem like it's finished b/c it's so quiet but it would still be in the dry stage. If you open it, it's not going to dry at all b/c you've let the energy out. :-)

We're getting a second dishwasher in our kitchen and I'm looking at the Electrolux line (b/c of the fridge/freezer and ovens,) and I'm a little torn. It's a European dishwasher in mode but not a Bosch so I'm not completely convinced. I need either a professional handle though (to go with Electrolux Icon all fridge/freezer) or no handle at all. :)


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

akcorcoran - if you like your Bosch, why don't you get a panel ready one?


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

I'm considering it, for sure. I was kind of looking at the Electrolux together b/c the store offered me better pricing (although that's often a sign that *something* in there isn't top rate.) I actually need it in stainless so the panel ready isn't an issue.

It's that I'm still torn in the whole heated dry w/disposal vs European no disposal/not heated dry debate. For the wet bar, we are really ONLY putting china and wine glasses in the dishwasher, pure entertaining materials. But, in our kitchen, I want a workhorse - and we use a lot of non-glass materials - my girls have to bring a trash-free lunch, so that's a lot of tupperware. We drink from Tervis Tumblers so that's not glass either. I had heard a heated dry was better for those types of materials. Any opinions there?

A


 o
RE: best bar dishwasher?

I share the no dry/no disposal opinion, it just seems unnecessary given how we use it. But I won't argue against having the features; just that we don't have much use for them.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Appliances Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here