Return to the Appliances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

Posted by Ott2 (My Page) on
Sun, Nov 4, 12 at 19:39

Hello -
Regarding a 36", panel ready, integrated, top fridge, bottom freezer:

I am planning on a Sub-Zero 736TCI for our new build. It's not too late to change my mind, and I would like to revisit the 36" Liebherr.

The Liebherr models in question are (and I'm not sure of the significant differences between these two models other than price) : HCB2062 and HC2062

Can anyone comment on any significant difference between these two Liebherrs and/or compare to the Sub-Zero model above? Does the Liebherr integrate as nicely as the Sub-Zero 700 series?

I wasn't excited about the Sub-Zero french door because the produce drawer requires opening both doors to get to the drawer, and because the french door model Sub-Zero is such a new model. I'm not sure about the drawers on the Liebherr models . Are the drawers that require opening both doors truly a pain, or is it not that big of a deal? And, has the Sub-Zero french door model been out long enough to be a solid contender?

Thanks! Ott2


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

I have had the stainless steel version of the Liebherr 36" French door model for over 3 years and am very pleased with it (quiet, energy efficient, well laid-out, cocktail style ice cubes). Regarding the wide drawer: It does require opening both doors to extend it but; there are also two drawers that can be extended individually with only one door open. It's nice to have the wide drawer when needed for larger items.


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

In our remodel, we replaced our 42" SZ side by side with the SZ 36" French door. We love it. We looked at the Liebherr but thought that the finish of the SZ was better. Also, the Liebherr top shelf is very high and that bothered me.


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

we have the Leibherr hcb2062..i think the difference between the 2 Lbrr's is one has the biofresh.
we have the biofresh and really does make a difference.

we did not even consider the SZ b/c of price. the Lbhrr was a couple thousand less.

we love the FD. you do not have to open both doors to acccess the veg/fruit bins. we do not have a one long drawer.
there are so many comments about the top shelf, but for us its a non-issue. i cannnot reach the very back, im 5'3", but everyone else can. we put our big bottles from bj's up there, bbq sauce - salad dressing bottles- etc...

we have had it over a year and have no compliants,,so quiet. very easy to clean and we have plenty of room in it (fam of 5).
love the freezer drawers..you really can find everything, no big bin for things to get lost.

we think it integrated very nicely, email me and i can send you a pic if you like.
one note..be sure you can get it serviced in your area, we have two companies who can service it and we live in a suburb outside of Philly, PA

any other questions, let me know.

HTH


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

Thank you for the feedback! I know I've looked at all of these models at some point in the last few months, but it all runs together after awhile, and owner and real life feedback is priceless. I'm going to head out this afternoon to look again at heights, layouts, etc. I want to really like the french door models. The fridge will be very visible from the living area, and will be in the background of our casual eating area, so a nice integration is important. I am in the Dallas/Ft.Worth area, so service should be available, but I'll specifically check regarding the Liebherr.
I'm only recently familiar with the Liebherr brand. Anybody have thoughts on long-term reliability of these new Liebherr models and/or customer service? I'm *planning* on having whatever fridge I buy *forever*...


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

from what i was told and researched, leibhr has been making frigs for a very long time, longer than sz.
that's what they are known for..so when i read that and was told, i felt alot more comfortable going with them.
they are not as known in the states as in europe..so i had to do some research on GW and elsewhere.

we just couldn't justify the price difference between lebhr and sz and miele.

i am NOT a SS girl and knew from the beginning i wanted the frig paneled...so it did limit our choices from the beginning.

hoping we get "forever" out of ours...keeping fingers crossed & toes!!! :)


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

Thanks again all! Your feedback is helping so much.

sprtphntc - I found a Liebherr hcb2062 to look at. I liked the layout, and appreciate you sharing your research and experience with this fridge model. I don't know whether I will end up doing the SubZero or the Liebherr, but I am convinced that either will work well for us. Also convinced that my toes and fingers will be cramping from all of the crossing in their future!

Best regards, Ott2


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

ott2

good luck with your decision. i am sure either will fit your bill. they are both quality frigs's.
its such a big $$$ purchase, but after all said and done it was worth it for us. we really do love it.
keep us posted on your decision.

i hear you about the cramping..haha :)

take care, e.


 o
Liebherr

We just bought a Liebherr CS2062 and already have had to have service, which parts have been ordered. It is a 36 FD bottom freezer. I bought this expensive refrigerator because I was told how quiet it is, well it runs 30 minutes on, then 30 minutes off, then 30 minutes on, then 10 minutes off, these cycles are fairly quite, then it runs for an hour to an hour and ten minutes and it sounds like angry bees. I am told that it is probably the circulating fans. The service person, which as far as I was concerned was an ass, said well that's the way it is, but I will order new fans and will not promise anything. At this rate our power bill should be outrageous. Has anyone else had these problems? I now have frozen vegetables in the vegetable drawer. Bio Fresh means frozen I guess.


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

Welcome to my dilemma! I really really want the Liebherr, but service issues concern me (i.e. getting parts and a qualified tech).

Vicki, does the Liebherr come with any kind of warranty? I am drawn to the biofresh drawers, mostly because my current fridge freezes produce and I can't stand it!!


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

It has a great warranty, one of the best . My caveman service person was just here yesterday. Put the new fan in and I finally have a quiet refrigerator. I do have to say I thought the service guy was beating the refrigerator up when he was working on it, but it works. Oops the circulating fan just made a funny noise, but then it stopped. We will see with the next cycle. My problem is I live out of their service area, so Liebherr pays extra for service people to come out here, which might be a problem later on when my warranty is up. The service guy did tell me, he hardly ever has to do service work on the Liebherr's, maybe one per year. That is a good sign. I am hopping this is just an isolated incident. Keep you fingers crossed. I do love the refrigerator.


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

Keep us posted on the fix...I too am still considering these and would love a follow up from you Vicki!


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

So far so good on the CS2062, it is much quieter, but I would not call this a quite refrigerator, but I do hear that Sub-Zero is much noisier. My concern now is it runs constantly. It is only the two of us and do not open the refrigerator much. I did put my old Jenn-Aire in the garage, and my new electric bill is almost $40 higher which, I think is high, so I will be calling service again regarding the constant running.


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

We installed a Thermador T36IB800SP recently and have been really happy with it. Fully integrated, and very quiet. Less expensive than Sub-Zero, and we liked the interior a lot more than the Liebherrs (and Sub-Zero to be honest).

Not that this directly answers the original Sub-Zero vs. Liebherr question, but if you're not dead set on those two only, check out the Thermador.

Here is a link that might be useful: Thermador T36IB800SP


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

Just an update. Have not had any additional service problems and I do really love the looks of the refrigerator and it does keep the food fresh and is easy to clean. We have no problems with the ice maker, it does seem to take awhile to make ice but works great. I have noticed that our energy bills are a bit lower the opposite than what I thought considering that I think this fridge runs all the time. Still love it.


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

We recently bought a floor model Liebherr CS2062 and are very happy with it so far. The installers couldn't get it out of demo mode, but Liebherr got back to us very promptly to resolve the issue. The Thermador wasn't an option for us because our fridge is at the end of the cabinet run and so we needed a model with SS finished sides. The fridge is very quiet; the only thing we hear is the water filling the ice maker. It also produces way more ice than we can use in a day, something I had been concerned about after reading some of the comments here.


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

" from what i was told and researched, leibhr has been making frigs for a very long time, longer than sz.
that's what they are known for..so when i read that and was told, i felt alot more comfortable going with them. "

This is totally incorrect !

In fact the opposite is Actually true,

Liebherr started out manufacturing cranes after WWII and are best known for Heavy Construction Machines like excavators and dump trucks larger than the size of American McMansions. The fridge business cam later is still sort of a sideline business.

SubZero on the other hand predates Liebherr by 5-6 years and started out in the fridge business and only made fridges until their acquisition of Wolf at the turn of the century.

The Liebherr's plastic interior is a lot more flimsy than in competitors' built ins and the toekick detail is not as good if you plan on running your cabinet toekick in front of the fridge.

Also, the freezer drawers are not quite as deep or pullout as far as do the SZ ones.

All and all, not a bad unit, but there are differences that justify the lower price.


 o
RE: 36" fridge, SubZero vs Liebherr

While I like Liebherr's use of variable speed compressors, which is of course more modern than the granny or great granny's on/off compressor that SZ uses, one should read the posts about having to pour some cleaning fluid or whatever down some pipe on a regular basis on the Liebherrs.

To me, thats like oiling the push rods on one of those old Buick engines, Certainly not in step with our modern times, "Ya thinks"?

Too bad they don't make the Jenn-airs like they did mine, (2006 before Whirlpool bought them). Variable speed compressor, and my only maintenance is change the water filter once/year, alto I have not done that for a year and a half, since the fridge is now fed whole house softened water.

Gary


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Appliances Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here