Return to the Appliances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built in?

Posted by SDgirlygirl (My Page) on
Mon, Nov 11, 13 at 17:07

We are looking for a fridge for our kitchen remodel and we're looking at 36" built-in or integrated. There does not seem to be very many options out there and we're left with the two described above (Thermadore or Subzero). We prefer the look of French Door which further limits our options.

First, are there other fridge models we haven't considered that fit the criteria: (1) 36" (2) built-in/integrated and (3) french door w/ bottom freezer?

Second, of the two options I'm looking at, is there one clear winner? We are leaning towards a 36" wolf gas cooktop although we are also considering a 36" Thermadore. From my limited research, Thermadore seems "newer" and less established as a brand than the Subzero/Wolf.

Last, is it just me or are these "higher end" fridges limited in their interior organizational options? I am used to the Samsungs/LGs/Kenmore where the interior has split shelves (two shelves versus one long) that allows you to adjust the height of interior shelving. These "big box" fridge brands (e.g. Samsung, lg, kitchenaid) seem much more functional to me in their interior organization. Its a shame they don't offer the built-in or integrated look.

Thoughts? Many thanks in advance!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

Thermador has been around since the 1950s if not longer so don't let age worry you.

Liebherr also has an integrated FD fridge. (Also Bosch and Gaggenau but they might be variations on the Thermador integrated.)

Personally, I prefer the function of non-integrated builtins like the SZ because the insides are less tall and I am not tall. But the fully integrated Thermador/Bosch/Gagg and Liebherr are so beautifully integrated they almost make up for dedicating so much fridge space to taller people. :)

(There are fewer of the Bosch integrateds now than a few years ago when I was looking--they might not have a paneled version anymore which is a shame since it was CHEAPER and looked just as good concealed in cabinetry. )


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

We have the SZ FD and love it. But then again, I am a SZ fan. Construction is great and customer service is top notch. We had one before we renovated as well. We looked at the Liebherr but the top shelf was too high for me. We also felt that the plastic parts of the interior felt flimsier than the SZ.


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

(There are fewer of the Bosch integrateds now than a few years ago when I was looking--they might not have a paneled version anymore which is a shame since it was CHEAPER and looked just as good concealed in cabinetry. )

the Bosch and the Thermador are one and the same -- identical in all respects except that the Thermador comes in a paneled version and the Bosch does not.


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

I was checking them out thoroughly a few years ago when we did our last kitchen and way back then Bosch had most of the size options as the Therm--even the columns--paneled or SS. The Thermadors had a slightly fancier interior. I settled on the Bosch and then noticed I couldn't reach enough of it. :P

Going to go reach around some fridge displays this weekend and see if I've grown.

I dislike the look of standard paneled built-in fridges, but the integrated ones look great paneled.


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

I dislike the look of standard paneled built-in fridges, but the integrated ones look great paneled.

I've never figured out the difference - pictures? (We have a 30" builtin thermador single door on order --- it will be paneled)


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

Thanks for the great responses. It sounds like Bosch = Thermadore in everything but the name. If we purchased an integrated, we wont do the paneling so that doesn't matter for us. I'm also relatively tall so I'm not too concerned about the height but that is a great point to think about. I just love the sleek full stainless look of an integrated fridge. Seems silly to buy a fridge based on looks alone tho :)

For the subzero owners, do you find the door difficult to open? The floor model was not turned on but I thought the doors required some muscle to pull open. Maybe I'm a wimp but I can't imagine how much harder it will be once on! Maybe its a bonus diet trick but I'd like to be able to open my fridge without hitting the gym or pulling my back.


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

yeesh the bosch reviews are not great on the bosch website. This is troubling bcs these reviews are also applicable for Thermadore.


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

The doors on the SZ are not hard to open. We have 12" (I thnk) appliance pulls on the doors and they open fine.


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

We are making the same decision right now -- either sub zero or thermador for a 36" French Door. I'm leaning towards Thermador based on (i) price (cheaper to start, then factor in the free range hood and it beats the sub by a $3k or more); and (ii) some aesthetic aspects, like the integrated look, the LED column style lighting, and that it would match a touch better with a Thermador range (which includes a free dishwasher). Based on name along, and my support of American manufactured products, I wanted the sub, but it's really hard to justify the extra money, particularly when I already have a hard time justifying the extra spend over the price of a Samsung FD which worked just fine for me for 5 years.

But I would love to hear if anyone has any other thoughts. When is the Sub Zero 42 inch French Door coming out? I see it in the design guide, so I assume sometime this year.


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

The freedom series of Thermador seem to get the best reviews of any Thermador product. They are made in the same factory as the Miele and Gagganeau refrigerators. I have always had the best luck with subzero, but given the prices of their new units, it just seems insanely priced. It's hard to justify the price of the Thermador, let alone the price tag I saw for subzero ($12k). I know a lot of people don't love consumer reports for high end appliances, but at least, I feel good that Thermador Freedom units have been highly rated. I have yet to bite the bullet on the refrigerator as I'm worried about customer service and longevity.


 o
RE: Fridge: Thermadore 36" FD integrated or Subzero 36" FD built

chris401 - can you post the link for the 42" french door? I cannot find a photo. Thanks!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Appliances Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here