Return to the Appliances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Washer - any recommendations?

Posted by aptosca (My Page) on
Mon, Aug 18, 14 at 19:17

My 10 year old Kirkland/ Whirlpool washer just croaked this morning. I did a search and there are too many choices out there. I can't make up my mind. I am looking for a top loader, with the basic choices (regular, PP, delicate). Soak/prewash would be nice. Of course having a choice of water temperature is also a must. But just want a basic washer without any fancy extras.

I have read on this forum that people recommend Speed Queen. I have never heard of that brand. I don't even know if it is available in this area. But am curious, what is the cost of the cheapest model?

Thanks.
Clare


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Washer - any recommendations?

Why not fix your current washer? Those Whirlpool Direct Drives are great machines and are usually cheap/easy to fix. What's wrong with it?


 o
RE: Washer - any recommendations?

You may be better having your existing machine repaired. What about it is not working? These Whirlpool-built washers are easy to repair, parts are reasonable cost. Something simple as a broken drive coupler (can be found online for less than $20) or a lid switch can seem serious when it's not.


 o
RE: Washer - any recommendations?

LOL

To elaborate more, I honestly don't think Speed Queen is any better than your current machine. It is the best top loader on the market today though, though in my opinion it is not as good as the Whirlpool direct drives before the reduced water levels and dumbed down temps.

I would only replace if you wanted to upgrade to a high efficiency machine, and in that case I would buy a front loader. Otherwise I would hold on to your current machine, they don't make them like that anymore!


 o
RE: Washer - any recommendations?

Thanks for the replies. It just stopped working in the middle of the regular cycle. I tried all the other cycles, stopping and starting and I get nothing. It won't drain or agitate. It is completely dead.

If it requires a new motor or transmission (?) then we are talking hundreds of dollars plus a service call charge.I can get a new machine at Sears for around $380. It is 10 years old and something else is bound to break. Life span of washing machine is 8-10 years, so lucky it lasted this long. This is my 4th machine in a 37 year marriage. I seem to replace them every 8-10 years.
Clare


 o
RE: Washer - any recommendations?

In my experience sugar is sugar, salt is salt and a washing machine is a washing machine. I don't think it really matters much other than obviously the more you pay, the better quality and longer life you can expect of it.

We are on our third in 14 years. The 2nd one we picked up used for 40 bucks -- practically stole it.

This new one sings a tune close to Yankee Doddle Dandy when its done!


 o
RE: Washer - any recommendations?

Clare, as I said a dead machine sometimes is not as serious a problem as it seems. I've seen several instances of a wire loose on the motor. A transmission problem won't make the machine dead, the motor would still run (or try to run).

Really, the only reason you're replacing your washer every 8 to 10 years is because you are opting not have them repaired.

My parents had a KitchenAid (same design as yours) that they used for 18 years with a few minor repairs (lid switch, motor coupler, pump) until the timer broke. It was fixable for less than $100 but their machine is in an exterior utility room and exposed to south TX humidity so had developed some cabinet deterioration. I swapped it out instead for a 12-years-old Kenmore (of the same mechanical design) that I had refurbished (a friend gave it to me, they were going to toss it for one of those $15 motor couplers).

I can DIY any repair on these machines, and parts can be had from several online sources at very reasonable prices. Your consideration of course is that you may not have a handyman family member or friend so labor costs would be involved to call-out a service tech.

You are going to find that many new machine will be different than what you have in several ways. Water temperatures are reduced by an electronic sensor that mixes in cold for energy usage considerations. Warm for example may be 75°F to 80°F. Hot may be 105°F to 110°F (which is more like the warm you're getting now). Cycles are longer to finish. Some machines have crippled rinsing that doesn't fill and agitate but rather sprays the spinning load a few times to flush the detergent.


 o
RE: Washer - any recommendations?

"In my experience sugar is sugar, salt is salt and a washing machine is a washing machine. I don't think it really matters much other than obviously the more you pay, the better quality and longer life you can expect of it."

No. There are many different designs. Even among similarly priced designs, some are better than others.

"I can get a new machine at Sears for around $380. It is 10 years old and something else is bound to break."

I agree with everything dadoes said about repair vs. replacement. Do you seriously think that $380 machine from Sears is going to be anywhere near as good as your current machine? Some of these new ones are just as "bound to break" if not more than your 10 year old washer as soon as they come out of the box!

I can take a guess at what the cheap machine is you're considering buying. Is it the new Whirlpool belt (VMW) design? They aren't bad for what they are but they seem cheaply made and I don't expect them to last anywhere near as long as the direct drives. I have taken one apart and own three for rental properties so you can take my word for it. They do have the dumbed down water temps dadoes mentioned, and the lid locks during the cycle. One of the upsides is they are super easy to repair, but for someone who replaces their machine at the slightest sign of a problem that probably isn't a big concern.

Before you replace it or call a repairman let's start with some basic diagnosis. I'm assuming you've already checked the breaker. If not do so. Assuming it is on, do you hear a humming sound when you pull out the timer or is the machine completely silent? Is the machine currently full of water?

Keep in mind that some of these repairs are extremely easy to do yourself and you do not need to be experienced to complete them successfully. There are so many videos, articles, and forums to help you along. Don't assume you'll need a repairman! The biggest impediment to most people is not their lack of experience but rather their confidence.

This post was edited by hvtech42 on Mon, Aug 18, 14 at 22:02


 o
RE: Washer - any recommendations?

To answer your question Clare -- I paid about $750 for my SQ. A lotta dough for a basic washer but I like lit.


 o
RE: Washer - any recommendations?

I owned a Whirlpool top loader purchased new in 1992. I gave it to my son and got a Samsung front loader. Long story short: it was still running strong last year when my son's wife wanted a front loader. That's 21 years. I had a previous WP top loader that was still going strong after 19 years, when the outer tub rusted out where the enamel surface was faulty. The newer one had a plastic outer tub. Of course we are do-it yourselfers and fixed every bad hose or once a start capacitor gave out. When I was removing it I broke a wire off flush with the motor and had to replace it. The fix was still cheaper than a new machine. I had paid about $500 for that machine.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Appliances Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here