Return to the Appliances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

Posted by tipsymcstagger (My Page) on
Thu, Jul 29, 10 at 16:32

I'm looking at the Windster "H" series wall mount stainless/glass range hood. It's available online for $462, shipped. It is very similar to the Broan B5630SS, available from Lowes for $499. I just found the Imperial TW5030PS which is $797 online, also nearly identical to the other two hoods.

I called one on the online sellers of both the Windster and Imperial and asked why I should consider paying nearly $350 additional for the Imperial vs. the Windster. I pointed out that the Windster has a two year warranty while the Imperial only has a one year warranty. The sales person told me "Imperial is one of our higher end brands." I asked what design features make it "higher end?" She had no answer.

So, I'm leaning toward the Windster. Just looking for some feedback from anyone who has experience with these three models before I make a purchase.

Thanks.

Tipsy


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

Imperial makes hoods in Brea,Ca.

Windster will not say where their hoods are made, 99/100 times that means China.

Imperial uses 304 SS.

Windster will not say what SS they use, 99/100 times that means 430 SS, which is less rust resistant than 304.

A warranty is only as good as the company guaranteeing it.

Imperial has manufacutred hoods in the USA for 45 years.

Windster has marketed hoods in the USA since 2003.

Is that worth $350? That is your call.


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

Another factor pertaining to capture and containment, the primary functions of a kitchen ventilation hood, is actual air flow rate (usually specified in cubic feet per minute). The rated rates are typically of the fan alone or of the assembly alone. When ducts are added, the flow rate will decrease. When the house is closed up, the flow rate will decrease further. How much it decreases is dependent on many factors, but the one under the control of the manufacturer is the blade design. Unless the design supports significant flow at typical pressure losses, the flow will decrease to too low a level to provide effective ventilation.

I haven't dealt with any of these sources, but from what has been written above I would guess that Imperial is most likely to provide you with advice about actual flow for a specific setup. Broan publishes fan curves, so with some study one might estimate the flow for their units. No idea about Windster.

kas


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

@deeageaux

For your information, Windster Hood units are made in Taiwan and not China. Look at Imperial's glass series and the Windster's glass series. They are exactly alike. And I know that Windster is the original manufacturer. So you're pretty much letting everyone know you have no idea what you're talking about by comparing two model that's exactly alike and by the same manufacturer. Just because Imperial is a manufacturer located in California doesn't mean that they are any good. You should go do more research before even talking about nonsense about a company/manufacturer that you have no idea about. So to sum it up, 99/100 times you have no idea or have any clue to what you are saying.


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

@dimsumonly

Did I say they were made in China?

I said Windster will not say (on their website) where they are made.That implied China. Yeah,Taiwan. Big huge difference. People's Republic of China vs Republic of China. If Windster is so proud their product is made in the Republic of China why don't they just say it on their website?

Most things made in California are of superior quality than those made in China. Whether ROC or PRC.

They don't make dog food or candy with lead here in California.

You are just showing people you don't know what you are talking about.


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

I bought Broan several times and liked it very much. Very quiet and when I needed a part for the metal screen they sent it for free. Very very good customer support.


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

"FWIW, I recently installed an Imperial 42" island hood with twin blowers (about 1300cfm) over my BS 6 burner range top.

I checked out several different hood brands and chose Imperial because of high power-low noise, quality construction and excellent customer service.

I called Imperial with a problem and they could not have been more responsive and supportive. I'm demanding and not easily impressed and believe me, I was very impressed with their service. I was assisted by an exceptional guy named Oscar.

Hoods and ventilation are somewhat complex and it is easy to make the wrong choice, so do your homework. I researched and spoke with several sellers and had the best experience with a salesperson named Donald at vent4less.com. He was honest and patient with me and more than delivered on everything he promised.

Anyway, my hood is working great, is powerful and is not too loud."

Especially with range hoods, shortcuts are expensive because of the complexity of the installation, etc. Bottom line, you get what you pay for.


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

Kelsold, would you be able to post a photo of your Imperial island hood? I would love to see a photo of how it looks from the front.

I am considering their Slim Line model for my 36" Bluestar which is in front of a window.


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

I went with the Broan.

Tipsy

Image Hosted by ImageShack.us
Shot at 2011-02-18


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

>>I went with the Broan.

How is the function, noise, etc? Is it annoying keeping that glass clean?


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

>>>>>How is the function, noise, etc? Is it annoying keeping that glass clean? <<<<<

The hood works well. I guess it's a bit loud but I only need to use it on "High" occasionally. I don't really have much basis for comparison.

I had to truncate the stainless flue covers because they are intended for an 8' to 10' ceiling height. The soffit conceals a structural beam, so I was unable to eliminate it...resulting in a 7' ceiling along that wall (the ceiling is sloped).

Insofar as the glass...I'm not certain if you're asking about the glass backsplash or the glass hood but in either case, they are no more difficult to keep clean than any other kitchen surface.

Tipsy


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

Beautiful! I love the backsplash! What type of stove is that? I will most likely get a GE Cafe slide in and I am, too, looking at Broans and Windster hoods. I am a bit concerned w/ the stainless finishes matching the appliances...how is your match? Thank you and hope you are enjoying your new space!


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

Thanks very much. The range is KitchenAid Architect Series II, as is the fridge and dishwasher. The microwave is a Sharp under-counter drawer unit.

The stainless all match very well. Hope this helps.

Tipsy


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

On Imperial glass models, they give only a 1 year parts & labor warranty, in home service, because they are made for them in Taiwan. Windster(also made in Taiwan) gives a two year PARTS ONLY warranty, NO LABOR. You get to uninstall the hood to fix it yourself, send them the defective part and only then will they send you a replacement part. Simply put, Imperial will back up their product. All Imperial hoods that are made in California(mostly all of them) come with a 7 year in home parts and labor warranty.


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

@deeageux: there is, in fact, a big difference between Taiwanese and Chinese manufacturing when it comes to stainless steel and range hoods.


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

I am going with Broan - just the right CFMs to prevent MUA system and like the bright lighting over the cooktop. Hopefully will be installed soon.


 o
RE: Range Hoods - Broan vs. Windster vs. Imperial

My builder's appliance 'package' is GE Monogram, including the vent hood. Anyone have experience or an opinion on the GE vent hood?


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Appliances Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Please review our Rules of Play before posting.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here