Return to the Appliances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

Posted by Ron_Ecars (My Page) on
Thu, Jun 5, 14 at 18:30

Hello, I'm in the process of replacing my freestanding electric range with an induction range. I found two display models available at local retail stores. They are Samsung NE597N0PBSR and GE Profile PHB925STSS. The Samsung is the current model and the GE Profile is a discontinued model. They both have features I like.

Our cooking includes stuff like spaghetti, steaks, shrimp scampi, homemade chicken pot pies and barbecue.

Based on experience or knowledge of these two models, which will be the better performer in the long run. I plan to get the 5 yr warranty. Price wise, the Samsung out the door is $1105 with warranty and GE out the door is $1800 with warranty. If the GE is better, is it $700 better or still way over priced?

I have until 6/9 to make a decision. Thanks.

This post was edited by Ron_Ecars on Thu, Jun 5, 14 at 18:32


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

I just got a GE PHB920 induction range and so far(a whole week) I am completely satisfied. I don't know how the 925 is different from the 920. In last year's ratings Consumer Reports gave the GE PHB925 a good score, and they rank GE at the top in reliability.

I looked at Samsung and their offerings are attractive. The local dealer did caution me that getting service can be a challenge. I live in southern Oregon and the nearest factory authorized service tech is in California. If the range is trouble free it doesn't matter where the tech is, but I like to plan for a dark cloud around my silver lining.

GE techs are everywhere, but I would check to make sure the service tech for Samsung is local before going that way.


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

Thank you JeBrooks for your response. That is a good idea to see if there are Samsung techs located here in my area.

I purchased the Samsung, but they are not scheduled to deliver until next week so I can still cancel it since it was a display model. The Samsung is a display model at BB, so I added the 5 yr geek squad protection.

The retailer (smaller local chain) with the GE PHB925 told me to let him know if I want theirs. I purchased most of my current appliance from them in the past.

I do have a question, during your use of the GE range, is it really finicky about pot sizes? I know you should closely match the size of pan to the hob.

The one thing that concerns me on the Samsung is that I have seen a few youtube videos where one pot will work on one hob, but not the other of the same size. The price difference is hard to ignore though :-).


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

Jebrooks, thanks for your recommendation. I looked online for authorized Samsung service/repair places here CLT, and only one was returned.


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

The PHB925 is just the predecessor to the 920. As far as I know they function the same, but the 920 has the updated look to match the rest of GE's new appliances.

With the increase in price for the GE, the advantages are that it's made in the USA and has more accessible service and parts. But, it appears that the Samsung has a more powerful cooktop. Will the Samsung be more or less reliable than the GE? Hard to say, I'd guess they'd be around the same reliability for induction ranges (not so sure in other appliance categories, though). Samsung has 3 fans in the convection oven and they claim that leads it to bake more evenly, but it sounds like a gimmick to me. Given that price difference, I think you made the right choice with the Samsung. It's probably what I would have went with in that situation.


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

The link is to a long thread about pot sizes vs hob sizes. This is my first time linking a url, I hope it works.

The last post is my report on pan sizes and compatibility with the GE hobs. If a small pan works on a hob, any larger pan will work too.

Some manufacturers specify a maximum pan size, but the GE manual does not. GE says pans bigger than the hob are OK, without stating a maximum pan size.

Here is a link that might be useful: Induction Cooktop: Burner & Pot Size Matching


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

Thank HVTech42 & jebrooks!

HVTech -
I like them both, but I may move forward and let BB deliver the Samsung (I may change my mind in the morning though LOL). They told me being Elite Plus with them I have a 45 day return period. I think I should know in a few weeks if I really like it.

The price difference is too large to be ignored. I went by the other store today to look at the GE PHB925 again, they have a price much higher on it then what they quoted me. At that higher price I don't think it will sell anytime soon. Its priced higher than the PHB920. When I asked why, they said is because they paid more for it.

So if I don't like the Samsung, that GE can be one to fall back on if its still available.

JeBrooks -
Thanks for the link. It was very helpful and answered my questions. BTW - I didn't think the GE had a bridge set of hobs. I saw your comments on Samsung which I appreciate someone else's thoughts on it.

I prelisted my current GE Profile radiant range on Craigslist, and someone already offered to buy it when my new one is delivered.

This post was edited by Ron_Ecars on Fri, Jun 6, 14 at 20:53


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

I think you will be pleased with the Samsung especially getting it for $1105 with the extended warranty and the opportunity to return it if you do not like it.

When the dealer tells you that they have to price the GE higher because of what they paid for it --- that seems credible to me. When I had to go stove shopping a couple of years ago, I had been planning on replacing my existing range with an induction range and was seriously considering the PHB925. However, the week before my existing stove up and died, GE had jacked up the prices of the wholesale and suggested retail prices of the PHB925 by about $400. So, if that floor model has been around any length of time, the dealer probably does need to get what is being asked for the GE.

The concern with longevity, durability, and repairability is two-fold, at least the way I saw it when I went stove shopping back in 2012 and was comparing the GE PHB925 with the Samsung NE597NOPBSR.

First, we just don't know about longevity. The GE has been around for four or five years, the Samsung for about three in Canada and about 2 1/2 in the US. That really isn't long enough to establish much of a track record for these induction ranges. The data from the annual membership surveys by Consumer Reports show GE electric ranges as the most reliable, exhibiting a 5% problem rate within the first five years. Samsung has finally sold enough ranges to CR members for it to show up in CR's most recent reports. They are currently exhibiting a 9% problem rate for the first five years of ownershipof Samsung electric ranges. According to CR's fine print, a 4 point difference is on the edge of statistically meaningful. (Some other brands are significantly worse, btw). That being said, we don't know how these overall electric-stove numbers relate to the induction ranges. The induction ranges might be more reliable that their radiant siblings or they might be less so. We just don't know,

Second, there may be more GE servicers out there, and that it might or might not make a lot of difference to you. If you check ConsumerAffairs.com, you will see a lot of complaints about Samsung service being unresponsive and slow. If you need service in the warranty period, GE is likely to be more responsive and give faster service. But, with the GE, you might get stuck with the likes of A&E, the Sears-Whirlpool joint venture that signed a contract with GE a couple of years ago. Search here for "A&E" and you'll find some long running threads on tales of woe and horror about what can go wrong with out-sourced warranty service. If the local dealer with the GE range actually handles warranty service and has a good reputation, that's a benefit well worth considering.

Now, If the two stoves were closer in price, I might be inclined to favor the GE, but, for a $700 savings, the Samsung looks much more tempting. Especially with the BB 45 day return policy.

Beyond the warranty period, my concern would be that both ranges make heavy use of circuit-boards which are the parts most likely to fail if something is going to fail. From the user reports I've seen, the failure of one board can cascade to others. The last time I checked, the boards were expensive and replacing several boards --- and paying somebody to fix things if you don't have the tools and skills to do it for yourself --- starts getting expensive enough that you might wind up considering a new stove whether you have a GE or a Samsung.

Speaking of that BB return policy, I'd want to look at the fine print to be sure that there aren't restocking fees and such.


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

I have had the GE for one year now and really like it. Water boils incredibly fast.

Pot sizes are not a problem. I can go up or down a couple of inches on any hob and the magnet still reads it and cooks just fine.

I like both the warming drawer and the warming zone on the surface.

Both DH and I are serious cooks, and do everything from delicate sauces to homemade breads to lots of ethnic cooking variety.

Plus, it IS an AMERICAN product!!!


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

Thanks Jwvideo and kitykay for your feedback!

The manager at BB who I have dealt with for years told me the GM gave them instructions to price display and open box appliances to move Memorial Day weekend. So the price before taxes and 5 yr warranty for the Samsung was $789.99. I just happened to walk in at the right time and place.

If BB didn't have that low price on the Samsung, I would have bought the GE PHB925 for $1800 (includes taxes, install and 5 yr warr) without hesitation.

I did ask about the PHB920, and he priced that at $1980.00. He said that the cost on the newer GE model was less than the discontinued one, so you are probably correct about timing of the price increase. There is also more stainless steel on the older model which would actually match my current GE profile OTR microwave.

Service:
I called both GE and Samsung (as Jebrooks suggested) to find out about service in my area. Samsung provided me the name of a local service company and A&E. GE told me that there is a GE service center in my area and they also use A&E.

The manager at BB assured me of no restocking fee, especially since it was not special ordered by me (I had them note that on my receipt) and 45 day no question asked return if needed.

The manager, where the GE range is located, said he can understand my decision, and if I decide to return the Samsung he would honor the price he gave me for the GE if it's still available.

Beyond the warranty period is a mystery for most of us, hopefully they are trouble free. I think about power surges that can cause damage, may need to look into a house surge protector.

Tuesday is delivery day, and a couple wants to pick up my current GE profile range immediately following the delivery. Funny, when I listed it on Craigslist I did not think it would sell so quickly.

One last bonus, since I bought the Samsung range Memorial Day weekend, BB was having a promotion of 10x reward points for using standard 30 day BB credit card. So I have ~$100 in BB reward dollars pending :-). I can put that toward a few pots and pans.

This was my first post out here, so thanks for all the support.


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

Don't make this your last post,. :>)

Please give us a report after the stove arrives and you've used it for a bit. There are a couple of long threads about the GE and its predecessor models as well as some posts about the FTQ predecessor of the Samsung NE597, but next to nothing on actually using the NE597.


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

Thanks JWVideo, I will report back after I used it a bit. I hope my report is good.


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

I'm late but...

I have the GE PHB925ST1SS and I love it! Love the induction part of the stove. I never knew about induction till my husband made me aware of it and now I am so thankful we got it.

The only issue I have had with the stove in total is that the oven temperature doesn't read right. I think its a sensor and we have heard that using the self clean function can make it read incorrectly. In other words, I can set it for 350 and it will get there but then heat another 25 degrees or so. I haven't had DH replace the sensor, which isn't a big deal to do, so far I just adjust the setting 25 degrees and all is well.

Now, about Samsung. At the same time we bought our stove, we bought a Samsung fridge. Just after a year, we started having issues with the ice maker. I won't go into full details but Samsung gave us a run around about it (you can google my username and find it). This all went on over many months and in the long run, I made them follow through with their promises but it took patience and gave me more white hair than I had. And from what I have read, its not uncommon in their approach.

So, I hope you got as much warranty coverage as you can get. BTW, with any new appliance, register it with the company and you get an addition 3 months. It was during this time we started having problems.

And if you ever need to call for service - with any company - make sure to keep accurate records of what they commit to doing - take the persons name, date it, get transaction number, and ask for an email to be sent to you to document it - if they refuse to do so, note that as well. Lastly, when the service center sends someone out to "look at your appliance, " get a paper that tells what they are going to do and part numbers to be ordered. I ran into issues as one company wouldn't leave anything till they came back to put the part in. The time lapse between ordering and installing became an issue because of the warranty timeframe.

I don't mean to sound pushy - just want to help someone not have to go through what I did.

Enjoy your induction stove - they are marvelous!


 o
RE: Samsung vs GE Profile Induction Range

Hello mboston -

Thank you for the response. My new Samsung Induction range was installed this past tuesday (6/10). The install occurred without any issues. They made sure it was leveled and powered on. In regards to the warranty, I did purchase the extended 5 years warranty.

Sorry you had issues with your Samsung Fridge. We have a Samsung French Door Fridge about two years now, and so far no issues. We opted for the ice maker in the freezer and water dispenser inside the door vs externally. I did get the extended warranty on that as well. I will definitely follow your advice in case I need to call for a repair on any of my Samsung appliances (includes washer and dryer too).

JWVideo and others -

So far the stove has been great. All of my induction ready pots/pans have worked on each hob. I actually picked up a couple of All-Clads 10 - 12" fry pans from HomeGoods that were on clearance. I am still getting use to the all touchpad controls vs the knobs controls.

Cooking has consisted of searing steaks, making shrimp scampi and normal breakfast foods. All, thus far went extremely well. The water for pasta boils extremely fast.

The oven seems to pre-heat faster than my old GE profile radiant range. I can not tell you about even oven temp, but I have used it to make chicken pot pie without issues. It does seem to bake well, and all three oven fans come on in convection mode.

Funny, how this range seems to make cooking easier and more enjoyable lol.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Appliances Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here