Return to the Appliances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

Posted by My4thGarden (My Page) on
Thu, May 30, 13 at 8:44

Does anyone have recommendations for a dishwasher that has a truly HEATED dry cycle?

I know that KitchenAid makes some models with a heat dry option but I am also reading numerous complaints and reports of problems with it not working properly. Apparently this is a known issue with at least the KitchenAid model 30 series... Don't know if it is the same for all KitchenAid models with the heated dry or not.

Any other brand choices for a dishwasher with a dry cycle having an actual heating element rather than just a fan?


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

There are two companies that make dishwashers with a truly HEATED dry cycle; Whirlpool and GE.

GE makes various GE brands like Profile, Café , and Monogram,

Whirlpool makes KitchenAid, JennAir, Kenmore Pro/Elite as well as tiny luxury niche brands like Heartland.

Whirlpool is better regarded than GE when it comes to dishwashers.

The problem here is new federal water and electric energy star regulations. Every watt spent drying is a watt not spent on the water pumps cleaning the dishes. Every watt spent on a hard food disposer is a watt not spent on the water pump cleaning dishes.

As American regulations converge with European regulations the German/European solutions work best. Enzyme based detergent to break down food instead of electricity consuming hard food disposers and rinse-aid/vented drying instead of heated dry.

If Federal regulators allowed Whirlpool to use as much water and electricity as they wanted in their dishwashers Whirlpool could make dishwashers like the Hobart of old and gives clean dry dishes in 20 minutes.

Miele can give you clean dry dishes. Uses less water and electricity too. It just takes 2-2.5 hrs.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

I'm a little confused by your answer deeageaux - I thought all manufacturers met the Energy Star standards using one particular cycle (e.g. with heated dry turned off). I thought the heated dry was in that sense independent of the energy used for cleaning.

To the OP: I have a 10 year old KA with heated dry - it cleans and dries well. There have been some reported issues with some recent KA models so do your research and be careful.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

My bocsh without heated dry, dries must better then my kenmore it replaced that had heated dry.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

Same with my Bosch. It does a better job of drying than my old KA.

Bonnie


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

My Bosch does not dry as well as my ten year old jennair. The middle rack is never dry. We have to empty the middle shelf every day so items can air dry in the drainboard.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

I would agree with others, my new Miele without a heated dry does way better at drying that my old whirlpool that did have it.

Get a Miele, you won't regret it in my opinion.

Phil


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

Could I add the best to dry that has a panel front fully integrated look? Thanks.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

I was dead set that my next DW had to have heated dry. I was talked into a Bosch after hearing the neighbors new KA and seeing the steam pouring out the side exhaust onto their cabinets. I am surprised at how much I like our Bosch. We leave the door shut until long after it is cool and it is always dry.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

Actually I currently have a Miele and have hated it since Month #1 (in the early 2000s!) because it does not dry without the use of rinse aid which I don't want to use. If I had known that about Euro DWs (which don't have a heated dry, like my previous vintage KA had) I would never have bought one. Hence my determination to make sure my next DW has a true heated dry instead of that ridiculous fan-dry system.

Another reason I hate the Miele is that when I did use it, the 2+ hour run time was ridiculous.

The Miele does a nice job as an additional pair of (hand washed) dish drainers though, LOL


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

i have a miele dimention plus (dec 2011) and everything just drys up great.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

So, what is the problem for you with rinse aids? Please do not take this as a rhetorical or mocking question. Do you have a medical reason for avoiding them? Or do you simply object to having to spend more money on cleaning dishes? Or is it something else?

I ask this because, as far as I could tell from my unexpected shopping expedition for a replacement DW last year (almost to the day, oddly enough), every current model DW I saw and/or researched required rinse-aids. From the cheapest Crosley at our local (very rural) hardware store to anything available from the Lowe's in my state's largest city to the boutique brands on offer from "high-end" retailers --- every one of them required a rinse aid. Of course, the DWs all can be run withou any rinse aid, but you may get spotting

Also, I found there are relatively few residential dishwashers these days that do not have extremely long cycle times. To me, a long cycle time is 1.5 hours. I bought a Bosch that will run a full cycle in about 1.5 hours. Most things are dry enough for me to put away in a few minutes after a cyle finishes, but your standards on this may vary. Everything else I saw had much longer times except for one KA model that apparently clocked at 115 minutes for a cycle. (I think it was a KUDS60 series model which was above my budget.)

I found some Kitchenaid and other models that Consumer Reports' testing said did a good job with heated drying but the cycles took well over two hours to complete and the one with stainless-steel tubs all seemed to cost twice what I paid for the Bosch. And they still required rinse-aids. In answer to your question about the heated dry not working on KitchenAIds, I did run across numbers of posts about the "KUDS30" series but couldn't figure out how much of the problem was not using rinse aids, very hig humidty locations, very hard water, circuit board or other component failures, and how much it might have been been other things or a poor product design.

I looked at Mieles but none of them had a heated dry cycle and, again, their specified cycle times were over two hours and they required rinse-aids and the were a lot more expensive than the Bosch I bought. I know a couple of folks who have Mieles ("crystal" models, IIRC) and the dishes all seem dry-enough to me. Cycle times all seem to be roughly 140 minutes and they do require/specify rinse aids.

When Deeagaux says Whirlpool brands (including KitchenAid) are "better regarded" than GE, this is borne out by the reliability reports from Consumer Reports' annual membership surveys. Bosch, Whirlpool (WP branded) and Miele are significantly the most reliable brands with about an 8% defect rate in the first 5 years of ownership. I think he is mostly correct that only GE and Whirlpool supply heated dry DWs, although it seems to me that, when I was shopping last summer, some of the less-expensive Frigidaire DWs also had heated dry cycles. IIRC, they also had very long cycle times, like on the order of 2.5 hours.

This post was edited by JWVideo on Tue, Jun 18, 13 at 20:39


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

I have a new KA SS dishwasher - model number KUDE50CXSS- I've had it about 2 months now. It does have a heated dry option, and I use the one hour wash with the heated dry option 95% of the time - I put dishes in without rinsing (but I do scrape off heavy food items), dirty greasy casserole dishes etc. - it takes about 1 hour 20 minutes with the heated dry. I use either Quantum Finish Tabs or the new Cascade Platinum Tabs with either Cascade RA or Quantum Finish RA - my dishes and glasses are sparkling clean. This dishwasher is super quiet, and I am very pleased with its perfomance - way better than the Bosch I replaced.
It does not have the upper cutlery rack, we did not want that. I am happy with the jumbo silverware basket along the bottom. The only thing I don't like is that my dinner plates shift around a bit - I found out later that the rack was designed this way to accommodate larger dishes, pyrex etc.
I was worried the dishes may chip, but this has not happened. Very happy with this KA.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

i don't think any dishwashers requires rinse aid, right? I do dishes without rinse aid all the time. The point of the rinse aid is to make them your dishes and glassware spotless after they have been dried inside the dishwasher.. which looks more presentable especially if you have guests.. Even if i don't use the rinse aid sometimes, the dishes will still be perfectly clean and dry, and the waterspots are not bad at all.. maybe a few on clear glassware.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

I have a GE Profile PDWT580VSS. I think there are some less expensive models in their line which essentially do the same thing. But it's worked perfectly for me for the past year I've had it. The heated dry works well for me when I use it.

It has this SmartDispense feature which I didn't think would be a big deal but is great -- I only fill the dishwasher with detergent about every 3-4 months.

It replaced a Bosch which, despite generally positive reviews, for me was terrible -- it didn't wash, it didn't dry, and it didn't have a lot of room inside.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

"i don't think any dishwashers requires rinse aid, right?"

No, many of the newer DWs that rely on condensation drying need a rinse aid.

They figured it was more effective to add heat to the water (warming the dishes).

The detergents work better in the hotter water also.

The thinner film of water remaining with the rinse aid usedc then evaporates off the dishes and condenses on the outer walls of the DW.

Low mass items (plastic usually) do not dry as well since with a smaller mass they cannot hold as much heat.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

You also need to use a rinse aid now becuase the FEDS have made detergent maker take out phosphate, which kept dirt from going back on the dishes.
GE vs Whirpool
As a person that sells both I have more problems with Whirlpool products as well as thier customer service.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

bluestar or capitol culinarian


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

Might want to check that post. Looks like it went to the wrong thread. This one is about dishwashers, not ranges or cooktops.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

Ooops, double post. Sorry.

This post was edited by JWVideo on Wed, Jun 19, 13 at 23:25


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

No it was deliberate. FmrQuahog is a troll.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

No offense taken at your question, JVVideo. :-) The reason I avoid using rinse aid is medically based; in addition to having multiple chemical sensitivities, I am also a former cancer patient. So I make a serious effort to greatly reduce or eliminate coming into contact with chemically (rather than naturally) based products. For instance I never use fabric softener and my laundry detergent is the 7th Generation brand which is also free and clear of dyes and fragrances. I also use naturally sourced shampoo and don't wear makeup or hair styling products, and wear only 100% natural fabrics such as cotton, linen and wool.

But getting back to the rinse aid question, I never needed it in my old Kitchen Aid which completely dried all the dishes with its blast-furnace heated dry cycle, LOL. When I first got the Miele I did not use rinse aid and of course found that everything remained wet. When I contacted Miele I was told that rinse aid was required for drying. Not a happy camper to hear this, but I decided that I would give it a try to see if it made a dramatic difference. I set the rinse aid dispenser to the recommended setting which was 3. The first thing I noticed was that when I filled one of the cleaned glasses with drinking water, it created some soapsuds on the water surface that did not go away. This was the case with all of the glassware and the bowls that had been washed by the Miele using rinse aid. I had to thoroughly rinse all of these items by hand in order to get them clean enough so that putting water into them wouldn't create any suds! When I contacted Miele about this new issue I was told that "of course the rinse aid leaves a slight surface residue because that is the way rinse aid works". And so, since I don't want to be drinking out of, or eating off of or with, items that have a film of chemical residue on them (which is why I don't use fabric softener, or laundry detergents with brighteners, both of which do the same thing) , I do not use rinse aid at all. (I did try using the two lower rinse aid settings but #2 still produced the suds and #1 left everything wet, thus no point). I have been told about the vinegar method but I have also read that it can damage the dishwasher parts so it seems to be a case of damned if you do and damned if you don't, LOL.

What is interesting is that on the very few occasions when I have run the dishwasher after the original rinse aid test had been flushed out of it, there are absolutely no suds in any of the glassware or bowls. So it definitely was not coming from the detergent but indeed from the rinse aid function as the Miele rep said.


 o
RE: Best dishwasher with a heated dry option?

Some of these folks that are saying that their old dishwasher (With a heater), did not dry as well as their new Bosch or Miele obviously had a bad or weak heater, or they did not have the heater turned on.

While I do have a Miele Optima, and I really like it, No WAY does it dry like the 3 old Kitcheaids I had.

In fact it took me "quite a while", to get used to reaching in to get the dishes in the Miele, (even right after it finsihed),. and NOT Hollerin "YOWSAH", as I used to do with the old KA's.
(YOWSAH being my exclamation!!!! when I grabbed a very not dish, looked for a place to set it down, (real fast like), cause I didn't wait for the dishes to cool.

Now YOU TELL ME, how can something be that hot and not dry????? (Most Unlikely).

Like I said, I really do like my Miele, but "Just the Facts", Just the Facts Mam!!!!

Gary


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Appliances Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here