Realize you are considering ice and water in the door, but I have an interior water dispenser Kitchen Aid french door and the water is very cold. I seldom use the ice from the freezer. An added advantage for me was more interior room in the refrigerator.

I have a Kitchen Aid that is now ten years old. It has ice and water through the door and the water is quite cool. The water filter is a real nuisance to change on mine. I literally have to lie on my stomach on the floor to do it. It is such a pain that I just took it off and do without it. Fortunately it is not necessary here.

Mine is a side by side and it has never needed a repair in 10 years. Knock wood! I would never get a side by side again. The french door fridges were just coming out when I bought this and some glitches at that time.

The water in our KA is cool as well. The water filters in the newer fridges are much easier to change now, a little door in the ceiling in the interior of the fridge.

Thanks everyone! The sales rep keeps saying its cool not cold. I am looking at a side by side because of my space and that's what I have now. A bosch SxS counter depth. ( If you have seen any of my past posts i have had so much trouble with the fridge in a year and a half that they are buying back all my appliances even the ones i love :( I know it may be small for some but I love the size because I have an overflow freezer in the garage and shop several times a week to keep produce fresh. I was tempted to get the FD with interior water but I just don't think it would work for my son.