Return to the Appliances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Wine Refrigerator

Posted by have2cats (My Page) on
Tue, Mar 22, 11 at 9:11

We are looking for an undercounter wine refrigerator to go in our Butler's Pantry. Any recommendations?

Thanks so much!


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

I bought the KitchenAid Architect KUWS24RSBS, based on visual inspection and online ratings. But it is still in the box in the living room, so I can't attest to whether it is really wonderful. It's attractive, though. I wanted the SSS, but since it will be built in, the black sides of the SBS don't really matter.

Here is a link that might be useful: KA Architect


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

Summerbabies, thanks for the info. That one looks really nice.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

We have been really pleased with our U-Line Wine Captain Drawer Model. It is quiet and has given us no problems in the three years we have had it.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

akrogirl, thanks I'll check these out too.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

How long are you storing the wine in the cabinet? I.e., is this for storing wines you are using in the next few weeks at most, or do you want to also use the cabinet for aging of any bottles?

If relatively short-term storage, the unit does not have to be as rigorous in maintaining an even temp, humidity etc. Most of the residential units should do ok, and it comes down largely to aesthetics, noise level, etc. Also, you need to decide if you want one or two temp zones...personally, in an undercounter unit I have a hard time believing that 2-zones really works that well. Perlick is very robust, though pricey; Marvel has a pretty good reputation and nice features, but is a bit loud (I can confirm this from personal experience now, it was a bit disturbing), U-Line seems to have really improved their product lately and looks pretty nice. Liebherr seems nice at a decent price, and they seem to place some priority on the segment. I Can't comment from any direct experience regarding the wine units from the mainstream brands like Kitchenaid, GE, etc., but in general I would think that if their other undercounter refrigeration has a good reputation - especially beverage centers - then you will probably be ok for short term storage use.

If you are looking to age at all, I would suggest you seriously consider a unit from a company specializing only in wine appliances. Eurocave does a built-in that you can integrate, though its a bit expensive given its size (about $2700). The Wine Enthusiast website sells a housebrand, N'FINITY, that is definitely worth looking at. They can be built-in, and are very affordable (usually under $1000) for what you get. Transtherm also has a small unit called the "mas" and/or "studio" that can be built-in; I own the bigger "Bastide" unit from Transtherm, and have been very happy with it for the cost.

Whatever you get, remember:

(1) Whatever capacity they claim, you will not fit anywhere near that number of bottles unless they are all exactly standard bordeaux bottles and you stack them for maximum capacity, not easy access. This is just a fact of life with wine cabinets.

(2) Extra shelves are often a separate accessory, and can cost more than you expect.

(3) Always keep the cabinet full, even if it is with bottles of water....the mass of the contents acts as a temperature reservoir to keep things even and prevent swings. By keeping it full, your conditions will be better and you will likely use less energy as well.

Hope that helps some, instead of making it just more confusing....


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

jsceva- Thank you so much for all of the info. This will be our first wine refrigerator so we had no idea what to look for. This will mostly be for short term storage. We'll definitely look into the Wine Enthusiast line.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

No problem. You might also consider getting a very small residential built-in or even countertop unit for immediate use indoors, and placing a bigger more long-term unit in the garage, basement, etc. You might get more for your money that way (i.e., the bigger unit will be ugly and possibly noisy, but work really well, while the inside unit will not work as well but will be much more attractive and quieter).

Also, are you looking to store reds, whites, or a little of both? If all red, proper storage temperature and serving temperature are pretty close. Probably a little colder than most are used to in US (about 55 degrees), but actually better usually than the full room temp usually served here. Its also a good temp for keeping/aging beers that improve with cellaring, like some Belgians. If you are looking at storing all white or sparkling, you can store a few degrees lower, but you will probably want to chill even further for service... you can store it at service temperature, but that retards aging so it isn't ideal for the longer term. I keep all mine at red storage temperature, and when I pull out a white or sparkling I either (a) put it in the regular fridge for a while, if I have planned ahead, or (b) use an electric wine chiller (the kind that has cold packs and swirls chilled water around the bottle - pretty cheap at bed bath and beyond or similar.

In general, the exact temp isn't as important as avoiding rapid swings in temperature - it is the rapid changes back and forth that damage the wine most. Choosing a temp too cold will slow down aging, and too warm will speed it up, but swinging back and forth rapidly will quickly destroy your bottle. Humidity and vibration are also concerns, of course, but temp is the biggie.

What part of the country are you in? If you are in a wine-growing area, there is likely at least one brick and morter store specializing in wine storage. In northern california, for example, the Wine Hardware Store (which is associated with the Wine Appreciation Guild, and is also online) has four physical locations where you can go actually see/touch units...


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

jsceva, we are in Northern Virginia. We will probably store a mix of red and white. We are just now starting to enjoy wine, so we're still learning. :)


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

Try the Vinotemp VT-50SBW wine cooler. I hope it can help you to decide.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

The point about capacity above is just right. Or, at least, it's right for every one that I've seen. Our vinotemp is supposed to hold about 5 cases of wine ... good luck with that. Maybe 4 cases -- let's say, 40-something bottles.

OTOH, we've had the unit for a few years and it seems to be doing a good job. Temp seems to be stable, no noise issues (although, frankly, it's in a storage room and that's no a huge concern) -- no complaints at all.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

greencleaning, djg1, thanks we're going to take a look at the Vinotemps this weekend.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

To decide which model suits your well,you have to consider a lot. www.secowinefridge.com gives a few tips on choosing. Also you could check their wine coolers, SECO-SW25 & SECO-SW55 might be suit for your first trial.

Here is a link that might be useful: seco wine fridge.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

Note that once you start enjoying your reds at celler temp, it is hard to go back! you'll be asking the waiter at the restaurant for an ice bucket for your syrah...

I have a big 400 bottle unit in the garage and a smaller unit in the house for mostly whites as jsceva recommends.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

i have been using one from GE Monogram for about 6 years, it is pretty quiet and problem free.


 o
RE: Wine Refrigerator

""www.secowinefridge.com gives a few tips on choosing.""

SECO, Where are this tips on your site? I just saw specs and product info. Tips would be like jsceva's post above.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Appliances Forum

Instructions

  • You must be a registered member and logged in to post messages on our forums.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review the contents and make changes.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • It is illegal to post copyrighted material without the owner's consent.
  • HTML codes are allowed in the message field only.
  • No advertising is allowed in any of the forums.
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.



 
Click here to learn more about in-text links on this page.