Return to the Appliances Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Induction or Gas cooktops

Posted by avidchef (My Page) on
Wed, Feb 15, 12 at 12:10

Can anyone evaluate the pros and cons of induction cooktops versus gas cooktops? Which cook tops do you recommend - please comment on 36 and 48
inch.
Please discuss any issues with retrofitting above a bank of drawers.


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

I have just gone through my own decision hell.
Briefly, I will share my thoughts but others are more eloquent than I.
If you can get natural gas, many people love it. I loved it but I would have to have propane and was told it would still not really compare to natural gas.
If you are looking for 48", I don't believe induction is available in that, though you could add a 12" unit to a 36" unit to obtain that.
There are only a few induction that have auto-turn off hobs. Some think that is a deal breaker and others consider it simply a nice feature.

Type in "induction" in the search and read some of the nice threads already here and then perhaps you can post back on any specific questions.


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

There are no 48" induction cooktops;36" is the largest size.Any accurate info about installation has to be done once a particular cooktop is picked. Lots of threads on this google "gardenweb induction installation."

The largest gas "cooktops" are Miele at 42" and Dacor at 46".

There are plenty of 48" gas rangetops. The only ones that will compare to better induction cooktops are Capital Culinarian and Bluestar RNB.

See link below for gas vs induction threads.

Here is a link that might be useful: LINK


 o
RE: Induction versus open flame burners

Thanks everyone.

Let me clarify. I am debating between a 48 inch BS or CC cooktop or an induction. Thermador is debuting an induction cooktop that is completely induction - no burner rings. The Thermador Freedom Induction Cooktop is the first full-surface induction appliance. According to Thermador "It features the flexibility of a natural-mapping user interface that intelligently recognizes cookware size, shape and position to deliver heat without boundaries."
It will be in the same price range as BS or CC.
Size of the induction top is not an issue because if I got a BS or CC it would be 48 to accommodate a grill and in the case of BS a french top. With induction the french top becomes a moot point, but I would miss the grill. But, that is another issue and not really relevant here.
What a really want to know is the pros and cons of induction versus open flame burners.


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

That particular Thermador unit is what is called "zoneless". It has something like 48 induction drivers below the surface. When you put a pan on it, the drivers sense the presence of the pan and the computer figures out the shape of the pan from the drivers that sense its presence. This means you can put any size or shape pan on the surface and the computer will do the rest. You can also slide the pan around and the computer will keep track of where the pan is located.

IIRC, there is a limit to the number of pans going at once, like 4 or 5 depending on the size of the unit (30" or 36").

It also means that you can put a rectangular grill pan on it successfully (steel, not aluminum).


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

"What a really want to know is the pros and cons of induction versus open flame burners."

That generally descends into an emotional flame war.

There are marginal pros and cons to each but usually it comes down to which you "like" better.


In general the topic has been discussed to death in previous threads. I think you have read the particular advantages to full-surface induction vs standard induction.

Are you a modernist or tradionalist?

Are you more likely to wait 12 hrs in line at an Apple store for the next I-phone or more likely to buy a mechanical Swiss wrist watch?

Induction fans will tout things like the safety of auto shutoff.

Gas fans will tell you cast iron open flames are a tried and true technoloy. The long term durability and possible repair cost to next generation full-surface induction is unknown.

There is nothing like roasting peppers or marshmellows over an open flame.The precision of induction temps is unmatched. You know this food should be cooked at "7" instead of a general "medium" for example.

Specialized cookware vs any cookware. Some magnetic cookware does not work on induction.

Induction is mechanically more efficient. Gas is cheaper to operate.

Induction produces less heat that needs to ventilated from the kitchen.

In the Nordic-Germanic countries trained professional chef's usually go with induction for new kitchens. In the Latin European countries usually open burner gas.Yes,there are famous exceptions but I said "usually."


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

For me it was easy, couldn't wait to get rid of gas. The ease of wiping a flat surface clean compared to scrubbing/scraping in, on, around and below heavy burners was a no brainer. Plus eliminating more heat emanating into the kitchen was a bonus. With the power and precision of induction, I just don't see the rationale for gas anymore. Unless, I guess, you're a die hard traditionalist, want the look, must roast peppers/marshmallows in your kitchen....???


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

Thank you everyone for the responses. I guess what I really want to know are there downsides to induction cooking?
My kitchen currently has two ranges - one gas, one electric. When I built my
kitchen 20 years ago, I wanted an electric oven for baking and gas burners. The only option was two ranges because I wanted a large capacity electric oven. Two years ago I replaced my gas range in a hurry and got a GE cafe gas model which I intensely dislike (uneven oven temps, poor simmer etc.) But it does give me access to gas burners. So the most frequently mentioned cons are a non issue for me.
I just called Thermador and the Freedom top will not be available until June or July. Since I need to replace my non functioning range before then, another question for me is pot sizes. I often have two or three oversize stock pots simmering at the same time (20 quart or more)- the bottoms are 12 -14 inches. Are there induction cooktops out there now that accommodate 3 large pots simultaneously? Any brand recommendations or ones to stay away from?


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

... Or, unless you live somewhere where electric power can be unreliable -- meaning occasionally you may not eat for a few days unless you have gas.

A point that has not been made clearly here (though I'm sure it's been discussed in the threads deeageaux linked above) is that you don't necessarily have to get one OR the other: It sounds like you have room for induction AND gas as well. This could be the best choice, depending on your (so far, unstated) individual needs and preferences.


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

I went induction and am t-1+ week to demolition and remodel.
The reasons I went induction
-Safety
-Control
-Don't like the smell of gas
-Added work surface

I wish I could have waited for the zoneless although probably out of price range

Also - induction choices are changing rapidly - so this is a relevant thread!

Disadvantages
-Griddle - still haven't found one that meets my needs - but do have an electric one but will miss my all clad double (which is aluminum)
-Special pans - my old aluminum will be stored in my basement for my "vacation home" of the future.


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

67 threads discussing your question. Many go into detail after detail comparing the two as well as conventional radiant electric.

Here is a link that might be useful: Induction vs gas threads


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

As far as I know, there isn't an induction unit out currently that will accomodate 3 12 inch stockpots at one time. My Miele will accomodate one 12 quart stockpot and two other 8-9 inch pans.

I love my induction cooktop, for the ease of maintaining even cooking temperatures, the power, and the absolutely effortless cleanup. If you have room for 48 inches of cooktop, you could do as some folks here have done and install an induction cooktop, with two additional gas burners next to it.

Cj


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

Thanks everyone. I found the threads people referenced very helpful. I especially liked the induction website. It had an incredible amount of information. In case anyone else needs large hobs, I found that Thermador makes an induction with a 13 inch hob (1-6, 2-7's, and a 9). MSRP is $3699.00 for one model and
$4,099.00 for another.


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

Ditto chac_mool.

I'm in the middle of going from electric to gas. There a number of stovetop-roasting operations that require an open flame (e.g. eggplant is incredible if your start out roasting over an open flame, and it's great for the final phulka with chapatis). Some of us like the visual cue of the flame.

But if I could truly start over including all new cookware, I'd get a 30" induction cooktop plus one gas burner ... maybe even the kind made for a wok. The efficiency benefits of induction are just unbeatable.


 o
RE: Induction or Gas cooktops

I found this quite interesting: Seems the Thermador Freedom Induction cook top got quite the review!
http://appliancebuyersguide.com/most-ridiculous-appliance-awards/

I purchased the 36" Bosch Induction cook top and cannot wait to use it. Europe has been using induction for a long time. Not sure why we haven't caught on yet. They love it and so do most people I know who do use them!


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Appliances Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here