Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
chibimimi

Replacing blades on sterling flatware

chibimimi
11 years ago

I have a set of Wallace Carmel sterling flatware. The original blades on the knives are silverplate and have corroded badly. Can anyone recommend someone to replace these blades with stainless ones? Several places advertise this service, but I'm a bit hesitant to ship the knives off to persons unknown.

Comments (9)

  • lindac
    11 years ago

    Let me know when you find someone....I have some too.

  • antiquesilver
    11 years ago

    I've never had any done for the same reason.

    I experimented on a few of my worst ones when I bought a couple of premium antique knives for pennies on the dollar because of the corroded blades & I didn't think I could hurt the blades. I cleaned the blades with 0000 steel wool (primarily the cutting edge) to remove the rust/corrosion/bubbled plate & then lightly coated with mineral oil. Much improved - the blades aren't silvery but they don't disgrace the table, either. Since then I haven't thought about having them replaced. Also, I find the carbon steel blades to be much sharper than the stainless replacements.

  • lindac
    11 years ago

    Please post a picture of your "fixed blades"...Did you remove all the silver plate? And is it carbon steel underneath?

  • antiquesilver
    11 years ago

    Linda, I'll charge my camera & try to get a photo posted on Sunday. As I recall I removed as little silver plate as possible but corrosion & wear had already done a pretty good job before I got to it. The blades are steel although perhaps I mispoke about the carbon part; actually, I thought carbon steel was what all old blades were made of.

  • antiquesilver
    11 years ago

    Reed & Barton's Les Cinq Fleurs, patented 1900


    4 dinner knives The one on the left was purchased separately from a different seller & has an acceptable blade.

    The 3 'bad' blades

    The worst blade has a chewed up cutting edge as well as severe pitting that would take something more aggressive than 0000 steel wool to fix; mostly, it lives at the bottom of the silver chest. The 2nd one still has one spot of deep corrosion but is much smoother than it used to be. The 3rd one doesn't look too bad but you can still feel some slight bumpiness to the surface where there is underlying light corrosion. No matter how bad they look now, they're a lot better than they were when I got them.

    These blades were heavily plated to begin with & I think the plate loss due to steel wool was minimal although the sheen is now more of a satin finish than before.

  • Eve Breckenridge
    2 years ago

    I want to replace my blades myself Why cant I find the replacement blades. I have removed the old blades no problem using a heat gun

  • patriciae_gw
    2 years ago

    Have you considered liquid silver plate? You rub your knives smooth and then replate the with liquid silver plate. I have done that with other silver plate items. Wouldn't it work on knives?

  • lindac92
    2 years ago

    I an sure it would....but would wear off at the first use.