Return to the Antiques & Collectibles Forum | Post a Follow-Up

 o
Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Posted by flyleft (My Page) on
Thu, Nov 1, 12 at 14:27

Hi folks,
I'm having the devil's own time trying to figure out a ballpark value for a tablecloth I found (see flickr)...literally, the only one Ive been able to find like it was one that went for over $900 on eBay recently, but that one had figures and a nice provenance. Mine is an Italian Cantu cloth, banquet size, made of thousands of the finest cantu curls and flowers *all over*...and in fabulous shape. There is a center area where the four rectangles of pattern converge with larger scallops making a subtle centerpiece, but not with a huge medallion.

But even without extra embellishment, it's unreal, it's *so* gorgeous. I also can't keep it, because never in my life will I have a 12' table, and if I did, I certainly wouldn't use this work of art to put under food.

I have no idea where I could get it appraised. Does anyone know? I've tried to find online and all I've gotten is confirmed that it is cantu, but no value. I wouldn't trust a general antique appraiser because lace/textile folks are their own specialty, compared to say, glass, toy or furniture people.

Any leads at all would be most appreciated. I can only imagine the grandmother who is spinning in her grave to see that her grandchildren donated this masterpiece to a thrift shop. But it's happened in my family (my father did it), so I guess it can happen in others...

Here is a link that might be useful: link to some photos


Follow-Up Postings:

 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

I should add that the one expert who looked at the photos said it was definitely handmade. Lacemakers fill me with awe.


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Oh yeah it's hand made!!...The value has to be inestimable...I can't believe one went for only $900.
Not sure it's cantu.....there are several similar, like Bruges and another Italian lace....but that's all moot...."a rose....etc".
I would suggest a museum....for appraisal. Surely you have seen the site linked below?

And remember, it doesn't take a 12 foot table to use a 12 foot cloth...only an 8 foot table. But I wouldn't be serving spaghetti from that table cloth!!
Just curious......where did you "find" it??

Here is a link that might be useful: lacy stuff....


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

To me, it looks like crochet and handmade. It is fantastic. It is very difficult to make large crocheted pieces to come out square and straight edged. I would use it as a table cover, but never serve food over it!


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Linda, thanks very much for your help. I didn't read that site carefully before because the piece is figural and mine isn't--but because you linked to it and I decided finally to read it through, I found the name of the person who looks to be the preeminent lace evaluator in the US! I'll let you know what she says. I'm contacting her tonight.

jem, thanks for your reply. It's not crochet. I have crocheted lace and it has a dimensionality that this doesn't. All of it lies flat.But you're right about the rest of it : )


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Well, update of a kind: I have written her twice, once even with a link to the file even though I had said I didn't want to bother her with pics until I was sure she is still appraising lace, and she hasn't gotten back to me : ( I want to know about this tablecloth!! Everyone else seems to have gotten appraisals from her...I hope she's o.k. and there's a simple explanation...it seems like she would be The One to ask.

*long, patient but self-pitying sigh*


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Patience......and I think that's an operetta by Gilbert and Sullivan....


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Yes I believe it is, one which I've meant to see and *still* never have! Thanks for diverting me for a little while : )


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Um, Linda...

I got a reply from a person who wrote on behalf of The One, so presumably the information comes from T.O. herself:

It is indeed what I thought it was, every bit, and it's worth a minimum of $2/*SQUARE INCH*.

It's 144x70.

I'm still feeling a bit weak in the knees.


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

I bought some acid-free wedding gown paper to wrap it in. I think I'll do that tonight.


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

I think I would....(fanning herself and feeling weak in the knees...)
But the question is....could you find a buyer for...say $.50 a square inch?


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Exactly; that's just the followup question I wrote back just now. I am wondering what are the most reputable venues through which to sell this kind of thing, and what that figure is: auction, retail, insurance replacement value? I mean, .50/sq. inch would still be the best thing I've ever found (it's closer to two other things, but it would top out the other two, and be the bottom estimate of the lace, so the lace wins : )).


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Keep us updated....if you would get close to what it's worth....it could finance a lot of other thrift store buys!:-)


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Such good news, Fly! Hope you find someone who will treasure and use it! If so, what are you going to treat yourself to with the proceeds?


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Hi Cyn & Linda - Cyn, I wish I could say it would finance a trip to Auckland to camp outside a certain dome-cranium recording studio...but I'll be responsible : )

I'm actually thinking of saving it/using it to start purchasing higher-end pieces that would be investments over time. I've realized my best investments have been my thrift shop purchases, seriously, and the next step up, with a corresponding loss in multiple of return, would/will be auctions, but that is much tricker...but at any rate, I am not going to count my eggs before they hatch - I want it to find its right home, which may take months, before I start fantasizing. That way lies madness.


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

At $2 per square inch, you piece computes to $20,160. This is a large sum, however, $2 per square inch seems a reasonable price for handmade antique lace in good condition. You have a winner. Your problem will be getting a fair price for it.

It might pay to have an appraisal made. Is the Antiques Road Show coming your way soon?


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Lol Fly. I was going to suggest that it might pay for concert tickets-ha. I like the way you think better-go for it all!

I will look around to see what I could sell and go with you. :)
Cynthia


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Cyn, just for you: have you heard this? Find the 1992 Roskilde transmission, and click on the first one. See, I find treasures everywhere : )

Here is a link that might be useful: for a beautiful Sunday...


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

I know, jem!!! I did the math several times just because I couldn't believe it. And T.O. said that the fact it's a 144" long and the fact that it's in such good condition (a few tiny brown stains but no tears at all -- it's actually very *strong*) *adds* to the $2...she couldn't give a full appraisal, but she will in February, evidently. She's got over a hundred people in her queue and isn't taking any more until then; I was just very lucky that she so generously gave me the brief version to tide me over : )

I was thinking Antiques Road Show too...I just checked, though, and see that they're done for the year.

And yes, the problem...I do wonder what the most highly-regarded venue for such a piece is, where I could see the best return. I figure T.O. is highly-regarded herself, pretty much the standard for reputable lace appraisal, **and whom for some reason I hadn't found until Linda hadn't posted that link--THANK YOU, LINDA!** so she wouldn't have put such a figure out without it being realistic. Any ideas, warnings, etc. would be most gratefully accepted! I'm not going to rush this.


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Wrap it well and acid free, and take out a short term insurance rider on it....just as you would a nice diamond ring.
Think you may have to sell it to someone in either a museum or with an unlimited supply of $$....like an Arab sheik!


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

I actually had ordered some wedding-gown acid free preservation tissue a couple of weeks ago, and we wrapped it in some yesterday. DH is on the rider (that's the part he can comprehend : )) and, re the sheik: who do you know? (I'm thinking mtnrdredux might be interested ; ))


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

And of course I forgot I'd mentioned the paper...too much going on around the house right now. Should read my own darn thread before I post!


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

I read thru this and this is really interesting. I had lots of old linens from my grandmother that I did not pay much attention to.

As far as looking for a buyer, do you mean Sheik, or Wall Street financier?


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Ha...my daughter keeps saying "but it's just a tablecloth!" And I tell her that it's thousands of hours of surgical-level work by women who almost never got the credit they should have.

My Armenian grandmother made lace -- I never met her but I have a few small pieces she did and I think from looking at them as a child, and imagining what her life as an unappreciated, abused woman who gave birth to 13 children who still sat and made such intensely focused beauty...it made me feel an instant kind of emotional bond with good lace when I see it.

There is a world of difference in the way this comes across vs. say Battenburg, much less anything machine made. It just Spoke to me from the shelf. I have to say I keep feeling slightly bad for the grandkids who obviously weren't sensitive to this piece's 'voice', as it were, and I hope you're not one of those, that maybe the pieces you saw and passed by weren't of this quality.

All that said, I'm not going to rush to a sale, but ultimately I can't keep it. Our family can use that kind of money more than I need one nice thing to look at and ponder.


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Is there a museum nearby that displays textiles or handmade items? I once saw a quilt displayed at a museum and shop near Ashville, NC. The price tag on the quilt was $800.


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

I was thinking...the best that might come of this is to donate it to a museum and get the museum to verify the appraiser's value...just take the deduction and call it a day. Then I know it will be taken care of, at least, and I don't have to go through the hassle of selling it. Although I'm not too sure about this place...

Here is a link that might be useful: scroll to the doll exhibit; you *know* they rushed back to their places around 6:30 am...


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

That tablecloth is the sort of thing you see on First Dibs ... it's definitely looking for a rich buyer.


 o
RE: Lindac? or anyone--? re Antique Lace tablecloth-

Hm, lazygardens...I went there just now and found the first two tablecloths I've ever seen there--thanks for the lead.


 o Post a Follow-Up

Please Note: Only registered members are able to post messages to this forum.

    If you are a member, please log in.

    If you aren't yet a member, join now!


Return to the Antiques & Collectibles Forum

Information about Posting

  • You must be logged in to post a message. Once you are logged in, a posting window will appear at the bottom of the messages. If you are not a member, please register for an account.
  • Posting is a two-step process. Once you have composed your message, you will be taken to the preview page. You will then have a chance to review your post, make changes and upload photos.
  • After posting your message, you may need to refresh the forum page in order to see it.
  • Before posting copyrighted material, please read about Copyright and Fair Use.
  • We have a strict no-advertising policy!
  • If you would like to practice posting or uploading photos, please visit our Test forum.
  • If you need assistance, please Contact Us and we will be happy to help.


Learn more about in-text links on this page here