http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/antiques/msg0921290130082.html?11

I have lightly sanded off what appears to be a poorly done more recent shellac with an amber cast, this shellac encased some earlier damage. I don't believe the original finish was amber. No new damage was done with sanding.

Here is where I am now - pictures below. I don't know whether to just recoat with blonde shellac at this point, or to just paint with high quality paint because of the damage pictured. I am not sure how to fill in the damage, if I paint, I may just paint over it. I am also not quite sure of choice of coatings - brands and types.

The style would look good painted or refinished. The purpose is my infant daughter's room, and I am hoping this to be her long term furniture, i.e. I don't intend on a baby furniture look, rather a classic look. There are two other pieces not pictured, a night table and vanity (which is in the linked post), but my first concern is being able to put her clothes away, and have a functional guest bed.

All comments are welcome... Thank-you all!!

Tall Dresser post sanding, still dusty

Tall Dresser damage

Tall Dresser Damage

Headboard, not sanded, note amber cast

Headboard damage

Headboard Damage

I would simply shellac, lacquer, or varnish it first. Some of the "damage" will disappear. The chipped drawers do not bother me at all.

If you then decide you cannot tolerate the flaws, you could later paint it. The additional layer of shellac would make it easier to strip the paint later, should you change your mind.