Please help me finalize my Kitchen design

animacafeMay 15, 2013

Hi All - I have been reading and researching for weeks and have this narrowed down to three options. The input from everyone here has been invaluable so I hope you don't mind lending your opinions!

First - We are a family of three - two 6'+ adults and one tall 10 year old. We also have one black lab / hound mix dog.

I have made a decision on appliances: Wolf 6 burner range, 36" Broan professional style canopy hood with 1200 cfm external blower, 42" SZ SxS, GE Monogram Advantium speed oven and bosch DW.

The existing floor in the kitchen is wide-plank maple, which will stay. Cabinets will be a simple shaker-style in an off-white. Currently there is a wall between the kitchen and dining-room, which will be removed and replaced with a peninsula.

One of my requirements is a place to feed the dog in the kitchen. Either a book-case on the end of the peninsula with cut-outs on the bottom shelf for bowls, or just an alcove / overhang at the end. One design has the peninsula end with table legs.

I have three options - the first is from a custom-cabinet maker. He would do the demo, build cabinets, install the lighting, cabinets, hood ductwork, etc. The construction would be plywood frames with maple cabinets and drawerfronts, dovetail drawers, softclose, etc - no MDF. He seems great but to get in line with budget it would not include roll-out shelves and some of the fancy finishes I hoped for - such as furniture legs on either side of the sink, panelling on the back of the peninsula, dummy doors on the end of cabinet runs etc. Is it difficult to add some of those things later?

He is also recommending no seating at the peninsula - and only a 12 inch overhang of countertop. There is enough width in the DR to accommodate up to 18 inches of overhang from that wall - as there is currently a hutch against it that is 18'' deep. Should I have counter seating or not? The current kitchen is 'eat-in' although we don't eat in it. We always sit at the DR table.

The second one is kraftmaid cabinetry.
I like the idea of the peninsula ending in table legs to tuck the dog's dish under, but am a little concerned about the loss of cabinet space. I also like the idea of the rolling 30" island that is proposed. It would be nice to order it in an accent color. These cabinets would be loaded with all the bells and whistles - roll-outs, soft-close, details etc. It will also cost about $5K more.

And the last is a design provided by an architect who also represents several cabinet lines.

They each have their strengths and weaknesses. How would you choose? Any suggestions are welcome.

For context - my existing kitchen only has cabinets on two walls and feels very closed-in. Opening the wall to the DR will incorporate light from three large double-hung windows.

I am very ready for this phase to be over - but don't want to do it if it isn't going to be right.

Thank you all in advance for your feedback!

PS: To add a little more context - here is the surrounding layout of the house around the kitchen -

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

If the extra cost would not be a great problem I'd say 2nd alternative.

I guess the 30' island 'll compensate for a part of the loss of cab space on the peninsula.

Does the price include countertop cost? Since you eat in the DR, if you don't need a deep countertop for any other reason, maybe having no extra overhang on the DR side of the peninsula may help economize on countertop cost and I think rolling island will have a lighter(and cheaper) countertop.

    Bookmark   May 16, 2013 at 7:30AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thanks Sena01, I appreciate the input. I think I like the table-leg solution best for hiding dog dishes too.

Would the absence of an 'eat-in' kitchen become a concern if or when we go to sell the house? I don't have any plans to move and could be here 'forever' (its already been 13 years), but you never know.

    Bookmark   May 16, 2013 at 9:04AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

"Would the absence of an 'eat-in' kitchen become a concern if or when we go to sell the house? "

From what I read in the forums it appears that it may be a problem if you decide to sell the house.-((

    Bookmark   May 16, 2013 at 11:35AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Kathy Rivera

We are working with very similar issues/designs, so I feel your pain!

The EIK's something I am struggling with. My realtor said I needed to keep it. But it makes my work area so small and not useful. So I am opening to the DR and having a breakfast bar. I'm hoping the open space and functional kitchen will be what people see and not the fact they can't stick a kitchen table there. Besides, the counter gives a space to eat breakfast/lunch, do homework, socialize with guests - all things a table can do. But it took me a loooooong time to decide to go this direction.

I would say you need to keep seating at the bar to make up for the lost EIK.

I like the KM design. I think I'd switch the fridge and the oven (do it as shown in the architect's rendition) - you aren't gong to be able to open the right fridge door all the way where it is. I'd also loose the island. You don't really have the space to support it - th aisles will be very narrow and it's so small, it's not going to be that helpful. That can save you money and you can add one at another time. There are tons of nice work table/islands you can purchase - it doesn't need to match the cabs. This was also something I struggled with b/c I felt the space was a little too open without it, but everyone here convinced me to leave it out and if I find I do want something there, go for the work table.

To save money you can also do furniture/particle board cabs - most everyone here agrees it's a great way to save about 15% on cabinets! Also, GW is the land of drawers! Ditch the cabs with rollouts and go for drawers. Easier to pullout one thing than to open doors and then pull out. Though probably won't save much $$ b/c I was told cabs with rollouts are about the same cost wise as all drawer bases.

The architect drawing - did he give you a price? His plan is very similar to the KM plan and you could just ask him to do furniture legs on the end for the dog bowls - every line carries something like that. He might be able to get you a better deal on another line (or he might not!)

Good luck! I am at the same point as you right now so I know how frustrating it is! I go back to my KD tomorrow to make some tweaks and see if I'm ready to take the plunge!

    Bookmark   May 16, 2013 at 2:07PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thanks KathyNY76! Your comments are really helpful. I had mixed feelings about the rolling island and keep thinking it will just be in the way. I love all the 'gadgety' cabinet interiors that are available today and was wondering whether they are really worth it - or whether I can add them later with rev-a-shelf or other modules for less.

My only concern with the KM layout is it doesn't have an angled cabinet on the fridge run next to the door, and I wonder if that will make the entry feel like an odd little tunnel with no transition into the room - or whether it will be fine since it is only standard counter-depth.

It is so hard to make these decisions on paper! I have been having nightmares that once I have made all the decisions and the kitchen is in - it won't be anything like what I expect it to be. This is a very stressful process.

Good luck tomorrow!

    Bookmark   May 16, 2013 at 5:50PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Kitchen window or no?
We are planning our new home. I am a difficult time...
What do you think of the deeper Ikea wall cabinets?
To me, it would seem that 15" deep is excessive....
Unsealed leathered Virginia Mist?
My Virginia Mist/Jet Mist counters are installed and...
Week 41: As we head into spring, what would you do to make space?
Tomorrow is March 1st. We can really, no longer say...
Kitchen cracking in back panels
We had brand new white shaker cabinets installed in...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™