A couple of vinyl replacement window questions

giantcrazyOctober 28, 2011

After a lot of searching, I'm coming down to a decision on my vinyl window replacements. I've had estimates from Great Lakes, Alside, Gorell and Okna distributors and gone back and forth on how I'm going to do this (my original budget was $9k - I've gone up and down from there with every passing estimate).

It looks like i'm settling in on the Okna 800 - more than I wanted to spend for 20+ DH, but I want to do this job once and not have to repeat it in the next 15-20 years if possible.

The few questions I have remaining:

- Of the window brands I listed, does this appear to be the best of the bunch? Gorell and Okna priced close, GL a little higher, Alside at the bottom.

- Three installers came, all highly regarded. Two claimed that they would add foam fiberglass insulation to the capping, the third claimed that there wasn't enough room for insulation but that caulking would stop any air intrusion around the frame. This sounds off to me, since I know caulk's usable lifespan is less than the window's (hopefully).

- Do I want triple-pane glass? I know it's more expensive, but I've read positives and negatives (positive = greater energy savings, negative = less ambient light passing through). I care about both, but it's hard for me to quantify what the energy savings would be from double to triple pane (I know the U numbers, which are Chinese to me), and I know I'm paying more and losing light. I'm leaning towards double pane, but not sure if that's the right approach.

- Does adding a color to the window frame increase the cost? I'm primarily working with the last installer I spoke to now, as they had more recommendations from people I know, so I hate to go out and ask the rest if I'm likely just wasting their time, but is it a universal that all window makers charge more for coloring the vinyl, or do some charge and not others (and hope springs eternal, everyone gives it for free?)

I've asked these guys every conceivable question, from do you cart away your mess to what the warranty is, are there any questions that aren't intuitive that I should ask before I sign on the dotted line?


Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Should add - as for the energy efficiency questions, I'm in NYC.

    Bookmark   October 28, 2011 at 4:08PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

The Okna 800 is a great window. Adding color to the exterior definitely adds more money.. Yes, if the gap is too narrow then caulk around window is fine.

    Bookmark   October 28, 2011 at 5:27PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thanks mmarse!

I think I'm almost there, just haven't fully figured out whether I should get the triple pane windows or not. I've well exceeded my budget at this point, but I want to be absolutely sure I get the best windows I can at this price point and not just miss out because of 10-15% at the end.

I'm concerned because I've read in some places that triple pane with certain coatings can result in a loss of ambient light, something I don't want to do (especially since the glass area is reducing in size going from my existing windows to these).

    Bookmark   October 31, 2011 at 11:03AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Whether Triple Pane glass is a good option depends on the additional cost and where you live. Prices on TP have come down over the years and I expect they will continue to fall as more manufacturers get involved in the R-5 Window program. The problem in the past is that the additional investment in the necessary equipment to produce a TP window has been expensive and so manufacturers charged a premium rate. So whether it makes sense depends largely on how much more and how long you plan on living in the house.

While TP does produce a more energy efficient window, the trade off is that you will have a lower Solar Gain in the winter and also reduced Visible Light or VT. It may very well be that it makes more sense to use TP on the North, East and West elevations and then use Double Pane on the South.

Okna makes an excellent window as does Gorell. I would base my decision between the 2 on which company you think will do a better job. If you think the both will do great, then I would look at the aesthetics and the total cost.

I would also ask if they are using krypton or argon gas between the panes. Krypton is preferable but it also comes with a higher price tag. Savings % will vary depending on where you live but keep in mind that although the difference in energy efficiency between a TP with kyypton at a U-factor of .15 and a DP with argon at .29 is nearly 50%, that does NOT mean the window will reduce your heating and cooling costs by that much. Depending on where you live, I would not expect to see much more than approx 10%-15% difference in utility costs between the two.

    Bookmark   October 31, 2011 at 11:36AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Windows on Washington

Sky is 100% correct. I would always try to get the absolute most efficient window that I could get but there are several factors that bear consideration.

At a U-Factor of 0.26 of the Okna 800 Deluxe, that is very near where most of the triple pane argon numbers are for the Gorell.

I don't think the Krypton is worth the additional investment in most cases as there are other locations in the home that can be upgraded and have a much better ROI when you examine their impact on utilities.

You have a couple of really good windows up for comparison there and as long as you pick a good installer, you can't really go wrong. If I had to choose, I like the Okna 800 better for its better thermal, air, and structural numbers, but both are stellar windows.

    Bookmark   October 31, 2011 at 8:19PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Thanks skydawggy and WoW.

The installer part of the question is out of the equation - the same installer sells both Okna and Gorell, and they come recommended with generally good feedback on the Internet.

The pricing he gave me was close, with the Gorell 5300 coming to be about 10% more than the Okna 800. To be honest, I didn't see much of a difference between the two but little features like the locks intended to let you keep the windows slightly open for ventilation but still secured as well as the metal lift made the difference for me.

The figures I got were for triple pane, argon filled gas. The salesperson advised that krypton was a lot more expensive and didn't merit the extra cost (in terms of recouping investment over the lifetime of the windows).

I hate the light loss that the TP glass will provide (WoW was kind enough to provide me those figures on another forum, thanks again!), but I can live with it if it makes it easier to cool the house in the summer. The next upgrade to the house is a mini-split AC system, which I'm hoping together with the window upgrades and some insulation and painting on the roof will make a big dent in my heating/cooling bill over the next year.

    Bookmark   November 1, 2011 at 11:32AM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Requesting feedback re: interior bronze window frames
My home is a small (1500 sq. ft.) contemporary with...
Fiberglass Windows from Hardie????
We need to replace 3 windows in our family room. ...
What size windows - 10' + Cathedral Ceiling
I like the look of the hearth room pictured below....
wood window restoring in Nova
I live in a cedar home with big wood casement windows....
Gigantic skylight needs replacing
A windstorm wisked away the living room skylight in...
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™