New Pool Build Help/Thoughts/Advice - Total Novice Here!!

ferkityferkAugust 3, 2012

HI! Been lurking here a few weeks now and decided to post. Everyone is so friendly and helpful so I'm hoping someone can help us out.

We just began the quote process for a new pool and are so confused. Salt water? Chlorine? Heater types, etc. Any advice is greatly appreciated. Here is our basic info and quote. Bear with me cause I am just retyping their info from their proposal.


550 sq ft custom concrete pool

50 ft. spa

Goldline Salt Water Generator (includes salt)

Hayward 400K BTU Natural Gas Heater

Ecostar Custom variable Speed Pump


1/2" steel rods in all beams in floor and walls on 12" centers

In the bond beams 1/2" steel rods will be placed on 6" centers (This protects the upper portion of your pool from frost damage)

Concrete shell 4000psi at 28 days of curing

top 24" of pool wall (frost beam) will be installed at 12"

Lifetime warranty on shell

Sub base of pool will be covered in crushed stone

Hydrostatic relief plugs installed - minimum of 2 common to have 3-4 for this size pool

Heater, filter and pumps set on solid concrete slabs

2 Hayward skimmers (sp10712s) and 3 wall returns, plus the cleaner return line

Anti-vortex double bottom drain in deep end with drain covers.

plumbing will be schedule 40 chemically sealed at all joints for max lifetime durability

1 Hayward Colorlogic LED light

Spa will have matching LED hayward light as well.

6"x6" row of frost proof tile installed below coping

12" custom travertine bullnose coping (double bullnose at the spa)

they will seal coping with a 31% solid base sealer for protection and look

Polaris 280 automatic cleaner that runs off a 3/4 booster pump

or i can choose the Polaris 9300 robotic cleaner which is electric and runs independent of pool filtration system

SPA - 50 sq ft raised 12" and tile faced with double bullnosed coping. 8 jets including one in 12" damn wall

Includes: dual elevation bench, 2HP Hayward North Star booster pump, double bottom drain (36" separation)

We will plumb the spa suction/return with 2" pvc as standard

wireless waterproof POD remote

Electrical work will be 1" conduit and they will bring 50 amps to the Goldline PS8 electronic panel to operate the complete system

Electrical work to included approx 200' of underground pipe work. Includes all bonding.

Patio/Decking - 350 sq. ft aggregate concrete decking. White expansion joints, subcompact base with roller and tamping device.

Custom skimmer lids.


Little bigger pool at 600 sq. ft with 50 sq ft spa (does not include water, but Company A does)


400,000 BTU Jandy gas fired heater or we could do the Aqua Cal electric heat pump for $1800 more (is this worth it? my husband likes a warm pool and hot spa but we are in full sun all day)

ECO pool system with FROG (heard the FROG was pointless)

Polaris 360 pool cleaner

500 sq ft concrete aggregate decking

NOT SALT WATER (i can change this though but not sure yet how much it will cost)

2 full days of rock excavating (which we need here) free (above company charges extra $2500 per day)

12 year platinum equipment warranty- this is not pro-rated

Comes with deluxe cleaner with heavy duty vacuum and telescoping pole,leaf skimmer, wall brush, safety rope, floats, complete water testing kit and $200 gift card to their retail stores

Differences from Company A quote:

This company uses 2 wall returns. 3 solar recirculating floor returns and a separately plumbed MDX debris removal main drain system which will feed pool water into a Jandy Stealth 2 HP self-priming pump where it then will be pumped through a Jandy vertical grid diatomaceous earth filter (WHAT???)

All above ground piping will be 2" schedule 40PVC piping

Poos and spa is 2" schedule 40PVC

All joints will be chemically welded for max strength

Aquabrite ecofinish with a 10 year warranty

1 Jandy LED light

custom 6 ft bench

6' swimout in deep end with corner step

SPA: deluxe series hydrotherapy 50 sq ft raised beam spa which will be a monolithic portion of the pool structure

1-1/2 HP spa air blower

6 hydro therapy jets, MDX safety and anti-vortex main drain assembly, 100W quartz halogen light, bench seat and corner step

tile damn wall will separate the pool from spa

Hope you are still with me. Sorry this is so long but we are loving the warranty with Company B and love their sales guy. He really sat with us and we felt most comfortable with him and he just did my cousin's pool. I just need info/advice on the equipment and other confusing stuff. Should we do salt water. Its what we want but then we heard it can corrode the decking. I'm assuming Company B pushes their pools with chlorine so they are making lots of after sale chemical profits.

Thanks so much for reading and for the advice.

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo

Company A has chemically sealed Schedule 40? LOL. That means they are glued and normal. Just make sure it's all hard pipe.

Put 2.5" suction on the drains. Especially important for the spa.

By keeping the returns open a little, a separate pool return in the spa can be eliminated as well as the dedicated 2 HP pump. Just use the pool pump for the spa. Its can go up to 2 HP also.

If they bring in a heat pump, they'll more amps brought in.

Company B likes to glue their plumbing fittings too! Shocking! You might think its an industry standard, And you'd be right! Heheh.

Same issue with the drains, go to 2.5" pipes.

Why only 6 jets?

Why not an E-Pump? Only the spa will need it. The pump is normally slowed and run a little longer so it saves power in pool circulation.

How big is the DE filter?

I don't see that there is a controller.

Since you're lighting it, putting in color LED fixtures in makes sense. Why is the 100W quartz in the spa and not a colored LED?

A 12 year warranty has to be specific to them. Find out ahead of time what isn't covered.

Both companies:
Salt it. Its easiest to care for.


    Bookmark   August 4, 2012 at 7:15PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
Small 3/4' mosaic waterline tile - mistake?
Hello, We're getting ready to sign our contract, and...
How to film pool build timelapse?
I've been lurking for months & finally ready to...
Wendy Baldwin
Need help with sealing gunite to rock, and black alge
Hey friends! I purchased a house last summer in Houston,...
Klint Turney
HELP!! Pool color and pricing with Pebbletec
Help please and fast!! When we started our pool I told...
Atlantis pool and spa (Magnolia Tx) anyone have any feedback?
Searching for a pool builder and looks like Atlantis...
Sponsored Products
Tribeca Outdoor Sofa Cover
$124.50 | FRONTGATE
Mitchell Loveseat - Key Largo Graphite Brown
Joybird Furniture
Cuadro Rug by Mat-The-Basics
$323.00 | Lumens
Trellis Hearts Giclee Glow 16"W Bronze Pendant Chandelier
Lamps Plus
Reflection Shine Rug 5' x 8' - IVORY/TAUPE
$529.00 | Horchow
Ivory Floral Diamond Wool Rug
$99.99 | zulily
Z-Bar Mini LED Desk Lamp
Darlee Monterey Swivel Bar Stool - 301110-7
$359.99 | Hayneedle
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™