recommendations for a new heater

amyhlrJuly 22, 2014

I'm looking to replace my 375,000 BTU Laars Lite heater, which is now 13 years old. I am tired of spending $200-$400 per season attemping to repair it, which we have done every year since 2005. I haven't shopped for heaters since 2001, so I have no idea what's out there. My pool is a 17x35 oval with a chlorinated system and sand filter. We live in New Jersey and use the pool May to September.
What heaters have you been happy with? What would you recommend for us?

Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
mongoct

I have a Raypak 400k ASME heater. Propane. It is not a Nox model. Copper HX. I tried to buy it local but the local Raypak reseller refused to order me an ASME heater, saying I didn't need it. Well, that might be true. But I wanted it. lol.

Because of the troubles I had with the old Pentair, I wanted something a little more durable, and maybe a little bit better built, even if durable in this case was in the eye of the purchaser (me) and not anything tangible. So I ordered it online and swapped it out myself. Paid roughly $1800. Installation was pretty easy to do.

It replaced a Pentair minimax 400k unit that was nothing but trouble.

I've had the Raypak in now for several years. Maybe five? Pretty user friendly regarding maintenance, all I've really had to do is winterize it and then open it up in the spring. Haven't had to replace any parts.

I'm in CT, my season goes from April through November. Pool is 20' by 40', about 20k gallons, liquid chlorine, and I have a Pentair Quad DE filter and a Pentair VS pump. I installed the Quad DE last year and the VS pump this year. I'm thrilled with the pump (saves big money over my old single speed pump).

The filter is great, I got the Quad DE 100, which is "oversized" for my pool. But I don't have to clean it at all during the swimming season. Only when I close the pool down in the fall.

I use the heater more for the side spa than for the pool.

    Bookmark   July 25, 2014 at 5:57PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Froogle_Pool_and_Spa

I would tend to agree with mongoct. As far as durability is concerned Raypak is the way to go. They do have two different types one being for the "residential" and the other being for "commercial" pools. The ASME version as stated above is the latter. They look almost identical with the only differences being the headers (ASME version has cast iron headers and the non-ASME has Capron plastic headers), and the heat exchanger inside the unit itself is 50% thicker copper on the ASME version.

The durability is definitely higher on the Raypak ASME model versus the other non-ASME heaters out there. Pentair, Hayward, and Jandy all have ASME versions of their heaters, however, if you're going to spend the money on a ASME heater I would say go Raypak.

Hope this helps!

    Bookmark   July 26, 2014 at 6:48PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
amyhlr

Thanks for the feedback. We visited the pool store over the weekend to learn more about heaters. I don't think we need the NOX heater, since we don't live in Texas or California. I'm not sure if we will get the ASME or the standard heater, copper or cupro nickel heat exchanger. Does anyone have an opinion about copper vs cupro nickel?

    Bookmark   August 5, 2014 at 6:04PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
mattw22

I would agree Raypak makes one of the most durable heaters. I had one for 15 years and just replaced it a few years ago. I would recommend you at least get the ASME version of the heater for the small price difference.

I have cupro- nickel. I felt it was worth the price difference. But it all depends on your water chemistry and hardness.

    Bookmark   August 11, 2014 at 3:54AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
mongoct

If you take care of your water then Cu should be fine. I have Cu. If you're sloppier about water chemistry, if your maintenance is intermittent, if you have kids peeing in the pool or perspiring adults in the hot tub every night and you're always chasing balanced water, then cupro nickel could give you better performance.

But I also use 12% liquid chlorine to chlorinate my pool.

If you have a SWG, or are considering instaling one in the future, SWGs can up the total dissolved solids in the pool. When you have high TDS water coursing through the heat exchanger at high flow rates, it can erode the Copper.

Cupro-nickel could be worth going with if you have a SWG or if your have difficult water chemistry.

    Bookmark   August 11, 2014 at 6:44PM
Sign Up to comment
More Discussions
I will answer pool plaster questions
For 23 years I was in the swimming pool plaster industry...
poolplasterexpert
Exceptional Pool Builders who build in Cleveland, OH area?
My wife and I are beginning the design stage of our...
jc_ufl
should pool building take this long??
I signed a contract July 19th with Mr. Carlos pools....
animallover5
Obsessing over pool finishes
Hello all, I am looking for any and all advice on pool...
megankheaps
Remounting aluminum track for a cover in a salt water pool
I've got a CoverPools automatic cover for my saltwater...
nick_shirley
Sponsored Products
Empire Star Indoor/Outdoor Rug 3'5" x 5'5" - LIME
$199.00 | Horchow
Angela Outdoor Club Chair
Grandin Road
Horse Play British Champion Equestrian Set - 85050-0PWM-1301
$24.99 | Hayneedle
Moda Rectangle Lace Chrome Two-Light 14-Inch Pendant with Royal Cut Sapphire Blu
$640.00 | Bellacor
Mosaic Tile: MS International Building Materials Greecian White 12 in. x 12 in.
$10.97 | Home Depot
Quantum Stainless Steel 13-Light Clear Spectra Crystal Pendant Light, 35.5W x 9H
Bellacor
Nu-Flame Incendio Tabletop Fireplace - NF-T1INO
$79.00 | Hayneedle
Oran Greek Key Flatweave Rug 3'6" x 5'6" - BLACK
$229.00 | Horchow
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™